Systematic review and meta-analysis of depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation among Ph.D. students

Emily N. Satinsky, Tomoki Kimura, Mathew V. Kiang, Rediet Abebe, Scott Cunningham, Hedwig Lee, Xiaofei Lin, Cindy H. Liu, Igor Rudan, Srijan Sen, Mark Tomlinson, Miranda Yaver, Alexander C. TsaiScientific 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

A systematic review and meta-analysis of 32 studies found that approximately 24% of Ph.D. students experience clinically significant symptoms of depression, and 17% experience clinically significant symptoms of anxiety. These rates are notably higher than those in the general young adult population, highlighting a significant public health concern within academia.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The academic journey for Ph.D. students is often characterized by intense pressure, financial insecurity, and demanding work environments. While anecdotal evidence and individual studies have pointed to high rates of mental health issues like depression and anxiety among this population, there has been a lack of a comprehensive, systematic synthesis of the available research. This gap makes it difficult for universities and policymakers to understand the true scope of the problem and to develop effective interventions. This paper aims to fill that void by systematically reviewing and meta-analyzing existing studies to provide robust estimates of depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation prevalence among Ph.D. students.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis. They searched major academic databases (PubMed, Embase, PsycINFO, ERIC, and Business Source Complete) for studies published up to November 2019 that reported on depression, anxiety, or suicidal ideation in Ph.D. students. Studies were included if they provided data on the number or proportion of Ph.D. students with clinically significant symptoms (using validated scales) or reported mean symptom severity scores. A rigorous process of screening, full-text review, and data extraction was employed. For the meta-analysis, pooled prevalence estimates were calculated using a random-effects model, and heterogeneity was assessed using the I² statistic. Subgroup analyses were conducted to explore variations, particularly for studies conducted in the United States and those using the PHQ-9 for depression assessment.

Datasets

This paper is a meta-analysis of existing studies and does not introduce new datasets. The "datasets" are the aggregated data from the 32 included studies, which collectively involved 23,469 Ph.D. students for depression prevalence and 15,626 Ph.D. students for anxiety prevalence.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Invisible Crisis" is Quantifiable: While concerns about Ph.D. student mental health have been voiced, this study provides concrete, data-driven evidence of its widespread nature. The high prevalence rates are not just anecdotal; they represent a significant portion of the Ph.D. student population.
  • Ph.D. Students are Not Just "Stressed Students": The rates of depression and anxiety among Ph.D. students are significantly higher than those reported for the general young adult population, suggesting that the unique stressors of doctoral training play a critical role.
  • Suicidal Ideation Remains a Critical, Underspecified Area: The study highlights a significant limitation in the existing literature regarding suicidal ideation, with data too heterogeneous to allow for a pooled estimate. This points to an urgent need for more standardized and robust research in this area.
  • The Need for Systemic Solutions: The findings strongly suggest that individual resilience-building alone is insufficient. The high prevalence indicates a need for systemic interventions at the institutional level to address the root causes of distress within Ph.D. programs.

Key Results

  • Depression: The pooled prevalence of clinically significant symptoms of depression among Ph.D. students was 24% (95% CI, 0.18–0.31), based on 16 studies involving 23,469 students.
  • Anxiety: The pooled prevalence of clinically significant symptoms of anxiety was 17% (95% CI, 0.12–0.23), based on nine studies involving 15,626 students.
  • Heterogeneity: Both depression and anxiety estimates showed high between-study heterogeneity (I² = 98.75% for depression, I² = 98.05% for anxiety), indicating considerable variation across studies.
  • Subgroup Analysis (US Studies): For studies conducted in the United States, the pooled prevalence of depression was 23% and anxiety was 14%, showing similar high rates.
  • Suicidal Ideation: Due to significant heterogeneity in reporting (e.g., varying recall windows), a pooled estimate for suicidal ideation prevalence could not be obtained.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • High Heterogeneity: The significant heterogeneity in the pooled estimates suggests variability in study designs, populations, and assessment methods, making direct comparisons challenging.
  • Limited Scope of Meta-Analysis: The meta-analysis for depression included 16 studies and for anxiety included nine studies. This is fewer than in meta-analyses of other trainee populations (e.g., medical students), indicating a need for more research specifically on Ph.D. students.
  • Data Limitations for Suicidal Ideation: The lack of a pooled estimate for suicidal ideation is a critical gap, underscoring the need for more standardized research in this area.
  • Potential Bias from Grey Literature: Some included studies were from grey literature (e.g., university reports), which might be more prevalent in research-intensive institutions, potentially introducing bias.
  • Lack of Disaggregated Data: Many studies did not provide data disaggregated by sociodemographic factors, stage of training, or discipline, limiting the ability to identify specific at-risk subgroups.

Future Work: The authors emphasize the urgent need for:

  • Systematic Data Collection: Universities should partner with national survey institutions to collect high-quality, clinically relevant data across diverse institutions and disciplines, disaggregated by student type.
  • Federal Agency Support: Federal agencies should fund efforts to monitor and improve Ph.D. student mental health.
  • Accreditation Requirements: Accreditation agencies should consider requiring mental health monitoring and programmatic responses.
  • More Research on Suicidality: Further research is needed to understand non-suicidal self-injury, suicide attempts, and completed suicide among Ph.D. students.
  • Inclusion of Clinic-Based Samples: Future research could benefit from including clinic-based samples, which might reveal even higher prevalence rates.
  • Disaggregated Data: Future studies should prioritize collecting and reporting data disaggregated by sociodemographic factors, stage of training, and discipline.

Summary updated

Abstract

University administrators and mental health clinicians have raised concerns about depression and anxiety among Ph.D. students, yet no study has systematically synthesized the available evidence in this area. After searching the literature for studies reporting on depression, anxiety, and/or suicidal ideation among Ph.D. students, we included 32 articles. Among 16 studies reporting the prevalence of clinically significant symptoms of depression across 23,469 Ph.D. students, the pooled estimate of the proportion of students with depression was 0.24 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.18-0.31; I<sup>2</sup> = 98.75%). In a meta-analysis of the nine studies reporting the prevalence of clinically significant symptoms of anxiety across 15,626 students, the estimated proportion of students with anxiety was 0.17 (95% CI, 0.12-0.23; I<sup>2</sup> = 98.05%). We conclude that depression and anxiety are highly prevalent among Ph.D. students. Data limitations precluded our ability to obtain a pooled estimate of suicidal ideation prevalence. Programs that systematically monitor and promote the mental health of Ph.D. students are urgently needed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{satinsky2021systematic,
  author = {Emily N. Satinsky and Tomoki Kimura and Mathew V. Kiang and Rediet Abebe and Scott Cunningham and Hedwig Lee and Xiaofei Lin and Cindy H. Liu and Igor Rudan and Srijan Sen and Mark Tomlinson and Miranda Yaver and Alexander C. Tsai},
  title = {{Systematic review and meta-analysis of depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation among Ph.D. students}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-93687-7},
}
Figure