Synaptic function and sensory processing in ZDHHC9-associated neurodevelopmental disorder: a mechanistic account

Rebeca Ianov Vitanov, Jascha Achterberg, Danyal Akarca, Duncan E. Astle, Kate BakerbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Loss-of-function variants in the ZDHHC9 gene are associated with X-linked intellectual disability (XLID), rolandic epilepsy, and language difficulties. While cellular studies suggest these variants disrupt the balance of excitatory and inhibitory (E:I) synaptic signaling, the link to macroscopic brain function remains unclear. This study integrates human magnetoencephalography (MEG) data with a recurrent neural network (RNN) model to investigate the neural mechanisms underlying ZDHHC9-associated sensory processing differences. We found that individuals with ZDHHC9 variants exhibit larger auditory evoked response amplitudes and delayed peak latencies. By perturbing an RNN trained to mimic human brain activity, we demonstrate that a reduction in neural inhibition—rather than an increase in excitation—recapitulates these clinical observations. These results provide a mechanistic account of how synaptic-level alterations translate to altered cortical dynamics in neurodevelopmental disorders.

Introduction

The ZDHHC9 gene encodes a palmitoyltransferase essential for the post-translational modification of proteins involved in synaptic plasticity and dendritic growth. Mutations in this gene are a known cause of X-linked intellectual disability (XLID) and are frequently comorbid with rolandic epilepsy and speech impairments. Previous research in animal models has indicated that ZDHHC9 deficiency leads to a reduction in inhibitory synapse density and altered E:I balance. However, bridging the gap between these microscopic synaptic changes and the macroscopic neurophysiological patterns observed in patients has been a significant challenge.

This study addresses this gap by combining empirical neuroimaging with computational modeling. By using an "AI sandbox" approach, the researchers sought to determine if the sensory processing differences observed in patients could be directly attributed to a specific failure in neural inhibition.

Empirical Findings: MEG and Sensory Processing

The researchers recorded brain activity from 15 participants (8 with ZDHHC9 variants and 7 age-matched controls) using a "roving oddball" auditory paradigm. In this task, participants listen to sequences of tones where a "deviant" frequency occasionally interrupts a series of "standard" tones. This paradigm allows for the measurement of the magnetic mismatch negativity (mMMN), a biomarker of the brain's ability to detect change and update its internal models of the environment.

The MEG data revealed distinct differences in the ZDHHC9 group:

  • Increased Amplitude: Auditory evoked fields (AEFs) were approximately 1.13x larger in magnitude compared to controls.
  • Delayed Latency: There was a significant delay in peak response, with the ZDHHC9 group peaking roughly 44ms later than the control group.
  • Enhanced Mismatch Negativity: The mMMN amplitude was increased, suggesting that the ZDHHC9 brain exhibits a hyper-responsive reaction to sensory change.

Computational Modeling: The RNN as a Virtual Patient

To test the hypothesis that these differences stem from reduced inhibition, the authors developed a discrete-time Recurrent Neural Network (RNN). The RNN was trained to predict the auditory evoked responses of the control group using synthetic training data generated from grand-average AEFs. Once the model could accurately simulate "healthy" brain activity, the researchers performed three perturbation experiments to simulate potential disease states:

  1. Experiment 1 (Reduced Inhibition): Inhibitory weights within the network were systematically weakened (by 0.5% to 4%).
  2. Experiment 2 (Increased Excitation): Excitatory weights were strengthened by the same levels.
  3. Experiment 3 (Random Perturbation): Network weights were altered randomly as a control.

Results of Model Perturbations

The results of the computational modeling were striking. Only the reduction of inhibitory weights (Experiment 1) successfully replicated the empirical findings from the ZDHHC9 patient group. This perturbation led to a linear increase in predicted response amplitude and a corresponding increase in peak latency (4–8ms in the model).

