Synergistic Mechanism of the High-Quality Development of the Urban Digital Economy from Blockchain Adoption Perspective - A Configuration Approach

Ming Xia, Zhimin Xie, Hui Lin, Xiangwu HeJ. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. Res 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how blockchain adoption drives high-quality urban digital economy development in China, moving beyond single-factor analyses to explore complex synergistic effects. Using a configuration approach (fs/QCA) and the Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) framework, it identifies distinct pathways and necessary conditions for success, offering valuable insights for policymakers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid growth of the digital economy, fueled by technologies like blockchain, presents a new engine for economic growth. However, achieving high-quality digital economy development, which goes beyond mere expansion to encompass efficiency, innovation, and sustainability, is a critical challenge. While blockchain technology is recognized for its potential to address data privacy and security concerns, its role in fostering this high-quality development is complex and not well understood. Existing research often focuses on individual factors or traditional analytical methods that fail to capture the synergistic interactions between technology, organizational, and environmental elements. This paper aims to fill this gap by exploring the multifaceted mechanisms through which blockchain adoption influences urban digital economy quality, considering how different combinations of factors lead to desired outcomes.

Methods

The study employs a fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fs/QCA) method, a powerful technique for analyzing complex causal relationships where multiple factors interact to produce an outcome. This approach is particularly suited for exploring "configurational effects," where different combinations of conditions can lead to the same result. The analysis is grounded in the Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) framework, which categorizes factors influencing technology adoption into three dimensions:

  • Technology: Blockchain service capability and blockchain knowledge accumulation.
  • Organization: Government attention allocation and government funding support.
  • Environment: Industry carrying capacity and technology R&D environment.

The fs/QCA method allows for the identification of necessary and sufficient conditions for both the presence and absence of high-quality digital economy development.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from 43 representative Chinese cities. These cities were selected based on their rankings in both blockchain development level and digital economy development. The data for the six conditional variables (blockchain service capability, blockchain knowledge accumulation, government attention allocation, government funding support, industry carrying capacity, and technology R&D environment) and the outcome variable (digital economy quality) were collected from various official sources, including government websites, patent databases, and industry reports. The digital economy quality was measured using the 2019 China City Digital Economy Index White Paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No Single Factor is Sufficient: The research highlights that no single factor in isolation guarantees high-quality digital economy development. Instead, it's the synergistic interplay of multiple elements that drives success.
  • Asymmetric Causality: The study emphasizes that the pathways leading to high-quality digital economy development are different from those leading to its absence, a key insight from QCA.
  • Government Funding is Crucial (for Absence): A significant finding is that the absence of government funding support is a necessary condition for the absence of high-quality digital economy development. This suggests that a lack of financial backing actively hinders progress.
  • Multiple Paths to Success: The study identifies three distinct configurations that lead to high-quality urban digital economy development, demonstrating that different combinations of factors can achieve the same positive outcome.

Key Results

The study identified the following key results:

  • Necessary Condition for Absence: The absence of government funding support is a necessary condition for the absence of high urban digital economy quality (consistency of 0.94).
  • Three Configurations for High-Quality Digital Economy:
    1. Knowledge-Industry Driven: Characterized by sufficient blockchain knowledge accumulation and strong industry carrying capacity.
  • Government-Service Driven: Driven by high government attention and strong blockchain service capability.
  • R&D-Service Driven: Fueled by a robust technology R&D environment and high blockchain service capability.
  • One Configuration for Absence of High-Quality Digital Economy:
    • Knowledge-R&D-Funding Inhibiting: This path is characterized by low blockchain knowledge accumulation, a poor technology R&D environment, and insufficient government funding support.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Scope of Factors: The study focused on six key factors within the TOE framework. Other factors, such as blockchain technology management capacity, citizen demand, and technology imitation, could also influence digital economy quality.
  • Cross-Sectional Data: The analysis relied on cross-sectional data, providing a snapshot in time. Future research could benefit from longitudinal data to examine the dynamic evolution of these relationships over time.
  • Data Precision: Due to data availability limitations, the measurement of some variables might not have been as precise as desired. Future studies could aim for more comprehensive and in-depth data.

The authors suggest that future work could explore these additional factors, employ longitudinal analysis, and refine data collection methods to further enhance the understanding of the complex mechanisms driving urban digital economy quality.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{xia2022synergistic,
  author = {Ming Xia and Zhimin Xie and Hui Lin and Xiangwu He},
  title = {{Synergistic Mechanism of the High-Quality Development of the Urban Digital Economy from Blockchain Adoption Perspective - A Configuration Approach}},
  journal = {J. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. Res.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jtaer17020037},
}
Figure