Syndromic Surveillance Systems for Mass Gatherings: A Scoping Review

Eliot Spector, Yahan Zhang, Yi Guo, Sarah Bost, Xi Yang, Mattia Prosperi, Yonghui Wu, Hui Shao, Jiang BianInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This scoping review examines how syndromic surveillance systems are used to monitor public health during mass gatherings. While these systems show potential for informing policy, the review found limited evidence that they reliably detect critical public health events in these high-risk scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Public health surveillance is crucial for monitoring and responding to health threats. Syndromic surveillance, which uses near-real-time data to detect disease outbreaks or adverse events earlier than traditional methods, is particularly relevant for mass gatherings. These events, like large sporting events or festivals, can strain healthcare systems due to increased population density, influx of travelers, and potential for rapid disease spread. However, there's a need to understand how effectively syndromic surveillance is implemented and its actual impact in these specific, high-stakes environments. This paper aims to fill this gap by reviewing existing literature on syndromic surveillance systems used for mass gatherings, focusing on their methodologies, preparation, and integration with existing infrastructure.

Methods

This study employed a scoping review methodology, adhering to the PRISMA-ScR guidelines. The researchers systematically searched three major databases (PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science) for relevant publications from January 2000 to January 2021. They also included two additional sources cited in relevant publications. Two reviewers independently screened titles and abstracts, with a third reviewer resolving any disagreements. Full-text articles were then assessed for eligibility. Data extraction focused on key characteristics of the syndromic surveillance systems, including data sources, processing procedures, preparation steps, and the types of mass gatherings involved. Studies were included if they described syndromic surveillance for planned gatherings with over 100 attendees, even if the term "syndromic surveillance" wasn't explicitly used, as long as they utilized real-time or near-real-time data collection based on symptom categories.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a review of existing studies and does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data Sources are Diverse but Often Centralized: Emergency departments are the most common data source, but first aid stations and event-based clinics also play a significant role. This highlights the need for integrated systems that can capture data from various points of care.
  • Custom Reporting is Prevalent: Many systems rely on custom reporting forms, suggesting a lack of standardized data collection methods across different mass gathering events.
  • Preparation is Paramount: Effective syndromic surveillance at mass gatherings requires significant preparation, including training staff, establishing collaborations between health agencies and care providers, and sometimes collecting baseline data.
  • Limited Evidence of Outbreak Detection: Despite the potential of syndromic surveillance, the review found limited evidence that these systems have reliably detected significant outbreaks during mass gathering scenarios. While systems often functioned well under increased clinical load, concrete examples of critical event detection were scarce.
  • Cross-Validation is Lacking: A significant limitation identified is the lack of contemporaneous investigation or validation of the data collected by syndromic surveillance systems. Without this, it's difficult to confirm whether detected signals warrant a public health response.

Key Results

The search yielded 19 relevant studies for data extraction. Key findings include:

  • Data Sources: 53% of studies used hospital emergency departments, 32% used first aid stations/mobile clinics, and 21% used general hospitals/care sites. 42% utilized multiple types of care sites.
  • Event Types: Syndromic surveillance was applied to sporting events (42%), religious gatherings (26%), political/cultural events (21%), and one natural event (5%).
  • Data Processing: Most data was reviewed daily (42% of studies). Some systems processed data in real-time (16%), while others reviewed it retrospectively (10%).
  • Preparation: Training was a common preparation step (63% of studies). Baseline data collection was noted in 26% of studies. 47% of systems were enhancements of pre-existing infrastructure.
  • Syndromic Profiles: The scope of syndromic indicators varied widely, with some studies focusing on specific regions or diseases. Event-related tags were used in some systems to link patient visits to the gathering.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Variability in Study Design: The high variability in study designs made it difficult to extract and present standardized information.
  • Lack of Specificity: Some studies lacked detailed information about the surveillance systems.
  • Limited Health Outcome Analysis: A thorough examination of the health outcomes measured by each system in relation to the mass gathering events was not attempted.

Future work should focus on:

  • Verifying Impact: Further research is needed to conclusively determine the verifiable impact of syndromic surveillance on population health during mass gatherings.
  • Health and Disease Profile Analysis: More in-depth analysis of health and disease profiles at mass gathering events, in conjunction with syndromic surveillance data, is necessary.
  • Cross-Validation Strategies: Developing and implementing robust methods for cross-validating syndromic surveillance data with other independent data sources is crucial to ensure the reliability of detected signals and justify potential public health responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Syndromic surveillance involves the near-real-time collection of data from a potential multitude of sources to detect outbreaks of disease or adverse health events earlier than traditional forms of public health surveillance. The purpose of the present study is to elucidate the role of syndromic surveillance during mass gathering scenarios. In the present review, the use of syndromic surveillance for mass gathering scenarios is described, including characteristics such as methodologies of data collection and analysis, degree of preparation and collaboration, and the degree to which prior surveillance infrastructure is utilized. Nineteen publications were included for data extraction. The most common data source for the included syndromic surveillance systems was emergency departments, with first aid stations and event-based clinics also present. Data were often collected using custom reporting forms. While syndromic surveillance can potentially serve as a method of informing public health policy regarding specific mass gatherings based on the profile of syndromes ascertained, the present review does not indicate that this form of surveillance is a reliable method of detecting potentially critical public health events during mass gathering scenarios.
BibTeX
@article{spector2022syndromic,
  author = {Eliot Spector and Yahan Zhang and Yi Guo and Sarah Bost and Xi Yang and Mattia Prosperi and Yonghui Wu and Hui Shao and Jiang Bian},
  title = {{Syndromic Surveillance Systems for Mass Gatherings: A Scoping Review}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19084673},
}
Figure