TL;DR
This paper introduces new symmetric linear programming (LP) relaxations for the minimum cut problem. These relaxations are particularly interesting because they provide exact solutions for minimum cuts on Hamiltonian cycles and can be used to strengthen existing LP relaxations for the Traveling Salesperson Problem (TSP).
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The minimum cut problem is a fundamental problem in computer science with many applications. While efficient algorithms exist for some variants (like s-t cut and global minimum cut), the fixed-size partition minimum cut problem is NP-hard. A common approach to tackle such problems is through linear programming relaxations. The challenge lies in finding LP formulations that are both compact (have a polynomial number of variables and constraints) and theoretically useful. Specifically, this paper explores LP formulations that are "symmetric" (meaning the feasible region remains the same under node permutations) and have a "Hamiltonian cycle property" (their minimum value on Hamiltonian cycles is a constant). The latter property is crucial for strengthening TSP relaxations. The authors aim to find smaller, symmetric LP relaxations for minimum cut and to leverage these for better TSP solutions.
Methods
The core of this paper is the development of several new LP relaxations for the minimum cut problem, denoted as $\alpha$-LP, $\beta$-LP, and $\gamma$-LP. These LPs are designed to be symmetric and to possess the Hamiltonian cycle property.
- $\alpha$-LP: This is the primary LP introduced. It's a symmetric relaxation for the minimum $\alpha$-cut problem (where one side of the cut has a fixed size $\alpha$). A key feature is that it includes only one typical min-cut constraint, with other constraints resembling those used for max-cut relaxations.
- $\beta$-LP: This is a relaxation of the $\alpha$-LP, achieved by allowing the partition size $\alpha$ to be a convex combination of two consecutive integers.
- $\gamma$-LP: This is a further relaxation of the $\beta$-LP, where $\alpha$ is expressed as a convex combination of two integers with a specific relationship. This allows for a logarithmic number of values for $\alpha$, leading to a potentially smaller set of LPs to solve.
The paper also utilizes techniques like:
- Lift-and-project: Used to derive symmetric LP formulations.
- Duality: Employed to relate primal and dual LPs and derive bounds.
- Lovász splitting off: A technique used to analyze properties of cuts and LP solutions.
- Convex hull: Used to understand the feasible regions of the LPs.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical LP formulations and their properties on general graphs and specific graph structures (like Hamiltonian cycles), rather than empirical evaluation on datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Symmetric LPs for Min-Cut: The paper successfully constructs symmetric LP relaxations for the minimum cut problem, which are often easier to analyze and can lead to more efficient algorithms.
- Hamiltonian Cycle Property as a Bridge to TSP: A crucial insight is that LPs satisfying the "Hamiltonian cycle property" can be used to create stronger LP relaxations for the Traveling Salesperson Problem (TSP) than the standard subtour elimination relaxation. This property essentially means the LP's minimum value on any Hamiltonian cycle is a constant.
- Smallest Known LP for Min-Cut: The authors present an $\alpha$-LP that, under certain conditions, is the smallest known symmetric LP formulation for the minimum cut problem that achieves a 9/8-approximation or better.
- Unusual Constraint Structure: The $\alpha$-LP's constraint set is noteworthy, featuring only one standard min-cut constraint and several others typically found in max-cut relaxations.
- Trade-off between Exactness and Size: The $\beta$-LP and $\gamma$-LP demonstrate how relaxing exactness (especially on Hamiltonian cycles) can lead to smaller or more manageable LP formulations.
Key Results
- The proposed $\alpha$-LP provides the optimal solution for the fixed-size partition minimum cut problem when the input graph is an unweighted Hamiltonian cycle.
- The $\beta$-LP and $\gamma$-LP also satisfy the Hamiltonian cycle property, with the $\gamma$-LP offering a potentially more efficient approximation.
- The paper shows that if an LP satisfies the Hamiltonian cycle property and includes triangle inequalities, it either provides an exact minimum cut formulation or leads to a TSP relaxation strictly stronger than the subtour relaxation.
- The $\alpha$-LP is shown to be an exact formulation for the minimum cut problem on Hamiltonian cycles for any partition size $\alpha \le n/2$.
- The paper provides evidence that the $\alpha$-LP can be used to strengthen TSP relaxations, potentially yielding a compact relaxation stronger than the subtour relaxation.
Limitations and Future Work
- General Graph Performance: While the $\alpha$-LP is exact on Hamiltonian cycles, its performance on general graphs (i.e., whether it always yields at least the minimum global cut) is not definitively established for all cases.
- Strengthening TSP Relaxation: A key open question is whether the $\alpha$-LP and $\beta$-LP always provide a lower bound for the minimum cut or if they can always be used to strengthen the subtour elimination linear program for TSP.
- Exactness of $\gamma$-LP: The $\gamma$-LP is an approximation to the $\beta$-LP and thus not exact for minimum cut.
- Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the remaining open questions regarding the lower bound properties of the $\alpha$-LP and $\beta$-LP and their ability to strengthen TSP relaxations. They also highlight the potential of the $\gamma$-LP for providing approximate minimum cuts with a more manageable number of LP programs.
Summary updated