System Implementation Trade-Offs for Low-Speed Rotational Variable Reluctance Energy Harvesters

Ye Xu, Sebastian Bader, Michele Magno, Philipp Mayer, Bengt OelmannSensors 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the impact of different rectifier circuits on the efficiency of low-speed rotational variable reluctance energy harvesting (VREH) systems. By comparing full-wave bridge (FWR), voltage doubler (VD), and negative voltage converter (NVC) rectifiers, the authors demonstrate that the optimal choice is highly dependent on operating conditions, and that careful tuning can significantly boost energy extraction for applications like self-powered sensors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Energy harvesting is crucial for powering low-power electronic devices, especially in the realm of IoT and smart sensors, as it can extend battery life or enable entirely autonomous operation. Kinetic energy harvesters, like Variable Reluctance Energy Harvesters (VREH), are particularly interesting for rotational applications. However, VREHs typically produce an AC output that needs to be converted to DC for most electronic loads. The interface circuit, specifically the rectifier, plays a critical role in this conversion. Poor rectifier design can lead to significant power loss and reduced overall system efficiency, especially at the low voltages and speeds characteristic of many VREH applications. This paper addresses the challenge of selecting the most effective rectifier for low-speed VREH systems by systematically comparing three common passive rectifier topologies (FWR, VD, NVC) and evaluating their impact on both power conversion efficiency (PCE) and power extraction efficiency (PEE).

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage experimental approach. First, they characterized the VREH transducer itself by determining its maximum output power under impedance-matched conditions. This established a baseline for evaluating how well the subsequent interface circuits could extract power. Second, they implemented and tested three passive rectifier circuits: a Full-Wave Bridge Rectifier (FWR), a Delon Voltage Doubler (VD), and a Negative Voltage Converter (NVC). These rectifiers were integrated with a commercial DC-DC power management integrated circuit (PMIC, TI BQ25570). Experiments were conducted across a range of rotational speeds (5-20 rpm) and with varying tuning capacitances between the rectifier and the PMIC. Key performance metrics, Power Conversion Efficiency (PCE) and Power Extraction Efficiency (PEE), were measured. Finally, they performed an end-to-end system evaluation by powering a wireless RPM sensing system with the VREH and each rectifier configuration to assess the practical impact on system performance, specifically sample rate.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements from a custom-built VREH setup and commercially available components.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rectifier Choice is Crucial and Condition-Dependent: There's no single "best" rectifier. The optimal choice between FWR, VD, and NVC shifts significantly with rotational speed.
  • Tuning Capacitance Impacts Both PCE and PEE: The capacitor between the rectifier and the PMIC is not just for smoothing; it actively influences the operating point of the VREH transducer, affecting how much power is extracted.
  • PEE is a More Holistic Metric: While PCE measures the efficiency of the interface circuit itself, PEE accounts for how well the circuit allows the transducer to deliver power, making it a better indicator of overall system performance.
  • Low Speeds Favor Voltage Doublers: At lower rotational speeds (e.g., 5 rpm), the VD rectifier significantly outperforms the others, likely due to its ability to boost the low AC voltage more effectively and its higher intrinsic efficiency.
  • NVC Shines at Higher Speeds: As rotational speed increases, the NVC rectifier's performance rapidly improves, eventually surpassing the VD. This is attributed to reduced MOSFET on-resistance at higher voltages, overcoming its initial limitations.
  • Trade-offs Exist: Optimizing for maximum PCE doesn't always yield maximum PEE. A higher tuning capacitance can increase PEE even if it slightly decreases PCE, indicating that maximizing extracted power is key.

Key Results

  • The FWR rectifier consistently showed the lowest performance across all tested conditions, with PEEs ranging from 20% at 5 rpm to 40% at 20 rpm.
  • The VD rectifier demonstrated the best performance at lower rotational speeds (5-15 rpm), achieving PEEs of 40-60%.
  • The NVC rectifier showed a condition-dependent performance, outperforming the VD at higher speeds (>18 rpm) with PEEs reaching up to 70%.
  • In the end-to-end system evaluation with a wireless RPM sensor, the VD rectifier enabled the system to reach its maximum sample rate (40 Hz) at approximately 15.5 rpm, while the FWR required around 18 rpm for the same rate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fixed Tuning Capacitance: For the end-to-end system evaluation, a fixed tuning capacitance was selected for each rectifier. The authors suggest that a dynamic tuning capacitance could further improve PEE by continuously optimizing the operating point.
  • VREH Transducer Optimization: While the study focuses on interface circuits, the authors note that optimizing the physical dimensions of the VREH transducer (magnet height, coil height, tooth height) could lead to higher volumetric power density and further enhance system performance.
  • Hybrid/Adjustable Solutions: Future work could explore hybrid rectifier solutions or adaptive strategies that can adjust their behavior based on real-time operating conditions to achieve optimal performance across a wider range of speeds.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{xu2021system,
  author = {Ye Xu and Sebastian Bader and Michele Magno and Philipp Mayer and Bengt Oelmann},
  title = {{System Implementation Trade-Offs for Low-Speed Rotational Variable Reluctance Energy Harvesters}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21186317},
}

Loading related content...

Figure