SyntheIce: A Synthetic Radargram Annotation Benchmark for Englacial Layer Reconstruction

Muhammad Behroze Hassan, Bayu Adhi Tama, Sanjay Purushotham, Vandana P. JanejaarXiv 2026 · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have introduced SyntheIce, a new benchmark for reconstructing fragmented subsurface ice layers from radar data. By combining a geometric synthetic data generator with TraceLink—a slope-aware algorithm that prioritizes trajectory over appearance—they’ve created a robust framework for turning disconnected radar "skeletons" into continuous, scientifically valuable climate records.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Glaciologists use airborne radio-echo sounding (RES) to peer into ice sheets, producing "radargrams" that reveal internal layers called isochrones. These layers are essentially a time capsule, recording past snowfall, ice flow, and deformation.

The problem? We have millions of kilometers of radar data but a massive bottleneck in processing it. Manual tracing is agonizingly slow, and even the best automated deep-learning detectors usually return "fragmented skeletons"—short, disconnected pieces of what should be a continuous line. This happens because of signal noise, signal fade at depth, or steeply dipping structures that confuse standard sensors. Reassembling these fragments into coherent layers is a complex spatial puzzle that existing tools struggle to solve consistently.

Methods

The authors tackle this with a three-part framework:

  1. SyntheIce (The Generator): Instead of relying on noisy human labels, the team built a code-based generator. It creates synthetic radargrams using cubic splines and a "shared deformation field," ensuring that layers bend together realistically (mimicking ice flow history). It then injects controlled "breaks" and terrain tilts to simulate real-world sensor failures.
  2. TraceLink (The Linker): This is a greedy algorithm that scans fragments from left to right. Its "secret sauce" is an Exponentially Weighted Moving Average (EWMA) slope predictor. Instead of just looking for the nearest pixel, it predicts where a layer should go based on its current trajectory. It uses "row-similarity gating" to decide if a new fragment belongs to an existing layer.
  3. XCheck (The Validator): To ensure consistency, they use a framework called XCheck to verify that layers line up perfectly across the boundaries of adjacent image tiles—a step often skipped in automated pipelines.
The end-to-end framework: from synthetic generation to TraceLink reconstruction and validation.

Datasets

  • SyntheIce: A new benchmark consisting of 600 synthetic radargrams across four complexity levels (Close-to-Synthetic, Mid-Level, Close-to-Real, and Noisy-Level). These provide "perfect" ground truth for every pixel.
  • CReSIS Greenland Datasets: Real-world radar data from the Center for Remote Sensing of Ice Sheets. The authors validated their method by taking high-quality expert annotations, intentionally breaking them with random gaps, and seeing if TraceLink could put them back together.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometry Trumps Appearance: The core finding is that in noisy spatial data, a feature's trajectory (slope) is a much more reliable linking cue than its brightness or pixel intensity. Even when the signal fades to nothing, the geometric "momentum" of the layer usually carries through.
  • The Failure of Generative AI: The authors tested state-of-the-art GenAI models (like Gemini and GPT-4o) to see if they could annotate these layers. The models failed spectacularly, hallucinating layers that didn't exist and missing real ones. This underscores the need for specialized, geometrically-aware algorithms in geosciences.
Comparison showing how GenAI models hallucinate layers compared to the structured ground truth required for scientific analysis.
  • Shared Flow History: By applying a single deformation field to all layers in a synthetic image, the authors ensured the layers "bend together." This makes the synthetic data much more representative of real-world glaciology than a simple stack of random lines.

Key Results

  • High Fidelity: On the most difficult "Noisy-Level" synthetic data, TraceLink maintained an F1-score of 0.85 and a Recall of 0.89.
  • Real-World Transfer: When tested on real Greenland radargrams with artificial fragmentation, the method achieved a Recall of 0.93 and an F1-score of 0.84. This proves the findings from synthetic data translate effectively to the messy reality of field data.
  • Consistency: XCheck achieved near-perfect Precision (0.99-1.00), meaning it almost never incorrectly flags a consistent layer as a mismatch across tile boundaries.
Performance metrics across different complexity levels, showing robust recall even as noise increases.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors note that their current synthetic terrain tilt is relatively mild (up to 3°). In some real-world scenarios, layers can dip much more steeply, which remains a challenge for future iterations.

Looking ahead, the team plans to move toward "learned" non-parametric linkers and explore using these synthetic masks to train generative models that can produce raw, realistic radar imagery. This would create a "closed-loop" system for training deep learning models without needing thousands of hours of manual human labor.

Summary updated

Abstract

Englacial layers in radio-echo-sounding radargrams (subsurface ice images) encode the climate and flow history of ice sheets and glaciers. However, large-scale extraction is hindered by time-consuming manual annotation and semi-automated detectors that produce fragmented rather than continuous horizons. We address two challenges: reconstructing complete layers from partial detections across radargram profiles and validating layer continuity across adjacent tile boundaries. We introduce a slope-aware greedy fragment-linking algorithm that reconstructs full-width layers using row-similarity gating and an exponentially weighted moving average (EWMA) slope predictor. Each reconstruction receives a content-based hash ID for stable cross-radargram identification. For quantitative evaluation, we generate SyntheIce, a synthetic dataset of 600 radargrams spanning multiple complexity levels and realistic noise conditions, including 150 wide radargrams divided into four adjacent tiles. All samples include exact ground-truth annotations. We evaluate the dataset using XCheck, a consistency-based validation framework, extending its original two-image setting to four consecutive tiles and enforcing continuity at every boundary. This demonstrates the dataset's utility for developing and evaluating real-world annotation algorithms. Our findings extend beyond ice science: when spatial features are fragmented but retain consistent local geometry, trajectory-based linking is more reliable than appearance-based matching. Evaluation against expert-labeled real radargrams demonstrates high precision, recall, F1-score, and mean IoU, supporting the method's transfer to real-world data.
BibTeX
@misc{hassan2026syntheice,
  author = {Muhammad Behroze Hassan and Bayu Adhi Tama and Sanjay Purushotham and Vandana P. Janeja},
  title = {{SyntheIce: A Synthetic Radargram Annotation Benchmark for Englacial Layer Reconstruction}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2611.14728},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.14728},
}
Figure