In contrast, increasing excitatory weights (Experiment 2) did not produce stable, brain-like activity. Instead, it often led to "runaway excitation," where the model’s internal states became chaotic and produced exponential spikes in activity. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) of the RNN’s internal states confirmed that while the "inhibitory-reduced" model remained stable, the "excitatory-increased" model's internal representations drifted into non-functional states. This suggests that the ZDHHC9 phenotype is specifically characterized by a lack of inhibitory "brakes" rather than a simple increase in excitatory "gas."

Discussion and Implications

The integration of RNN modeling with MEG data provides a powerful framework for understanding rare genetic disorders. The model's internal hierarchy also mirrored biological reality: the distinction between "standard" and "deviant" tones became more pronounced in the later hidden layers of the network, suggesting that higher-level cortical processing is more sensitive to these E:I imbalances.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the study provides a compelling mechanistic account, it is limited by a small clinical sample size—a common challenge in rare disease research. Additionally, the RNN nodes represent general neural populations rather than specific cell types. Future work could incorporate "Dale’s Law" to more accurately model separate excitatory and inhibitory neuron populations. Furthermore, while this study perturbed a "mature" network, future research should explore how these genetic variants affect the learning process itself during development.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that reduced neural inhibition is a plausible mechanism for the altered sensory processing observed in ZDHHC9-associated neurodevelopmental disorders. By using AI to bridge the gap between synaptic dysfunction and systems-level neurophysiology, researchers can better understand the functional consequences of genetic mutations and potentially identify new targets for therapeutic intervention.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Loss-of-function ZDHHC9 variants are associated with X-linked intellectual disability (XLID), rolandic epilepsy (RE) and developmental language difficulties. This study integrates human neurophysiological data with a computational model to identify a potential neural mechanism explaining ZDHHC9 -associated differences in cortical function and cognition. Magnetoencephalography (MEG) data was collected during an auditory roving oddball paradigm from eight individuals with a ZDHHC9 loss-of-function variant (ZDHHC9 group) and seven age-matched individuals without neurological or neurodevelopmental difficulties (control group). Evoked responses to auditory stimulation were larger in amplitude and showed a later peak latency in the ZDHHC9 group but demonstrated normal stimulus-specific properties. Magnetic mismatch negativity (mMMN) amplitude was also increased in the ZDHHC9 group, reflected by stronger neural activation during deviant processing relative to the standard. A recurrent neural network (RNN) model was trained to mimic recapitulate group-level auditory evoked responses, and subsequently perturbed to test the hypothesised impact of ZDHHC9 -driven synaptic dysfunction on neural dynamics. Results of model perturbations showed that reducing inhibition levels by weakening inhibitory weights recapitulates the observed group differences in evoked responses. Stronger reductions in inhibition levels resulted in increased peak amplitude and peak latency of RNN prediction relative to the pre-perturbation predictions. Control experiments in which excitatory connections were strengthened by the same levels did not result in consistently stable activity or AEF-like RNN predictions. Together, these results suggest that reduced inhibition is a plausible mechanism by which loss of ZDHHC9 function alters cortical dynamics during sensory processing. Abstract Figure Graphical Abstract In the current study, we employed a bottom-up approach to study the impact of synaptic-level alterations associated with ZDHHC9 variants on cortical function in healthy and ZDHHC9 -deficient participants. To achieve this, a recurrent neural network model was developed to recapitulate MEG-derived auditory evoked responses and subsequently perturbed in order to determine effects on resulting dynamics. We show that reduced network inhibition recapitulates empirical observations, specifically increased response amplitudes, delayed peak latencies and increased mismatch negativity. These results offered a mechanistic account on the impact of ZDHHC9 -associated synaptic alterations on auditory processing.
BibTeX
@misc{vitanov2024synaptic,
  author = {Rebeca Ianov Vitanov and Jascha Achterberg and Danyal Akarca and Duncan E. Astle and Kate Baker},
  title = {{Synaptic function and sensory processing in ZDHHC9-associated neurodevelopmental disorder: a mechanistic account}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.03.28.587155},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure