Syntrophy via Interspecies H 2 Transfer between Christensenella and Methanobrevibacter Underlies Their Global Cooccurrence in the Human Gut

Albane Ruaud, Sofia Esquivel‐Elizondo, Jacobo de la Cuesta‐Zuluaga, Jillian L. Waters, Largus T. Angenent, Nicholas D. Youngblut, Ruth E. LeymBio 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the co-occurrence of the gut bacteria Christensenella and the archaea Methanobrevibacter is driven by a syntrophic relationship where Christensenella produces hydrogen (H₂) that M. smithii consumes to produce methane (CH₄). This interaction, facilitated by physical flocculation, influences bacterial fermentation products, potentially contributing to the association of these microbes with a lean host phenotype.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human gut microbiome is a complex ecosystem where different microbes interact to influence host health. Previous studies have observed a consistent co-occurrence between the bacterial family Christensenellaceae and the archaeal family Methanobacteriaceae in the human gut, and notably, this co-occurrence is enriched in individuals with a lean body mass index (BMI). However, the nature of this association – whether it's purely correlational or reflects functional metabolic interactions – and its potential role in the lean host phenotype remained unclear. This paper aims to elucidate these functional interactions and their implications for host health.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Meta-analysis of Metagenomes: They analyzed a large dataset of 1,821 human gut metagenomes from 10 independent studies. This allowed them to statistically validate the co-occurrence patterns between Christensenellaceae and Methanobacteriaceae at family, genus, and species levels, and to confirm their association with lean BMI, while controlling for factors like age. A custom reference database was created to improve the taxonomic resolution of Christensenellaceae.
  • In Vitro Coculture Experiments: They performed laboratory experiments by growing representative species, Christensenella minuta (a Christensenellaceae member) and Methanobrevibacter smithii (a Methanobacteriaceae member), together and separately.
  • Microscopy: Confocal and scanning electron microscopy were used to visualize the physical interactions between these microbes, specifically looking for aggregation and floc formation.
  • Gas and Metabolite Analysis: They measured the production of hydrogen (H₂) and methane (CH₄) gases, as well as short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) like acetate and butyrate, in both mono- and cocultures. This allowed them to assess the metabolic exchange and its impact on fermentation products.

Datasets

  • Human Gut Metagenomes: A meta-analysis of 1,821 metagenomes from 10 independent studies was performed. This dataset was augmented with newly generated metagenomic data.
  • Cultured Microorganisms: Pure cultures of Methanobrevibacter smithii, Christensenella minuta, Christensenella massiliensis, Christensenella timonensis, and Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron were used for in vitro experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Syntrophy is Key: The study strongly suggests that the co-occurrence of Christensenella and Methanobrevibacter is not just a coincidence but a functional partnership (syntrophy) where one organism's waste product is another's fuel.
  • H₂ Transfer is the Engine: The core metabolic interaction is the transfer of hydrogen (H₂) from Christensenella to M. smithii. This is a crucial insight into how these otherwise disparate organisms can thrive together.
  • Physical Proximity Matters: The formation of "flocs" (dense aggregates) by Christensenella and M. smithii is critical. This close physical association enhances the efficiency of H₂ transfer, akin to a direct pipeline.
  • Metabolic Rewiring: The presence of M. smithii actively alters Christensenella's fermentation. By consuming H₂, M. smithii shifts C. minuta's metabolism away from butyrate production and towards acetate production. This has implications for host nutrient availability.
  • Lean BMI Link: The observed metabolic shifts and the efficiency of this interaction provide a plausible explanation for why these microbes are associated with a lean phenotype, potentially by altering energy harvest or availability for the host.

