Systematic Search for VHE Gamma‐Ray Emission from X‐Ray–bright High‐Frequency BL Lac Objects

J. Albert, E. Aliu, H. Anderhub, P. Antoranz, C. Baixeras, J. A. Barrio, H. Bartko, D. Bastieri, J. K. Becker, W. Bednarek, K. Berger, C. Bigongiari, A. Biland, R. K. Böck, P. Bordas, V. Bosch-Ramón, T. Bretz, I. Britvitch, Montaña Cámara, E. Carmona, A. Chilingarian, J. A. Coarasa, S. Commichau, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, M. T. Costado, V. Curtef, V. Danielyan, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, C. Delgado Mendez, R. de los Reyes, B. De Lotto, D. Dorner, M. Doro, M. Errando, M. Fagiolini, D. Ferenc, E. Fernández, R. Firpo, M. V. Fonseca, L. Font, M. Fuchs, N. Galante, R. J. Garcı́a López, M. Garczarczyk, M. Gaug, M. Giller, F. Göebel, D. Hakobyan, M. Hayashida, T. Hengstebeck, A. Herrero, D. Höhne, J. Hose, Stefan Huber, C. C. Hsu, P. Jacoń, T. Jogler, R. Kosyra, D. Kranich, R. Kritzer, A. Laille, E. Lindfors, S. Lombardi, F. Longo, Marcos López, E. Lorenz, P. Majumdar, G. Maneva, K. Mannheim, M. Mariotti, M. Martı́nez, D. Mazin, C. Merck, M. Meucci, M. Meyer, J. M. Miranda, R. Mirzoyan, S. Mizobuchi, A. Moralejo, D. Nieto, K. Nilsson, J. Ninković, E. de Oña Wilhelmi, A. N. Otte, M. Panniello, R. Paoletti, J. M. Paredes, M. Pasanen, D. Pascoli, F. Pauß, R. Pegna, M. Persic, L. Peruzzo, A. Piccioli, E. Prandini, N. Puchades, A. RaymersThe Astrophysical Journal 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a systematic search for very high-energy (VHE) gamma-ray emission from X-ray bright, high-frequency peaked BL Lac objects (HBLs) using the MAGIC telescope. The study detected two new VHE sources, 1ES 1218+304 and 1ES 2344+514, and found that VHE-emitting HBLs do not appear to form a unique subclass based on their multi-frequency spectral properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Astronomers have long been interested in understanding the extreme phenomena powering blazars, particularly the emission of very high-energy (VHE) gamma-rays. While most extragalactic VHE gamma-ray sources detected so far are high-frequency peaked BL Lac objects (HBLs), the exact criteria that make an HBL a VHE emitter were not well-defined. This paper addresses this by conducting a systematic survey of a carefully selected sample of X-ray bright HBLs to identify new VHE emitters and to better characterize the properties of these objects. The challenge lies in the faintness of VHE signals and the absorption of gamma-rays by the intergalactic radiation field, which requires sensitive instruments and careful selection of targets.

Methods

The researchers used the MAGIC telescope, a ground-based imaging atmospheric Cherenkov telescope, for their observations. They selected candidate sources from a compilation of X-ray blazars, focusing on HBLs with specific X-ray flux and redshift criteria (X-ray flux > 2 μJy at 1 keV and redshift z < 0.3). This selection aimed to maximize the chances of detection by targeting bright sources and minimizing gamma-ray absorption. Observations were conducted from December 2004 to March 2006, covering a specific range of declinations. The data analysis involved standard techniques for Cherenkov telescopes, including background subtraction and statistical significance estimation. They also characterized the multi-frequency spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of the sources using optical, archival X-ray, and radio data.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for source selection was the compilation of X-ray blazars by Donato et al. (2001). Observational data were collected by the MAGIC telescope between December 2004 and March 2006. For spectral energy distribution analysis, archival radio and X-ray data were utilized, along with simultaneous optical data from the KVA telescope. The Crab Nebula was used as a calibration source for determining upper limits.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • VHE emitters are not a unique subclass: The study found that HBLs detected at VHE gamma-ray energies do not stand out as a distinct group when their multi-frequency spectral indices are analyzed. This suggests that the conditions for VHE emission might be more widespread within the HBL population than previously thought.
  • X-ray luminosity correlates with VHE emission: There's a tendency for VHE-emitting HBLs to have higher X-ray luminosities, and the ratio of VHE to X-ray luminosity is generally not significantly higher than unity. This implies that the processes responsible for both X-ray and VHE emission are closely linked.
  • Systematic surveys are crucial: This work demonstrates the power of systematic surveys with sensitive instruments like MAGIC to uncover new VHE sources and refine our understanding of astrophysical phenomena.

