Symbolic Performance and Learning in Continuous Environments

AAAI 1996

TL;DR

This paper introduces SPLICE, a novel symbolic architecture for agents learning to achieve goals in continuous environments. By combining a performance module for action selection with a learning module that generates new action mappings from experience, SPLICE offers a more interpretable and potentially more robust alternative to purely numerical control methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional approaches to control in dynamic, continuous environments often rely on complex numerical methods. While effective, these methods can be opaque, making it difficult to understand why an agent takes a particular action or how to integrate them with other symbolic reasoning systems like planning or natural language understanding. This paper addresses the challenge of developing an agent that can learn to perform tasks in continuous environments using a symbolic architecture, aiming to bridge the gap between symbolic AI and real-world control problems. The authors propose that a symbolic approach can offer advantages in terms of interpretability and extensibility.

Methods

The core of the proposed system is SPLICE (Symbolic Performance & Learning in Continuous Environments). SPLICE consists of two main modules:

  • Performance Module: This module is responsible for selecting an action based on the agent's current state and goals. It achieves this by:
  • Symbolic Mapping: Translating continuous, quantitative state variables and goals into hierarchical symbolic regions of varying generality.
  • Action Search: Searching through learned action mappings, from specific to general, to find one that matches the current symbolic situation and goals.
  • Qualitative Domain Model: If no direct action mapping is found, a qualitative domain model is used to suggest an action.
  • Action Execution: The suggested action is then executed.
  • Learning Module: This module enables SPLICE to improve its performance over time. After an action is taken and the deadline for achieving a goal is reached, the learning module:
  • Evaluates Outcome: Assesses the effect of the action.
  • Creates New Mapping: Generates a new action mapping (a new condition and a new action) based on failures. Failures are categorized as either overgeneral goal conditions or overgeneral state conditions.
  • Action Interpolation: The new action is defined as a linear interpolation of the two closest results that straddled the current goal.

A key aspect of SPLICE is its reliance on "seed" qualitative knowledge and its ability to learn through experimentation, rather than requiring explicit domain law equations.

Datasets

The paper describes testing SPLICE on three successively more detailed and complex automotive simulations. These simulations serve as the "datasets" for evaluating the agent's performance and learning capabilities. The paper does not introduce new, publicly available datasets but rather uses these simulated environments to demonstrate the system's effectiveness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symbolic Control for Continuous Environments: The paper demonstrates that a symbolic approach can be effectively applied to learning and control in continuous, dynamic environments, offering an alternative to purely numerical methods.
  • Interpretability Advantage: By using symbolic representations, SPLICE's decision-making process is inherently more interpretable than that of black-box numerical controllers.
  • Learning from Failure: The system's ability to generate new action mappings from failed attempts, by identifying overgeneral conditions, is a crucial mechanism for adaptation and improvement.
  • Scalability with Complexity: The results suggest that SPLICE's learning rate is not significantly impacted by increased domain detail and complexity, a promising characteristic for real-world applications.

Key Results

The paper presents a qualitative and graphical result in Figure 1, illustrating SPLICE's performance in three different automotive simulation domains. The graph shows "Control Adjustments" (presumably a measure of how much the agent had to adjust its control, like throttle setting) over "Problems" (learning steps).

  • Performance Improvement: In all three domains, the agent's performance improves over time, requiring fewer control adjustments as it learns.
  • Robustness to Complexity: The learning curves for Domain 1, Domain 2, and Domain 3 are shown to be similar, indicating that the added detail and complexity of domains 2 and 3 did not slow down the learning rate. This suggests SPLICE is robust to increasing environmental complexity.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and outline promising future directions:

  • Current Mapping Scheme: The current research has focused on learning action mappings and left-region mapping using a static binary division scheme. This is a simplification that could be expanded.
  • Future Work:
    • Extending SPLICE: The authors plan to extend SPLICE in several dimensions, including incorporating multiple goals and developing hierarchical control structures.
  • Realistic Environments: The ultimate objective is to demonstrate SPLICE's capabilities in complex, realistic environments, such as simulating airplane flight.
  • Integration with Other Systems: The symbolic nature of SPLICE makes it well-suited for integration with other symbolic AI systems, such as qualitative reasoning modules, which is a key area for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1996symbolic,
  title = {{Symbolic Performance and Learning in Continuous Environments}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1996},
}
Figure