TL;DR
This paper investigates how learners' internal motivational processes (attention, relevance, confidence) and their evaluation of game outcomes (satisfaction) interact within digital game-based learning (DGBL). They found that these motivational and outcome processing elements are significantly related, suggesting that DGBL design needs to consider both to effectively sustain engagement and learning.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Digital game-based learning (DGBL) is increasingly recognized for its potential to enhance learning by leveraging the engaging nature of games. However, much of the existing research has focused on identifying intrinsic motivational factors within games (like challenge or curiosity) that initially draw players in. This approach is limited because it doesn't fully capture the dynamic and iterative nature of game playing, where learners repeatedly engage with game mechanics and feedback. Furthermore, it often overlooks the crucial role of outcome processing – how learners evaluate their efforts and performance within the game – in sustaining their motivation over time. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring the relationship between a learner's internal motivational processing and their subsequent evaluation of the game's outcomes, within the framework of the Motivation, Volition, and Performance (MVP) theory.
Methods
The study employed a survey research method to collect data from undergraduate students after they played an online instructional game called "Trade Ruler."
- Instrument: The Instructional Materials Motivational Survey (IMMS) was adapted to measure motivational processing (attention, relevance, confidence) and outcome processing (satisfaction) using a 9-point Likert scale.
- Data Analysis:
- Principal Components Analysis (PCA) with Varimax Rotation: Used for data reduction and to identify underlying components within the survey data. This involved multiple stages of PCA and parallel analysis to refine the extracted components.
- Scale Reliability: Cronbach's Alpha was used to assess the reliability of the overall scale and its sub-scales.
- Multiple Regression Analysis: Conducted to determine if motivational processing components (Attention, Relevance, Confidence) could significantly predict outcome processing (Satisfaction).
Datasets
- "Trade Ruler" Online Instructional Game: This game, developed by the Nobel Prize Foundation, was selected for its rich multimedia components, consistent cognitive activities, and its focus on economic theory (Heckscher-Ohlin Theory). It was chosen to ensure learners' prior knowledge wouldn't unduly influence their motivational levels and that the learning process was attainable.
- Participant Data: Data was collected from 264 undergraduate students recruited from a public Midwestern university in the United States. These students were novices in economic theories and were taking introductory educational psychology courses.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Intrinsic Motivation: The study highlights that simply focusing on intrinsic motivational factors isn't enough for DGBL. The iterative nature of games requires understanding how learners process their experiences and outcomes.
- Motivational Processing and Outcome Processing are Linked: The core finding is that how learners feel motivated (attention, relevance, confidence) is significantly related to how they evaluate their success and effort (satisfaction). This suggests a continuous loop where initial motivation influences outcome evaluation, which in turn can influence future motivation.
- Relevance is Key for Satisfaction: Among the motivational processing components, "relevance" emerged as the strongest predictor of "satisfaction." This implies that learners are more likely to feel satisfied if they perceive the game's content and activities as meaningful and connected to their existing knowledge or interests.
- The Role of Extrinsic Rewards: The study acknowledges that DGBL often includes built-in reward systems (like game scores). These extrinsic motivators, alongside intrinsic ones, likely play a role in outcome processing and need to be considered in design.
Key Results
- Significant Predictive Model: A multiple regression analysis revealed that Attention, Relevance, and Confidence together significantly predicted Satisfaction, explaining 43.4% of the variance (R² = .434).
- Relevance Dominates: Relevance was the strongest predictor of Satisfaction (β = .37), followed by Attention (β = .32) and Confidence (β = .19).
- Large Effect Size: The effect size of the regression model was considered large (f² = .77), indicating a substantial relationship between the variables.
- Moderate Satisfaction: Participants reported a moderate level of satisfaction, suggesting they perceived the learning outcome as a fair result of their invested efforts.
Limitations and Future Work
- Satisfaction as a Proxy: The study acknowledges that "satisfaction" as measured is a proxy and may not fully capture the multifaceted nature of an overall satisfactory learning experience, which can involve social and cognitive learning aspects.
- Unaccounted Variance: While the model was significant, motivational processing components only explained 43.4% of the variance in satisfaction. This suggests that other factors, such as cognitive processing during the game, also play a crucial role.
- Future Research Directions:
- Investigate the empirical relationship between motivational processing, cognitive effort investment, and outcome processing more deeply.
- Further explore the impact of extrinsic rewards in DGBL on motivational processing and outcome processing.
- Examine the full spectrum of motivation development in DGBL, moving beyond just motivational processing.
Summary updated