Swimming efficiently by wrapping

Harinadha Gidituri, Marco Ellero, Florencio Balboa UsabiagaJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how bacteria swim using two distinct flagellar configurations: extended and wrapped. While the extended mode is faster in open environments, the wrapped mode proves more efficient in confined spaces like narrow pipes, acting like an Archimedes' screw to propel the bacterium.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bacteria are masters of navigating complex environments, often using flagella for propulsion. A fascinating behavior observed in some bacteria is the "wrapped mode," where their flagellum coils around their body. This mode is typically seen in highly viscous or confined spaces. The key question this paper addresses is: does this wrapped mode offer a functional advantage to the bacteria, particularly under confinement, compared to the more common "extended" mode where the flagellum streams behind? Understanding this could shed light on bacterial adaptation and potentially inspire new micro-robot designs.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated computational approach using the rigid multiblob method to simulate the hydrodynamics of bacteria swimming in viscous fluids. This method models the bacterium as a collection of interconnected rigid bodies (blobs) interacting with the fluid. They solved the Stokes equations (governing low Reynolds number flows) with a no-slip boundary condition on the bacterium's surface. To model the bacteria's propulsion, they applied constant torques to the flagella, mimicking the action of molecular motors. They also developed a simplified minimal model to gain analytical insights into the observed phenomena.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wrapped mode as an Archimedes' Screw: The most striking insight is that the wrapped flagellum configuration acts like an Archimedes' screw, actively pushing fluid along the pipe. This is a key mechanism for its enhanced efficiency in confinement.
  • Confinement is key: While the extended mode is superior in bulk, the wrapped mode's efficiency dramatically increases as the pipe narrows. This suggests a specific evolutionary advantage for bacteria in confined niches.
  • Trade-off between speed and efficiency: The wrapped mode is generally slower than the extended mode, but its power consumption is lower, leading to higher efficiency in tight spaces.
  • Hydrodynamic interactions dominate: The study highlights the crucial role of hydrodynamic interactions between the bacterium, its flagellum, and the pipe walls in dictating swimming behavior and efficiency.
  • Flagellum shape matters: The length and wave number of the flagellum significantly influence the efficiency of both modes, with longer flagella in the wrapped mode showing particular promise in confinement.

Key Results

  • In bulk fluid, the extended mode swims approximately twice as fast as the wrapped mode.
  • As pipe confinement increases (decreasing pipe radius), the wrapped mode's swimming speed initially increases before decreasing, while the extended mode's speed consistently decreases.
  • The wrapped mode becomes more efficient than the extended mode in tight pipes (ro/a ≤ 1.7), with efficiency improvements up to two times greater.
  • The wrapped mode consumes less power across all pipe radii due to slower flagellar rotation.
  • A minimal model successfully predicts the observed trends, indicating that the difference in the decay of hydrodynamic coefficients (Mtt and Ntr) between the two modes is the primary driver of their distinct behaviors.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their simulations focused on a bacterium placed in the center of the pipe. They performed additional simulations to investigate the robustness of their findings when the bacterium is free to move and tilt. Future work could explore:

  • The behavior of bacteria in more complex geometries beyond simple circular pipes.
  • The interplay of steric interactions and hydrodynamic forces in very tight confinements.
  • The potential advantages of mixed swimming modes where flagella might exhibit both wrapped and extended configurations simultaneously.
  • Investigating the impact of different fluid properties and bacterial species.

Summary updated

Abstract

Single-flagellated bacteria are ubiquitous in nature. They exhibit various swimming modes using their flagella to explore complex surroundings such as soil and porous polymer networks. Some single-flagellated bacteria swim with two distinct modes, one with the flagellum extended away from its body and another with the flagellum wrapped around it. The wrapped mode has been observed when bacteria swim under tight confinements or in highly viscous polymeric melts. In this study we investigate the hydrodynamics of these two modes inside a circular pipe. We find that the wrapped mode is slower than the extended mode in bulk but more efficient under strong confinement due to a hydrodynamic increase of its flagellum translation–rotation coupling and an Archimedes’ screw-like configuration that helps to move the fluid along the pipe.
BibTeX
@article{gidituri2024swimming,
  author = {Harinadha Gidituri and Marco Ellero and Florencio Balboa Usabiaga},
  title = {{Swimming efficiently by wrapping}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1017/jfm.2024.594},
}
Figure