T2S2G: A Novel Two-Tier Secure Smart Grid Architecture to Protect Network Measurements

Israa T. Aziz, Hai Jin, Ihsan H. Abdulqadder, Sabah M. Alturfi, Wisam H. Alobaidi, Firas M. F. FlaihEnergies 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces T2S2G, a novel two-tier architecture for smart grids that enhances security against False Data Injection (FDI) attacks. By employing distributed state estimation and a multi-layered security approach, T2S2G significantly reduces computational overhead while improving detection accuracy and measurement protection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Smart Grids (SGs) are increasingly complex systems that rely heavily on accurate data for efficient operation and control. However, this reliance makes them vulnerable to False Data Injection (FDI) attacks, where attackers subtly alter measurements from sensors (like smart meters) to disrupt grid operations or compromise system integrity. Existing solutions often depend on centralized State Estimation (SE), which is computationally intensive and can become a bottleneck. Furthermore, many methods focus on detecting modified data but fail to identify compromised meters themselves, leaving a critical security gap. This paper aims to address these limitations by proposing a more efficient, distributed, and comprehensive security framework.

Methods

The T2S2G architecture is built on a two-tier system:

  • Tier 1: Measurement Collection and Distributed State Estimation
    • System Partitioning (WQT): The SG is divided into four sections using a Weighted Quad Tree (WQT) method. This partitioning is crucial for enabling distributed SE.
  • Measurement Encryption (PEECC): Data from Remote Terminal Units (RTUs) is encrypted using a Parallel Enhanced Elliptic Curve Cryptography (PEECC) algorithm. This ensures data integrity during transmission.
  • Distributed State Estimation (APSO): Each section has an aggregator that performs SE using an Amended Particle Swarm Optimization (APSO) algorithm. APSO is designed to minimize estimation error and computational overhead compared to traditional PSO.
  • Tier 2: Aggregator Authentication and Compromised Meter Detection
    • Aggregator Authentication (LSA): Aggregators are authenticated at the Control Server (CS) using a Logical Schedule Based Authentication (LSA) scheme, ensuring only legitimate data sources are processed.
  • Compromised Meter Detection (FNN): The CS uses a Fuzzy with Neural Network (FNN) algorithm to classify measurements. This algorithm considers error levels, similarity, and trust levels to identify malicious measurements and subsequently compromised meters/buses.

Datasets

The paper utilizes the IEEE-9 bus system for simulation and evaluation. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distributed SE is Key: Moving away from centralized SE is crucial for scalability and efficiency in modern SGs, especially when dealing with security threats.
  • Layered Security Works: Combining encryption, distributed estimation, robust authentication, and intelligent classification provides a more resilient defense than any single method.
  • APSO for Efficient SE: The proposed APSO algorithm offers a significant reduction in estimation error compared to existing methods, which is vital for accurate FDI detection.
  • FNN for Comprehensive Detection: The FNN's ability to analyze multiple metrics (error, similarity, trust) allows for the detection of not just data manipulation but also the compromised sources themselves.
  • WQT for Smart Partitioning: The WQT method provides a structured way to partition the grid, facilitating the distributed SE process effectively.

Key Results

The proposed T2S2G system demonstrated significant improvements across several metrics:

  • Estimation Error: Reduced by 0.6% compared to parallel SE, with an average error of 0.014 p.u.
  • Protected Measurements: The PEECC algorithm protected approximately 85% of measurements (300 out of 350).
  • Detection Probability: Achieved 90% detection probability, a 9% improvement over the sparse method.
  • Successful Detection Rate: Identified 88% of attackers/compromised meters, a 20% improvement over the quickest detection method.
  • Detection Delay: Minimized to 1.95 ms, a significant reduction from the 6.5 ms observed in the quickest method.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the T2S2G system can be further extended. Future work includes:

  • Integrating More Attack Detection Mechanisms: Exploring additional methods to defend against a wider range of attacks, particularly those targeting SCADA systems.
  • Diverse Conditions: Evaluating the system's performance under more varied and complex operational conditions.
  • Further Investigation: Extending research into energy consumption, measurement computation, and communication overhead to optimize the system further.

Summary updated

Abstract

False data injection (FDI) attacks are a major security threat to smart grid (SG) communication systems. In FDI attacks, the attacker has the ability of modifying the measurements transmitted by smart grid entities such as smart meters, buses, etc. Many solutions have been proposed to mitigate FDI attacks in the SG. However, most of these solutions rely on centralized state estimation (SE), which is computationally expensive. To engulf this problem in FDI attack detection and to improve security of SGs, this paper proposes novel two-tier secure smart grid (T2S2G) architecture with distributed SE. In T2S2G, measurement collection and SE are involved in first tier while compromised meter detection is involved in second tier. Initially the overall SG system is divided into four sections by the weighted quad tree (WQT) method. Each section is provided with an aggregator, which is responsible to perform SE. Measurements from power grids are collected by remote terminal units (RTUs) and encrypted using a parallel enhanced elliptic curve cryptography (PEECC) algorithm. Then the measurements are transmitted to the corresponding aggregator. Upon collected measurements, aggregator estimates state using the amended particle swarm optimization (APSO) algorithm in a distributed manner. To verify authenticity of aggregators, each aggregator is authenticated by a logical schedule based authentication (LSA) scheme at the control server (CS). In the CS, fuzzy with a neural network (FNN) algorithm is employed for measurements classification. Our proposed T2S2G shows promising results in the following performance metrics: Estimation error, number of protected measurements, detection probability, successful detection rate, and detection delay.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aziz2019t,
  author = {Israa T. Aziz and Hai Jin and Ihsan H. Abdulqadder and Sabah M. Alturfi and Wisam H. Alobaidi and Firas M. F. Flaih},
  title = {{T2S2G: A Novel Two-Tier Secure Smart Grid Architecture to Protect Network Measurements}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/en12132555},
}
Figure