Key Results

  • Robust Co-occurrence: The meta-analysis confirmed the strong positive correlation between Christensenellaceae and Methanobacteriaceae at family, genus, and species levels across diverse populations.
  • Lean BMI Association: This co-occurrence was significantly associated with a lower BMI, reinforcing previous findings.
  • Christensenella as a Superior H₂ Source: Christensenella species were significantly more effective at supporting M. smithii's growth via H₂ production compared to Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron, a known H₂ producer.
  • Flocculation and H₂ Consumption: C. minuta readily formed flocs that were colonized by M. smithii. In these cocultures, M. smithii efficiently consumed H₂, leading to increased methane production.
  • Metabolic Shift: M. smithii's H₂ consumption in coculture with C. minuta led to a decrease in butyrate production and an increase in acetate production by C. minuta.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Vitro vs. In Vivo: While the study provides strong evidence for syntrophy and metabolic shifts in vitro, directly translating these findings to the complex in vivo environment of the human gut requires further investigation.
  • Host Physiology Modeling: The authors suggest that careful modeling of energy flow in vivo is needed to quantitatively assess how the presence and activity of these microbes impact host physiology.
  • Other Christensenellaceae Species: While C. minuta was extensively studied, the interactions of other Christensenellaceae species with M. smithii were explored but with some differences in outcomes, suggesting species-specific nuances.
  • Broader Microbiome Context: The study focuses on a specific interaction. Understanding how this syntrophy fits within the larger context of the entire gut microbiome and its diverse interactions remains an area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Across human populations, 16S rRNA gene-based surveys of gut microbiomes have revealed that the bacterial family <i>Christensenellaceae</i> and the archaeal family <i>Methanobacteriaceae</i> cooccur and are enriched in individuals with a lean, compared to an obese, body mass index (BMI). Whether these association patterns reflect interactions between metabolic partners, as well as whether these associations play a role in the lean host phenotype with which they associate, remains to be ascertained. Here, we validated previously reported cooccurrence patterns of the two families and their association with a lean BMI with a meta-analysis of 1,821 metagenomes derived from 10 independent studies. Furthermore, we report positive associations at the genus and species levels between <i>Christensenella</i> spp. and <i>Methanobrevibacter smithii</i>, the most abundant methanogen of the human gut. By coculturing three <i>Christensenella</i> spp. with <i>M. smithii</i>, we show that <i>Christensenella</i> spp. efficiently support the metabolism of <i>M. smithii</i> via H<sub>2</sub> production far better than <i>Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron</i> does. <i>Christensenella minuta</i> forms flocs colonized by <i>M. smithii</i> even when H<sub>2</sub> is in excess. In culture with <i>C. minuta</i>, H<sub>2</sub> consumption by <i>M. smithii</i> shifts the metabolic output of <i>C. minuta</i>'s fermentation toward acetate rather than butyrate. Together, these results indicate that the widespread cooccurrence of these microorganisms is underpinned by both physical and metabolic interactions. Their combined metabolic activity may provide insights into their association with a lean host BMI.<b>IMPORTANCE</b> The human gut microbiome is made of trillions of microbial cells, most of which are <i>Bacteria</i>, with a subset of <i>Archaea</i> The bacterial family <i>Christensenellaceae</i> and the archaeal family <i>Methanobacteriaceae</i> are widespread in human guts. They correlate with each other and with a lean body type. Whether species of these two families interact and how they affect the body type are unanswered questions. Here, we show that species within these families correlate with each other across people. We also demonstrate that particular species of these two families grow together in dense flocs, wherein the bacteria provide hydrogen gas to the archaea, which then make methane. When the archaea are present, the ratio of bacterial products (which are nutrients for humans) is changed. These observations indicate that when these species grow together, their products have the potential to affect the physiology of their human host.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ruaud2020syntrophy,
  author = {Albane Ruaud and Sofia Esquivel‐Elizondo and Jacobo de la Cuesta‐Zuluaga and Jillian L. Waters and Largus T. Angenent and Nicholas D. Youngblut and Ruth E. Ley},
  title = {{Syntrophy via Interspecies H <sub>2</sub> Transfer between <i>Christensenella</i> and <i>Methanobrevibacter</i> Underlies Their Global Cooccurrence in the Human Gut}},
  booktitle = {mBio},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1128/mbio.03235-19},
}
Figure