Synergistic targeting of breast cancer stem‐like cells by human γδ T cells and CD8+ T cells

Hung‐Chang Chen, Noémie Joalland, John S. Bridgeman, Fouad Alchami, Ulrich Jarry, Mohd Wajid Ali Khan, Luke Piggott, Yasmin Shanneik, Jianqiang Li, Marco J. Herold, Thomas Herrmann, David A. Price, Awen Gallimore, Richard Clarkson, Emmanuel Scotet, Bernhard Moser, Matthias EberlImmunology 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates a powerful synergistic effect between two types of immune cells, γδ T cells and CD8+ T cells, in targeting and eradicating breast cancer stem-like cells (CSCs). By combining strategies that enhance CSC recognition by both cell types, researchers propose a novel two-pronged immunotherapy approach for more effective cancer treatment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cancer stem cells (CSCs) are a major hurdle in cancer treatment. These cells are inherently resistant to conventional therapies like chemotherapy and radiation, leading to disease recurrence and metastasis. Developing effective strategies to specifically target and eliminate CSCs is crucial for improving patient outcomes in advanced cancers, particularly breast cancer. Current immunotherapies often rely on CD8+ T cells, which are MHC-restricted, limiting their effectiveness in patients with specific MHC haplotypes. This paper explores the potential of non-MHC-restricted γδ T cells, in combination with CD8+ T cells, to overcome CSC resistance and enhance anti-cancer immunity.

Methods

The researchers established a model system using immortalized human mammary epithelial cells (HMLER) engineered to exhibit CSC-like properties. These CSC-like cells were characterized by their CD44<sup>hi</sup> CD24<sup>lo</sup> GD2<sup>+</sup> phenotype, mesenchymal morphology, and ability to form mammospheres and tumors in mice.

Key experimental approaches included:

  • Cell Culture and Sorting: HMLER cells were cultured under various conditions (adherent, mammosphere) and sorted to isolate CSC-like and non-CSC populations based on surface markers.
  • Functional Assays: Mammosphere formation assays were used to assess self-renewal capacity. Tumorigenicity and metastasis were evaluated in immunodeficient NSG mice.
  • T Cell Co-cultures: Expanded human γδ T cells (specifically Vγ9/Vδ2 T cells) and antigen-specific CD8+ T cells were co-cultured with CSC-like and non-CSC target cells.
  • Sensitization Strategies:
    • Farnesyl pyrophosphate synthase (FPPS) Inhibition: Pretreatment of CSC-like cells with zoledronate (a bisphosphonate) or short hairpin RNA targeting FPPS was used to enhance γδ T cell recognition.
  • Antibody Opsonization: The anti-GD2 antibody hu14.18K322A was used to direct γδ T cell responses towards CSC-like cells.
  • Cytokine Induction: The role of γδ T cell-derived cytokines, particularly Interferon-gamma (IFN-γ), in upregulating MHC class I and CD54 on CSC-like cells was investigated to improve CD8+ T cell targeting.
  • Flow Cytometry: Used extensively to analyze cell surface marker expression (CD44, CD24, GD2, MHC class I, CD54), T cell activation (CD107a mobilization), and intracellular cytokine production (IFN-γ).
  • Xenograft Models: Immunodeficient mice were used to assess tumor formation, growth, and metastasis of CSC-like and non-CSC cells.
  • Histology and Immunohistochemistry: Tumors were analyzed for differentiation markers and mesenchymal/epithelial characteristics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes established human cell lines and primary human T cells.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CSC-like cells are inherently resistant to both γδ T cells and CD8+ T cells: This highlights the challenge of targeting these cells with conventional immune approaches.
  • FPPS inhibition is a potent sensitizer for γδ T cell recognition of CSCs: Targeting FPPS with zoledronate or shRNA effectively overcomes CSC resistance to γδ T cells, likely by inducing stress signals recognized by these unconventional T cells.
  • γδ T cells can "prime" CSCs for CD8+ T cell attack: γδ T cells secrete IFN-γ, which upregulates MHC class I and CD54 on CSC-like cells. This makes them more visible and susceptible to killing by antigen-specific CD8+ T cells. This is a crucial finding for synergistic targeting.
  • Anti-GD2 antibodies can direct γδ T cell responses: This provides an alternative strategy for targeting CSCs, particularly those expressing GD2, by leveraging antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity.
  • A two-pronged approach is key: The study strongly suggests that combining the innate-like, non-MHC-restricted targeting of γδ T cells with the adaptive, tumor-specific killing by CD8+ T cells offers a powerful synergistic strategy for eradicating CSCs.

