Synthesis and investigation of donor–porphyrin–acceptor triads with long-lived photo-induced charge-separate states

Julien Kelber, Naitik A. Panjwani, Di Wu, Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli, Brendon W. Lovett, John J. L. Morton, Harry L. AndersonChemical 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a new, versatile synthetic route to donor-porphyrin-acceptor molecular triads, enabling the incorporation of sensitive electron-donating groups. They demonstrate that by switching the acceptor from a quinone (TNQ) to a fullerene (C60), they can achieve a significantly longer-lived photo-induced charge-separated state (16 ms at 10 K), which is crucial for applications in quantum information processing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ability to store and manipulate energy from light is fundamental to many technologies, from solar cells to quantum computing. Photo-induced electron transfer in molecular systems can create "charge-separated states" (CSSs) where an electron and a "hole" (the absence of an electron) are spatially separated. While these states are often short-lived due to rapid recombination, long-lived CSSs are highly desirable for applications like mimicking natural photosynthesis or encoding quantum information. The challenge lies in designing molecules that can efficiently separate charges and then prevent them from recombining for extended periods, especially under conditions relevant for quantum information processing (e.g., low temperatures in frozen solvents). Previous work had achieved long-lived CSSs, but the synthesis of such molecules often required protecting sensitive donor groups, leading to less efficient synthetic routes. This paper aims to develop a more versatile synthesis for these triads and to further extend the lifetime of the CSS by exploring different acceptor units.

Methods

The core of this work involves the synthesis and characterization of novel molecular triads.

  • Synthesis: The researchers employed a Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling strategy. This is a well-established and mild method for forming carbon-carbon bonds, particularly useful here because it allows for the introduction of sensitive donor groups (like tetraalkylphenylenediamine, TAPD) late in the synthesis, avoiding the need for protection. They developed efficient multi-step syntheses for key building blocks, including boronic ester-functionalized porphyrins and acceptors.
  • Theoretical Calculations:
    • Density Functional Theory (DFT) was used extensively to calculate molecular geometries, frontier orbital energies, and reaction free energies (AG) for electron transfer steps. This helped predict the thermodynamic favorability of charge separation and recombination.
  • Marcus theory and related equations were applied to model electron transfer rates, considering factors like coupling matrix elements (VDA), reorganization energies (λ), and free energy changes (AG).
  • Polarizable Continuum Model (PCM) was used to simulate the effect of solvent environments, including both fluid solutions and frozen solvent glasses.
  • Experimental Characterization:
    • Electrochemistry (Squarewave Voltammetry): Used to determine the oxidation and reduction potentials of the molecular components, which are crucial inputs for calculating free energy changes.
  • Optical Spectroscopy (UV-Vis): Used to estimate the energy of the first singlet excited state (S1) of the porphyrin.
  • Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) Spectroscopy: This was the primary technique for observing and characterizing the long-lived charge-separated states. They used both continuous-wave (CW) and pulsed EPR to probe the spin polarization and measure the lifetimes of these transient species.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of specific molecular systems rather than training on large datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Suzuki Coupling as a Versatile Tool: The paper highlights the power of Suzuki coupling for constructing complex molecular architectures like donor-porphyrin-acceptor triads, especially when dealing with sensitive functional groups. This opens doors for synthesizing a wider range of such molecules.
  • C60 as a Superior Acceptor for Long-Lived CSSs: Replacing the triptycenenaphthoquinone (TNQ) acceptor with a fullerene (C60) significantly improved the lifetime of the charge-separated state. This is attributed to C60's higher electron affinity, which increases the driving force for charge separation, and potentially its electronic properties that lead to weaker coupling and lower reorganization energies.
  • Frozen Solvent Importance for Quantum Information: The study emphasizes that achieving long-lived CSSs at low temperatures in frozen solvents is critical for quantum information processing applications. The lack of solvent reorientation in frozen media makes charge recombination more challenging to stabilize.
  • Predictive Power of Computational Modeling: The theoretical calculations accurately predicted the trends in electron transfer thermodynamics and kinetics, guiding the experimental design and explaining the observed differences in CSS lifetimes between the different triads.

Key Results

  • Successful Synthesis: Two new donor-porphyrin-acceptor triads were synthesized using a versatile Suzuki-coupling route.
  • TNQ-ZnPAr-TAPD Failure: The triad with a tetraarylporphyrin core and a TNQ acceptor (TNQ-ZnPAr-TAPD) did not exhibit a detectable long-lived CSS in frozen solution, consistent with theoretical predictions of insufficient thermodynamic driving force.
  • C60-ZnPAr-TAPD Success: The triad with a C60 acceptor (C60-ZnPAr-TAPD) successfully generated a spin-polarized charge-separated state observable by EPR.
  • Extended Lifetime: The mean lifetime of the CSS in C60-ZnPAr-TAPD was measured to be 16 ms at 10 K, which is approximately four times longer than the previously reported TNQ-ZnP-TAPD triad (4 ms). This is among the longest reported lifetimes for such systems.
  • Computational Agreement: Theoretical calculations predicted that the C60-based triad would have a longer lifetime due to a more favorable driving force and weaker coupling, which was experimentally confirmed.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Solvent Dependence: While the C60-ZnPAr-TAPD triad showed a long-lived CSS in xylenes and 2-methyltetrahydrofuran, it could not be investigated in butyronitrile due to limited solubility. This highlights the importance of solvent choice for both synthesis and characterization.
  • Quantum Yield: The quantum yield for CSS formation in C60-ZnPAr-TAPD was estimated to be around 0.1, suggesting room for improvement.
  • Further Spectroscopic Studies: The authors mention that further spectroscopic studies on the C60-ZnPAr-TAPD triad are in progress, indicating a desire to delve deeper into its photophysical properties.
  • Broader Applications: The paper suggests that this synthetic strategy and the resulting molecular systems could be applied to other advanced molecular materials, such as those for photovoltaic devices and optically gated molecular wires.

Summary updated

Abstract

Two donor-porphyrin-acceptor triads have been synthesized using a versatile Suzuki-coupling route. This synthetic strategy allows the powerful donor tetraalkylphenylenediamine (<b>TAPD</b>) to be introduced into tetraarylporphyrin-based triads without protection. The thermodynamics and kinetics of electron transfer in the new triads are compared with a previously reported octaalkyldiphenyl-porphyrin triad exhibiting a long-lived spin-polarized charge separate state (CSS), from theoretical and experimental perspectives, in both fluid solution and in a frozen solvent glass. We show that the less favorable oxidation potential of the tetraaryl-porphyrin core can be offset by using <b>C<sub>60</sub></b> , as a better electron-acceptor than triptycenenaphthoquinone (<b>TNQ</b>). The <b>C<sub>60</sub></b> -porphyrin-<b>TAPD</b> triad gives a spin-polarized charge-separated state that can be observed by EPR-spectroscopy, with a mean lifetime of 16 ms at 10 K, which is longer than in the previously reported <b>TNQ</b>-porphyrin-<b>TAPD</b> triad, following the predicted trend from calculated charge-recombination rates.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kelber2015synthesis,
  author = {Julien Kelber and Naitik A. Panjwani and Di Wu and Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli and Brendon W. Lovett and John J. L. Morton and Harry L. Anderson},
  title = {{Synthesis and investigation of donor–porphyrin–acceptor triads with long-lived photo-induced charge-separate states}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1039/c5sc01830g},
}
Figure