Key Results

  • Two new VHE sources detected: The survey led to the detection of 1ES 1218+304 (for the first time at VHE) and a strong detection of 1ES 2344+514 in a low flux state. These are in addition to the known bright TeV blazars Mrk 421 and Mrk 501, which were also observed.
  • Marginal detection and confirmation: A marginal excess (3.5 sigma) was observed from 1ES 1011+496, which was later confirmed as a VHE source by subsequent observations.
  • Upper limits set: For the remaining sources, 99% confidence level upper limits on the integral flux above ~200 GeV were established, providing valuable constraints for future studies.
  • Spectral index analysis: The analysis of broad-band spectral indices (radio-to-optical, optical-to-X-ray, and X-ray-to-gamma-ray) revealed no clear distinction between VHE-emitting and non-emitting HBLs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the multi-wavelength data used for SED analysis were not always simultaneous, which can introduce uncertainties due to the inherent variability of blazars. The limited number of detected VHE sources also makes it challenging to definitively characterize the VHE luminosity function of HBLs. Future work could involve more sensitive observations with instruments like the planned MAGIC-II telescope, which will have a lower energy threshold, and all-sky surveys from missions like eROSITA and GLAST to build larger statistical samples for a more robust analysis. Understanding the role of cascade emission from faint point sources and the diffuse extragalactic background will also be important.

Summary updated

Abstract

All but three (M87, BL Lac, and 3C 279) extragalactic sources detected so far at very high energy gamma-rays belong to the class of high-frequency-peaked BL Lac objects. This suggested to us a systematic scan of candidate sources with the MAGIC telescope, based on the Donato et al. compilation of X-ray blazars. The observations took place from 2004 December to 2006 March and cover northern sky sources visible under small zenith distances zd 30 degrees at culmination, constraining the declination to -2 degrees to +58 degrees. The sensitivity of the search was planned for detecting X-ray-bright [F(1 keV) &amp;gt; 2 mu Jy] sources emitting at least the same energy flux at 200 GeV as at 1 keV. To avoid strong gamma-ray attenuation close to the energy threshold, source redshift was constrained to z &amp;lt; 0.3. Of the 14 sources observed, 1ES 1218+304 (for the first time at VHE) and 1ES 2344+514 (strong detection in a low flux state) were detected in addition to the known bright TeV blazars Mrk 421 and Mrk 501. A marginal excess of 3.5 sigma from the position of 1ES 1011+496 was observed and then confirmed as a VHE gamma-ray source by a second MAGIC observation triggered by a high optical state. For the remaining sources, we present 99% c. l. upper limits on the integral flux greater than or similar to 200 GeV. We characterize the HBL sample (including all HBLs detected at VHE so far) by looking for correlations between their multifrequency spectral indices determined from simultaneous optical, archival X-ray, and radio luminosities, finding that VHE-emitting HBLs do not seem to constitute a unique subclass. The HBLs' absorption-corrected gamma-ray luminosities at 200 GeV are generally not higher than their X-ray luminosities at 1 keV.
BibTeX
@article{albert2008systematic,
  author = {J. Albert and E. Aliu and H. Anderhub and P. Antoranz and C. Baixeras and J. A. Barrio and H. Bartko and D. Bastieri and J. K. Becker and W. Bednarek and K. Berger and C. Bigongiari and A. Biland and R. K. Böck and P. Bordas and V. Bosch-Ramón and T. Bretz and I. Britvitch and Montaña Cámara and E. Carmona and A. Chilingarian and J. A. Coarasa and S. Commichau and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and M. T. Costado and V. Curtef and V. Danielyan and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and C. Delgado Mendez and R. de los Reyes and B. De Lotto and D. Dorner and M. Doro and M. Errando and M. Fagiolini and D. Ferenc and E. Fernández and R. Firpo and M. V. Fonseca and L. Font and M. Fuchs and N. Galante and R. J. Garcı́a López and M. Garczarczyk and M. Gaug and M. Giller and F. Göebel and D. Hakobyan and M. Hayashida and T. Hengstebeck and A. Herrero and D. Höhne and J. Hose and Stefan Huber and C. C. Hsu and P. Jacoń and T. Jogler and R. Kosyra and D. Kranich and R. Kritzer and A. Laille and E. Lindfors and S. Lombardi and F. Longo and Marcos López and E. Lorenz and P. Majumdar and G. Maneva and K. Mannheim and M. Mariotti and M. Martı́nez and D. Mazin and C. Merck and M. Meucci and M. Meyer and J. M. Miranda and R. Mirzoyan and S. Mizobuchi and A. Moralejo and D. Nieto and K. Nilsson and J. Ninković and E. de Oña Wilhelmi and A. N. Otte and R. Mirzoyan and M. Panniello and R. Paoletti and J. M. Paredes and M. Pasanen and D. Pascoli and F. Pauß and R. Pegna and M. Persic and L. Peruzzo and A. Piccioli and E. Prandini and N. Puchades and A. Raymers},
  title = {{Systematic Search for VHE Gamma‐Ray Emission from X‐Ray–bright High‐Frequency BL Lac Objects}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1086/587499},
}
Figure