Tackling the dimensions in imaging genetics with CLUB-PLS

André Altmann, Ana C. Lawry Aguila, Neda Jahanshad, Paul M. Thompson, Marco LorenziarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In the burgeoning field of imaging genetics, researchers seek to map the intricate relationship between our genetic blueprint and the structural architecture of the human brain. However, this pursuit is frequently hindered by a massive "dimensionality" bottleneck. Traditional methods often struggle to process the sheer volume of data generated by modern biobanks, which include millions of genetic markers and complex neuroimaging phenotypes. To address these challenges, researchers have developed CLUB-PLS (CLUster Bootstrap Partial Least Squares), a scalable multivariate framework designed to identify genetic influences on the brain that traditional, one-variable-at-a-time studies often overlook.

The Limitations of Mass Univariate Approaches

The standard methodology in this field is the mass univariate Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS). This approach tests the relationship between every single genetic marker (SNP) and every single brain measurement (such as the volume of a specific region) independently. While robust, this method faces two significant flaws:

  1. Narrow Scope: Univariate tests require researchers to pre-define specific brain regions of interest. If a genetic effect is distributed across multiple regions or influences global brain symmetry, a univariate test may fail to detect the signal entirely.
  2. Computational Constraints: As datasets grow to include tens of thousands of participants (such as the UK Biobank) and millions of SNPs, the memory required to analyze these matrices simultaneously exceeds the capacity of standard computing infrastructure.

Methodology: The CLUB-PLS Framework

CLUB-PLS solves these issues by integrating three key computational pillars:

  • Partial Least Squares (PLS): Unlike GWAS, PLS is a multivariate technique that analyzes the entire "block" of genetic data and the entire "block" of imaging data simultaneously. It identifies linear combinations—or patterns—in both datasets that exhibit maximum covariance.
  • Meta-PLS for Scalability: To manage the memory load of massive datasets, the authors implemented a federated approach. The data is partitioned into 66 smaller "chunks" (clusters) of approximately 500 subjects each. Each chunk is processed locally, and the results are aggregated into a global solution, bypassing the memory limits of processing 33,000 subjects at once.
  • Cluster Bootstrap for Statistical Rigor: Standard PLS does not inherently provide $p$-values. The authors utilized a "cluster bootstrap" method, repeatedly sampling the 66 data chunks with replacement. This allows for the calculation of robust statistics and significance levels for every genetic marker and brain feature without the prohibitive computational overhead of a traditional subject-level bootstrap.

Experimental Design and Data

The framework was validated using data from the UK Biobank (UKB), comprising:

  • N = 33,070 subjects of Central European ancestry.
  • Genetic Data: 582,538 autosomal single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs).
  • Imaging Data: 132 regional measures derived from T1-weighted MRI, specifically 66 regions for Surface Area (SA) and 66 for Cortical Thickness (CT).

Key Insights and Biological Relevance

One of the most significant findings was that the primary "component" identified by CLUB-PLS for both surface area and thickness represented global brain size and thickness. Traditional GWAS often fails to highlight these overarching patterns because of its focus on localized regions.

Furthermore, the method identified 107 genome-wide significant locus-phenotype pairs associated with 386 different genes. These were not merely statistical artifacts; the results pointed to well-known biological drivers of neurodevelopment and disease. For instance, the study linked specific loci to the MAPT gene (associated with Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases) and PAFAH1B1 (a gene essential for brain development).

Validation and Results

To ensure the reliability of the framework, the researchers compared their results to traditional GWAS and a method known as GWIS. 85 out of the 107 pairs were successfully validated, reaching at least a "suggestive" significance threshold in traditional tests. This confirms that CLUB-PLS identifies real, reproducible biological signals. Additionally, the study found that genetic correlations were generally higher for surface area (Pearson’s $r$ up to 0.184) than for cortical thickness (up to 0.118), suggesting that surface area may be more strongly influenced by common genetic variants.

Limitations and Future Directions

While CLUB-PLS represents a significant step forward, the authors noted several areas for future development. This proof-of-concept utilized brain regions (ROIs) rather than "vertex-level" data, which treats the brain surface as a high-resolution mesh. Although the underlying mathematics of PLS can handle vertex-level data, regional analysis was chosen here to simplify validation. Future iterations may also incorporate denser, imputed genetic data for finer mapping.

Beyond neuroimaging, CLUB-PLS is a general-purpose tool. It holds potential for any research scenario requiring the correlation of two high-dimensional datasets, such as linking complex lesion maps to cognitive performance or multi-omic data to clinical outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

A major challenge in imaging genetics and similar fields is to link high-dimensional data in one domain, e.g., genetic data, to high dimensional data in a second domain, e.g., brain imaging data. The standard approach in the area are mass univariate analyses across genetic factors and imaging phenotypes. That entails executing one genome-wide association study (GWAS) for each pre-defined imaging measure. Although this approach has been tremendously successful, one shortcoming is that phenotypes must be pre-defined. Consequently, effects that are not confined to pre-selected regions of interest or that reflect larger brain-wide patterns can easily be missed. In this work we introduce a Partial Least Squares (PLS)-based framework, which we term Cluster-Bootstrap PLS (CLUB-PLS), that can work with large input dimensions in both domains as well as with large sample sizes. One key factor of the framework is to use cluster bootstrap to provide robust statistics for single input features in both domains. We applied CLUB-PLS to investigating the genetic basis of surface area and cortical thickness in a sample of 33,000 subjects from the UK Biobank. We found 107 genome-wide significant locus-phenotype pairs that are linked to 386 different genes. We found that a vast majority of these loci could be technically validated at a high rate: using classic GWAS or Genome-Wide Inferred Statistics (GWIS) we found that 85 locus-phenotype pairs exceeded the genome-wide suggestive (P<1e-05) threshold.
BibTeX
@misc{altmann2023tackling,
  author = {André Altmann and Ana C. Lawry Aguila and Neda Jahanshad and Paul M. Thompson and Marco Lorenzi},
  title = {{Tackling the dimensions in imaging genetics with CLUB-PLS}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2309.07352},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07352},
}
Figure