Symmetry Breaking in Self-Assembled Nanoassemblies

Yutao Sang, Minghua LiuSymmetry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This review explores the fascinating phenomenon of symmetry breaking in self-assembled nanoassemblies, where achiral molecules can spontaneously form chiral structures. It highlights how understanding and controlling this process is crucial for unraveling the mystery of biological homochirality and for designing advanced chiral materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The origin of homochirality in biological systems, where life predominantly uses L-amino acids and D-sugars, remains a profound mystery. While molecular chirality is well-understood, the transition to homochirality at a larger scale is less clear. This paper addresses the question of how symmetry breaking, a process where a system loses its symmetry, can occur at the supramolecular level, leading to the formation of chiral assemblies from achiral building blocks. This phenomenon is not only fundamental to understanding biological homochirality but also key to developing new functional chiral materials. The challenge lies in not just observing symmetry breaking but also in controlling and amplifying the resulting chirality to achieve homochiral assemblies.

Methods

The paper reviews various approaches to induce and control symmetry breaking in self-assembled systems. These methods span different physical and chemical strategies:

  • Physical Control Methods:
    • Viedma Ripening: A process that can deracemize solid-state crystals, transforming a racemic mixture into a single chiral form.
  • Hydrodynamic Macro- and Micro-Vortices: The application of stirring or vortex motion, often in microfluidic devices, to induce chiral alignment during self-assembly.
  • Superchiral Light (SCL): The interference of circularly polarized light beams to create a light field that can enhance enantioselective processes.
  • Rotational and Magnetic Forces: Utilizing external forces like rotation and magnetic fields to influence the orientation and assembly of molecules.
  • Chemical Control Methods:
    • Chiral Dopants/Additives: Introducing small amounts of chiral molecules to guide the self-assembly of achiral components.
  • Chiral Solvents: Using chiral solvents that can induce and maintain chirality in the self-assembled structures even after the solvent is removed.
  • Noncovalent Interactions: The paper emphasizes the crucial role of various noncovalent interactions, including hydrogen bonding, π-π stacking, and coordination bonds, in driving and stabilizing chiral self-assembly.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a review of existing research and does not present new experimental data or datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symmetry Breaking is Ubiquitous: Symmetry breaking is not limited to specific systems but occurs across diverse self-assembly scenarios, including crystals, liquid crystals, interfaces (air/solution, solution/solid), and supramolecular gels.
  • Achiral Molecules Can Be Chiral: A key takeaway is that even molecules lacking inherent chirality can form chiral aggregates or crystals due to symmetry breaking during self-assembly.
  • Noncovalent Interactions are Key Drivers: Hydrogen bonding, π-π stacking, and coordination bonds are fundamental forces that orchestrate the formation of chiral supramolecular structures from achiral building blocks.
  • Controlling Chirality is Possible: While spontaneous symmetry breaking often leads to a racemic mixture of chiral assemblies, various physical and chemical methods can be employed to bias the process towards a specific handedness or even achieve homochirality.
  • Synergistic Approaches are Powerful: Combining multiple control methods (e.g., CPL irradiation with grinding) often yields more effective and controlled chiral outcomes than single methods alone.
  • Biological Homochirality Connection: The study of symmetry breaking in synthetic systems offers valuable insights into potential mechanisms for the origin of homochirality in biological systems.

Key Results

The paper highlights successful demonstrations of symmetry breaking and chiral control across various systems:

  • Chiral Crystals from Achiral Molecules: Examples like sodium chlorate (NaClO3) forming chiral crystals, and tartrate crystals exhibiting optical activity even after dissolution, showcase symmetry breaking in the solid state.
  • Chiral Assemblies at Interfaces: Langmuir-Blodgett films of achiral amphiphiles forming chiral spiral nanoarchitectures and 2D nanoporous assemblies with chiral domains have been observed.
  • Chiral Supramolecular Gels: Achiral molecules forming optically active supramolecular gels with predominant helical handedness have been reported, driven by interactions like hydrogen bonding and π-π stacking.
  • Vortex-Induced Chirality: Vortex mixing has been shown to significantly amplify supramolecular chirality, leading to near-unity homochiral assemblies from achiral molecules.
  • Superchiral Light Enhancement: Superchiral light has demonstrated enhanced enantioselective polymerization of achiral monomers, leading to more helical structures.
  • High Chirality Control: Microvortices generated by microfluidic devices have achieved up to 96% chirality control in supramolecular gels.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Quantitative Analysis of Enantiomeric Excess: While microscopic chirality can be observed, quantitatively analyzing the enantiomeric excess, especially in dynamic systems, remains a challenge.
  • Achieving Complete Homochirality: Even with advanced techniques, achieving complete homochirality in exclusively achiral systems is still difficult, and asymmetric environments are generally necessary.
  • Understanding Initial Chiral Bias: The precise origin of the initial chiral bias in biomolecules is still debated, and further research is needed to reconcile experimental findings with theoretical models.
  • Developing Advanced Techniques: The authors emphasize the need for advanced techniques to better follow the symmetry breaking process and the amplification of supramolecular chirality.
  • Combinatorial Approaches: The review suggests that combining two or more control processes is often more effective for achieving controlled chirality and subsequent amplification, pointing towards future research directions in integrated strategies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{sang2019symmetry,
  author = {Yutao Sang and Minghua Liu},
  title = {{Symmetry Breaking in Self-Assembled Nanoassemblies}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/sym11080950},
}
Figure