Systematic mapping of the free energy landscapes of a growing immunoglobulin domain identifies a kinetic intermediate associated with co-translational proline isomerization

Christopher A. Waudby, Maria‐Evangelia Karyadi, Tomasz Włodarski, Anaïs M. E. Cassaignau, Sammy H. S. Chan, Julian M. Schmidt-Engler, Anne S. Wentink, Carlo Camilloni, Michele Vendruscolo, Lisa D. Cabrita, John ChristodouloubioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper maps the complex free energy landscapes of protein folding as a growing polypeptide emerges from the ribosome. They discovered a key intermediate state linked to proline isomerization, revealing that while the ribosome can delay folding, it doesn't inherently prevent misfolding in multi-domain proteins. This work highlights the critical role of kinetic factors, beyond just thermodynamic stability, in ensuring proper protein folding during synthesis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proteins are the workhorses of the cell, and their function depends on them folding into precise three-dimensional structures. This folding process is complex, especially for multi-domain proteins, where the sheer number of possible conformations grows exponentially with chain length. Co-translational folding, where a protein folds as it's being synthesized on the ribosome, is thought to be a crucial mechanism to manage this complexity and prevent misfolding and aggregation, which are linked to many diseases. However, understanding the detailed pathways and energy landscapes of co-translational folding has been a major challenge. This paper aims to systematically map these landscapes for a growing protein chain, specifically focusing on how the ribosome's influence and the intrinsic properties of the protein (like proline isomerization) contribute to efficient and accurate folding.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • C-terminal Truncation Strategy: They created a series of truncated versions of the FLN5 filamin domain, mimicking the sequential emergence of the protein from the ribosome. This allowed them to study folding at different "chain lengths" in isolation.
  • NMR Spectroscopy: This was the primary tool for structural and dynamic characterization. They used various NMR techniques (¹H,¹⁵N-SOFAST-HMQC, ¹H,¹³C-HMQC, ¹H,¹⁵N-HSQC, ¹⁵N CPMG relaxation dispersion, and ¹⁵N magnetization transfer) to probe the structure, stability, and dynamics of these truncated proteins and ribosome-nascent chain complexes (RNCs).
  • Chemical Denaturation: Used to measure the thermodynamic stability of folded versus unfolded states.
  • Replica-Averaged Metadynamics Simulations: These simulations were used to determine ensemble structures of folding intermediates, particularly when direct NMR structural determination was challenging due to dynamics and resonance overlap.
  • Real-time Temperature-Jump Kinetics: This technique allowed them to measure the rates of folding and proline isomerization by rapidly changing the temperature and monitoring spectral changes over time.
  • Markov Chain Modeling: Used to integrate thermodynamic and kinetic data with translation rates to predict the probability of misfolding in multi-domain proteins during synthesis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from engineered protein constructs and computational simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nested Free Energy Landscapes: Protein folding on the ribosome isn't a single landscape but a series of evolving landscapes as the polypeptide chain grows.
  • Kinetic Intermediate and Proline Isomerization: A key finding is the identification of a partially folded intermediate state. This intermediate is directly linked to the isomerization of a conserved, native-state cis proline residue (P742 in FLN5). This isomerization is a slow step and can become a bottleneck for reaching the fully native state.
  • Ribosome's "Holdase" Activity: The ribosome doesn't just passively release proteins; it actively influences folding. The study suggests the ribosome can delay folding by stabilizing unfolded states, but this delay doesn't automatically prevent misfolding, especially in multi-domain proteins.
  • Misfolding Risk in Tandem Repeats: For proteins with multiple similar domains (like filamin), the accumulation of unfolded domains due to slow co-translational folding can lead to an increased risk of forming non-native inter-domain contacts and misfolding.
  • Enzymatic Catalysis is Crucial: The risk of misfolding is significantly reduced if the slow proline isomerization step is accelerated by enzymes like peptidyl-prolyl isomerases (PPIases). This highlights that kinetic factors are as important as thermodynamic stability for accurate protein folding.

Key Results

  • Thermodynamic Stability: The six C-terminal residues of FLN5 contribute significantly to its overall stability (ΔG<sub>N-U</sub> = -7.0 ± 0.2 kcal mol⁻¹).
  • Intermediate Stability: The trans-proline intermediate (I state) has a modest stability relative to the unfolded state (ΔG<sub>I-U</sub> = 0.8 ± 0.2 kcal mol⁻¹).
  • Folding Kinetics: For the A6 intermediate, the folding rate (k<sub>U→I</sub>) was ~0.8 s⁻¹, and the unfolding rate (k<sub>I→U</sub>) was ~1.7 s⁻¹.
  • Proline Isomerization Rate: The trans-to-cis isomerization of P742 was measured to have a time constant of ~1.5 minutes at 298 K.
  • Ribosome-Induced Destabilization: The ribosome can destabilize the nascent chain by approximately 7 kcal mol⁻¹, comparable to the folding energy of the isolated domain.
  • Misfolding Risk Model: The developed model predicts a high risk of misfolding for tandem repeat proteins when proline isomerization is the rate-limiting step, but this risk is largely eliminated if PPIase activity is present.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Truncation vs. Ribosome: While the truncation strategy is powerful, it's not a perfect mimic of the ribosome-bound state. The paper acknowledges that the intermediate observed in isolation might be structurally incompatible with ribosome tethering or destabilized by other ribosomal interactions.
  • Model Simplifications: The Markov chain model makes simplifying assumptions about translation rates and the independence of folding rates.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest developing a quantitative understanding of the ribosome's "holdase" activity. Further work is needed to explore the impact of these findings on other multi-domain proteins and to investigate the role of chaperones in mitigating misfolding risks. The conservation of the proline residue despite the potential misfolding hazard also warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Co-translational folding is a fundamental molecular process that ensures efficient protein biosynthesis and minimizes the wasteful or hazardous formation of misfolded states. However, the complexity of this process makes it extremely challenging to obtain structural characterizations of co-translational folding pathways. Here we contrast observations in translationally-arrested nascent chains with those of a systematic C-terminal truncation strategy. We create a detailed description of chain length-dependent free energy landscapes associated with folding of the FLN5 filamin domain, in isolation and on the ribosome. By using this approach we identify and characterize two folding intermediates, including a partially folded intermediate associated with the isomerization of a conserved proline residue, which, together with measurements of folding kinetics, raises the prospect that neighboring unfolded domains might accumulate during biosynthesis. We develop a simple model to quantify the risk of misfolding in this situation, and show that catalysis of folding by peptidyl-prolyl isomerases is essential to eliminate this hazard.
BibTeX
@misc{waudby2017systematic,
  author = {Christopher A. Waudby and Maria‐Evangelia Karyadi and Tomasz Włodarski and Anaïs M. E. Cassaignau and Sammy H. S. Chan and Julian M. Schmidt-Engler and Anne S. Wentink and Carlo Camilloni and Michele Vendruscolo and Lisa D. Cabrita and John Christodoulou},
  title = {{Systematic mapping of the free energy landscapes of a growing immunoglobulin domain identifies a kinetic intermediate associated with co-translational proline isomerization}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/189050},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure