Symmetric extension of two-qubit states

Jianxin Chen, Zhengfeng Ji, David W. Kribs, Norbert Lütkenhaus, Bei ZengPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The property of symmetric extendibility is a cornerstone of quantum information theory, influencing entanglement detection, secure key distillation, and the characterization of quantum channels. While determining extendibility previously required complex numerical optimization, this work establishes a definitive analytic criterion for any two-qubit state ${\rho}_{AB}$. We prove that a state is symmetrically extendible if and only if it satisfies the inequality $\text{tr}(\rho_B^2) \ge \text{tr}(\rho_{AB}^2) - 4\sqrt{\text{det } \rho_{AB}}$. This result provides a simple "pencil-and-paper" test for properties that were once computationally intensive to verify, and solves the bosonic three-representability problem for the two-body reduced density matrix.

Introduction

In quantum mechanics, the principle of "monogamy of entanglement" dictates that quantum correlations cannot be freely shared among multiple parties. If particle A is maximally entangled with particle B, it cannot be simultaneously entangled with a third particle B'. Symmetric extendibility formalizes a specific version of this constraint: a bipartite state $\rho_{AB}$ is symmetrically extendible if there exists a tripartite state $\rho_{ABB'}$ such that the marginal states $\rho_{AB}$ and $\rho_{AB'}$ are identical.

This property is a vital tool in several domains of quantum information:

  1. Entanglement Testing: Symmetric extendibility provides a hierarchy of tests to detect entangled states. If a state cannot be symmetrically extended, it is guaranteed to be entangled.
  2. Quantum Key Distribution (QKD): Symmetric extendibility is a fundamental limit for security. If an eavesdropper (Eve) can hold a symmetric extension B' of the state shared by Alice (A) and Bob (B), she can obtain the same information as Bob, making it impossible to distill a secret key via one-way communication.
  3. Quantum Channels: It helps identify "anti-degradable" channels—those that have zero quantum capacity because they effectively "clone" information to the environment.

The Challenge of Characterization

Historically, determining whether a given state $\rho_{AB}$ possessed a symmetric extension required Semidefinite Programming (SDP). While SDP is a powerful numerical tool, it acts as a "black box," offering little physical intuition and no closed-form solution. The search for an analytic condition—especially for the fundamental two-qubit case—remained a significant open problem, as the general "Quantum Marginal Problem" is known to be QMA-complete (the quantum equivalent of NP-hard).

Methodology: Geometry and Physics

The authors moved beyond numerical simulations by treating the set of all symmetrically extendible states as a convex body. Their approach involved several key theoretical pillars:

  • Geometric Analysis: They characterized the boundary of the set of extendible states and identified "supporting hyperplanes" (linear constraints) defined by specific Hamiltonians.
  • Physical Mapping: They linked the existence of an extension to the ground-state space of a three-qubit Hamiltonian $H = H_{AB} + H_{AB'}$. If the ground state energy is zero, the extension exists.
  • Matrix Calculus: Using Jacobi’s formula for the derivative of a determinant, the authors analyzed how the state changes near the boundary of the extendible set.

The Fundamental Result

The central achievement of this research is the proof of a simple, necessary, and sufficient condition for the symmetric extendibility of two-qubit states. A state $\rho_{AB}$ is extendible if and only if: $$\text{tr}(\rho_B^2) \ge \text{tr}(\rho_{AB}^2) - 4\sqrt{\text{det } \rho_{AB}}$$

This formula transforms a complex optimization problem into a straightforward calculation involving the purity of the marginal state ($\text{tr}(\rho_B^2)$), the purity of the total state ($\text{tr}(\rho_{AB}^2)$), and the determinant of the density matrix. The authors successfully proved that this condition is not just necessary, but sufficient, confirming a long-standing conjecture.

Key Applications

  • Werner States: The result provides a definitive bound for Werner states, showing they lose the ability to support one-way secure key distillation when their fidelity drops to $3/4$.
  • Channel Theory: It provides the first full analytic characterization for anti-degradable qubit channels.
  • Bosonic Three-Representability: The paper solves this specific problem for the two-body reduced density matrix, a significant result for quantum chemistry.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this result is a milestone for two-qubit systems, the authors acknowledge that this simple "spectral" characterization (based only on the eigenvalues and traces of the state) is unlikely to work for higher-dimensional systems (qudits). In larger systems, the relative orientation of the state in Hilbert space matters as much as its eigenvalues.

However, the geometric approach established here—focusing on the convexity and symmetry of the state space—provides a potential roadmap for finding approximate bounds or more efficient numerical tests for larger, more complex quantum systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bipartite state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}$ is symmetric extendible if there exists a tripartite state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB{B}^{\ensuremath{'}}}$ whose $AB$ and $A{B}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ marginal states are both identical to ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}$. Symmetric extendibility of bipartite states is of vital importance in quantum information because of its central role in separability tests, one-way distillation of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen pairs, one-way distillation of secure keys, quantum marginal problems, and antidegradable quantum channels. We establish a simple analytic characterization for symmetric extendibility of any two-qubit quantum state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}$; specifically, $\mathrm{tr}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B}^{2})\ensuremath{\ge}\mathrm{tr}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}^{2})\ensuremath{-}4\sqrt{det{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}}$. As a special case we solve the bosonic three-representability problem for the two-body reduced density matrix.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2014symmetric,
  author = {Jianxin Chen and Zhengfeng Ji and David W. Kribs and Norbert Lütkenhaus and Bei Zeng},
  title = {{Symmetric extension of two-qubit states}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.90.032318},
}
Figure