Abstract
This paper reframes Albert Einstein’s discovery of special relativity as a sophisticated machine learning problem, where physical symmetries act as an inductive "bias" that constrains the search for physical theories. By implementing a computational framework consisting of the Erlanger program and the BEGAT algorithm, we demonstrate how an automated system can detect inconsistencies between existing biases and new empirical data, derive the Lorentz transformations, and reformulate classical mechanics as a limiting approximation of relativistic physics.
Introduction: The Paradox of Strong Bias
In machine learning theory, a fundamental tension exists between the breadth of a search space and the efficiency of convergence. To derive a theory from experimental evidence within a reasonable timeframe, a system requires a "strong bias"—a restricted search space that prioritizes certain hypotheses over others. However, the stronger the bias, the higher the risk that the "correct" theory is excluded from the search space entirely.
This paper explores how a discovery system can escape this trap by reasoning about and dynamically updating its own bias. Using the history of physics as a case study, we analyze Einstein’s transition from the Newtonian bias of absolute space to the relativistic bias of spacetime. We formalize this "paradox-breaking" strategy into a computationally tractable algorithm capable of unifying inconsistent theories through symmetry-based reasoning.
Methods: The Erlanger Program and BEGAT
The research introduces a "rational reconstruction" of scientific discovery through two primary computational tools designed to manage the relationship between physical laws and transformation groups.
1. The Erlanger Program
Developed in Mathematica, the Erlanger program utilizes the Invariance Principle to evaluate the consistency between a physical theory and a specific group of transformations (the bias). When a theory—such as the constancy of the speed of light—is found to be inconsistent with a prevailing bias (such as Galilean transformations), the system invokes the DeriveNewBias algorithm. This algorithm treats the space of possible biases as a lattice, searching for a new set of transformations—specifically the Lorentz group—that satisfies the new empirical constraints while maintaining structural integrity.
2. BEGAT (BiasEd Generalization of Approximate Theories)
Once a new bias is established, the system must reconcile it with legacy knowledge. The BEGAT algorithm employs Limit Homomorphisms to treat older theories as special cases of newer, more general frameworks. By "rotating" Newtonian equations through the newly derived relativistic bias, BEGAT can derive consistent laws, such as relativistic velocity composition, by treating the original Newtonian addition ($v_1 + v_2$) as a limit point where $v \to 0$.
Key Insights: Symmetry as Inductive Bias
The core contribution of this work is the mapping of physical principles to machine learning concepts:
- Symmetry = Bias: The physical requirement that "laws must remain invariant for all observers" is functionally identical to a bias in machine learning. It prunes the space of possible physical laws to a manageable subset.
- Mutual Bootstrapping: Discovery is modeled as a co-evolutionary process between the hypothesis space for biases and the hypothesis space for theories. The invariance principle serves as the bridge that constrains both simultaneously.
- Contravariance of Consistency: A structural property identified in the research suggests that weaker physical theories (those with fewer deductive consequences) are consistent with larger sets of transformations. This allows the system to "relax" a theory to identify a broader bias, which is then filtered to find the correct specific transformations.
- Primal-Dual Learning: The discovery strategy is proposed as a form of primal-dual optimization. The system incrementally converges on an optimal model by alternating updates between the theory space (primal) and the bias space (dual).
Results and Automated Derivations
The computational framework successfully replicated key milestones of 20th-century physics:
- Automated Derivation of Lorentz Transformations: Starting from Newtonian physics and the postulate of the constancy of the speed of light, the Erlanger program successfully derived the Lorentz transformations without human intervention.
- Theory Reformulation: The BEGAT algorithm successfully derived the relativistic velocity composition formula: $$V_{rel} = \frac{v_1 + v_2}{1 + \frac{v_1 v_2}{c^2}}$$ This was achieved by treating the Newtonian addition of velocities as a limit point and applying the new relativistic bias to the underlying algebraic structure.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the system demonstrates the tractability of Einstein’s "genius" through symbolic algebra and group theory, several challenges remain. The Erlanger program currently struggles with Subgroup Factoring; it cannot yet automatically isolate subgroups of transformations (like spatial rotations) that are already consistent with new data, requiring occasional manual guidance.
Furthermore, the BEGAT algorithm faces Ontological Ambiguity. Because the mapping functions (homomorphisms) between old and new domains are underconstrained, the system requires specific assumptions about how terms like "force" or "mass" translate across biases. Future work will explore applying this primal-dual learning framework to non-physics domains, such as linguistics, to determine if the symmetry-as-bias approach can generalize to other forms of human knowledge acquisition.
Summary updated