Key Results

  • CSC-like cells exhibit enhanced tumorigenicity and metastatic potential compared to non-CSCs in xenograft models.
  • Zoledronate treatment significantly increased γδ T cell-mediated killing of CSC-like cells (e.g., >75% specific killing at 10:1 E:T ratio compared to <25% for untreated).
  • γδ T cell-conditioned medium (rich in IFN-γ) upregulated MHC class I and CD54 on CSC-like cells, leading to a substantial increase in their susceptibility to CD8+ T cell-mediated killing. For instance, specific killing by CD8+ T cells increased from around 25% to over 75% at a 10:1 E:T ratio after γδ T cell treatment.
  • Anti-GD2 antibody treatment also enhanced γδ T cell responses towards CSC-like cells, as evidenced by increased degranulation and IFN-γ secretion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Use of an in vitro model: While HMLER-derived CSC-like cells provide a valuable model, they are not primary human breast CSCs. The authors acknowledge that future work will aim to validate these findings using primary CSCs.
  • Surrogate antigens: The study utilized viral epitopes (FluM1) as surrogate antigens for CD8+ T cell targeting. Future research needs to focus on relevant tumor-associated antigens for more clinically applicable strategies.
  • Clinical translation: The findings provide a strong preclinical rationale, but further studies are needed to translate these synergistic approaches into effective clinical immunotherapies. This includes testing combinations of γδ T cell activators (like zoledronate) with adoptive T cell therapies or other immunomodulatory agents.

Summary updated

Abstract

The inherent resistance of cancer stem cells (CSCs) to existing therapies has largely hampered the development of effective treatments for advanced malignancy. To help develop novel immunotherapy approaches that efficiently target CSCs, an experimental model allowing reliable distinction of CSCs and non-CSCs was set up to study their interaction with non-MHC-restricted γδ T cells and antigen-specific CD8<sup>+</sup> T cells. Stable lines with characteristics of breast CSC-like cells were generated from ras-transformed human mammary epithelial (HMLER) cells as confirmed by their CD44<sup>hi</sup> CD24<sup>lo</sup> GD2<sup>+</sup> phenotype, their mesenchymal morphology in culture and their capacity to form mammospheres under non-adherent conditions, as well as their potent tumorigenicity, self-renewal and differentiation in xenografted mice. The resistance of CSC-like cells to γδ T cells could be overcome by inhibition of farnesyl pyrophosphate synthase (FPPS) through pretreatment with zoledronate or with FPPS-targeting short hairpin RNA. γδ T cells induced upregulation of MHC class I and CD54/ICAM-1 on CSC-like cells and thereby increased the susceptibility to antigen-specific killing by CD8<sup>+</sup> T cells. Alternatively, γδ T-cell responses could be specifically directed against CSC-like cells using the humanised anti-GD2 monoclonal antibody hu14.18K322A. Our findings identify a powerful synergism between MHC-restricted and non-MHC-restricted T cells in the eradication of cancer cells including breast CSCs. Our research suggests that novel immunotherapies may benefit from a two-pronged approach combining γδ T-cell and CD8<sup>+</sup> T-cell targeting strategies that triggers effective innate-like and tumour-specific adaptive responses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2017synergistic,
  author = {Hung‐Chang Chen and Noémie Joalland and John S. Bridgeman and Fouad Alchami and Ulrich Jarry and Mohd Wajid Ali Khan and Luke Piggott and Yasmin Shanneik and Jianqiang Li and Marco J. Herold and Thomas Herrmann and David A. Price and Awen Gallimore and Richard Clarkson and Emmanuel Scotet and Bernhard Moser and Matthias Eberl},
  title = {{Synergistic targeting of breast cancer stem‐like cells by human γδ T cells and CD8<sup>+</sup> T cells}},
  booktitle = {Immunology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/icb.2017.21},
}
Figure