α-Synuclein Suppression by Targeted Small Interfering RNA in the Primate Substantia Nigra

Alison L. McCormack, Sally K. Mak, Jaimie M. Henderson, David Bumcrot, Matthew J. Farrer, Donato A. Di MontePLoS 2010 · DOI

Abstract

The protein α-synuclein is central to the pathogenesis of Parkinson's disease (PD) and other neurodegenerative "synucleinopathies." Evidence suggests that increased protein expression enhances its toxic potential, making the reduction of neuronal α-synuclein burden a compelling therapeutic strategy. This study evaluates the feasibility and safety of α-synuclein suppression in a primate model using small interfering RNA (siRNA). By infusing chemically modified siRNA directly into the substantia nigra of squirrel monkeys, researchers achieved a significant 40–50% reduction in α-synuclein expression without adverse consequences, providing a critical proof-of-concept for RNA interference (RNAi) therapeutics.

Introduction

Parkinson’s Disease is characterized by the progressive loss of dopaminergic neurons, a process often linked to the aggregation of α-synuclein (α-syn) into toxic clumps known as Lewy bodies. Since higher levels of α-syn correlate with increased neurotoxicity, "silencing" the SNCA gene responsible for its production has emerged as a primary therapeutic goal. However, translating this theory into clinical practice faces two major hurdles: ensuring the safety of knocking down a protein with normal physiological roles and validating these findings in models relevant to human biology. While rodent studies have yielded conflicting results regarding the safety of α-syn knockdown, primate brains—which naturally upregulate α-syn with age—offer a more accurate platform for testing these interventions.

Methodology

The study utilized six adult squirrel monkeys (Saimiri scuireus) to test a unilateral infusion approach designed to compare treated and untreated brain regions within the same subject.

  • The Intervention: A chemically modified, "naked" siRNA designed to resist enzymatic degradation was infused directly into the left substantia nigra via an osmotic mini-pump for four weeks.
  • The Control: The right hemisphere served as an internal untreated control. Additionally, a separate group of monkeys received siRNA targeting firefly luciferase to rule out non-specific effects of the infusion process.
  • Analysis: Quantitative PCR (qPCR) and in situ hybridization were used to measure mRNA levels, while immunohistochemistry with densitometry quantified protein levels. Safety was rigorously assessed via stereological cell counting of dopaminergic neurons and HPLC measurement of striatal dopamine concentrations.

Key Results

The intervention successfully reduced α-synuclein levels while maintaining the functional and structural integrity of the nigrostriatal system:

  • mRNA and Protein Suppression: qPCR revealed a 50% reduction in α-syn mRNA in the anterior substantia nigra and a 42% reduction in the posterior region. Densitometric analysis confirmed a corresponding 40% decrease in α-syn protein immunoreactivity compared to the untreated hemisphere.
  • Neuronal Survival: Crucially, there was no loss of dopaminergic neurons. Stereological counts showed approximately 60,000 neurons in both the treated and untreated hemispheres, indicating that partial knockdown is not toxic to these cells.
  • Functional Stability: Striatal dopamine and its metabolites (DOPAC, HVA) remained unchanged. This suggests that the remaining α-syn levels were sufficient to maintain normal neurotransmitter synthesis and release.
  • Lack of Inflammation: Despite the invasive nature of a four-week continuous infusion, no significant microglial activation or tissue inflammation was observed, suggesting the modified siRNA is well-tolerated by the primate brain.

Discussion and Insights

These findings highlight a potential "therapeutic window" where a 40–50% knockdown is sufficient to lower the protein burden without compromising the functional integrity of the dopaminergic system. This result is particularly important given that some rodent studies using viral-delivered RNAi reported neurotoxicity. The authors suggest that such toxicity in rodents might stem from "over-silencing" (e.g., >90% knockdown) or the high-pressure delivery of viral vectors, rather than the loss of α-syn itself.

The use of "naked" siRNA is a significant methodological choice. Unlike permanent viral gene therapy, naked siRNA allows for controlled dosage and temporary effects, offering a safer and more tunable clinical profile. This study provides the first evidence of successful and safe anti-α-synuclein intervention in the primate substantia nigra.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this proof-of-concept is promising, several questions remain for future research:

  1. Long-term Safety: The study's four-week duration does not account for the chronic, decades-long nature of Parkinson's disease.
  2. Disease Context: The effects were tested in healthy monkeys; it is unknown if the same knockdown would effectively halt pre-existing neurodegeneration in a brain already suffering from α-syn pathology.
  3. Delivery Methods: Continuous infusion via a cannula and pump is highly invasive. Future work must explore less invasive delivery methods or long-acting siRNA formulations.
  4. Efficacy Threshold: It remains to be determined if a 40–50% reduction is enough to provide meaningful neuroprotection in a clinical disease state.

Overall, this research represents a major step forward in validating RNAi-based therapeutics as a feasible strategy for treating Parkinson's disease and related synucleinopathies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The protein alpha-synuclein is involved in the pathogenesis of Parkinson's disease and other neurodegenerative disorders. Its toxic potential appears to be enhanced by increased protein expression, providing a compelling rationale for therapeutic strategies aimed at reducing neuronal alpha-synuclein burden. Here, feasibility and safety of alpha-synuclein suppression were evaluated by treating monkeys with small interfering RNA (siRNA) directed against alpha-synuclein. The siRNA molecule was chemically modified to prevent degradation by exo- and endonucleases and directly infused into the left substantia nigra. Results compared levels of alpha-synuclein mRNA and protein in the infused (left) vs. untreated (right) hemisphere and revealed a significant 40-50% suppression of alpha-synuclein expression. These findings could not be attributable to non-specific effects of siRNA infusion since treatment of a separate set of animals with luciferase-targeting siRNA produced no changes in alpha-synuclein. Infusion with alpha-synuclein siRNA, while lowering alpha-synuclein expression, had no overt adverse consequences. In particular, it did not cause tissue inflammation and did not change (i) the number and phenotype of nigral dopaminergic neurons, and (ii) the concentrations of striatal dopamine and its metabolites. The data represent the first evidence of successful anti-alpha-synuclein intervention in the primate substantia nigra and support further development of RNA interference-based therapeutics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mccormack2010synuclein,
  author = {Alison L. McCormack and Sally K. Mak and Jaimie M. Henderson and David Bumcrot and Matthew J. Farrer and Donato A. Di Monte},
  title = {{α-Synuclein Suppression by Targeted Small Interfering RNA in the Primate Substantia Nigra}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0012122},
}
Figure