TL;DR
This paper introduces and validates a new model of "dualistic psychological thriving at work," which encompasses both immediate vitality and learning (work experience) and future-oriented growth (work development). They developed a reliable scale to measure this construct and found significant differences in how different generations (post-1970s, post-1980s, post-1990s) prioritize these two aspects of thriving.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The existing understanding of "psychological thriving at work" often focuses on immediate feelings of vitality and learning, neglecting the crucial aspect of future-oriented growth and development. This narrow view is problematic because employees need to feel energized and engaged in their current roles while also having a sense of purpose and expectation for their future career trajectory. Furthermore, previous research on thriving at work, largely developed in Western contexts, has shown limited applicability and validity when applied to Chinese employees. This study aims to bridge this gap by proposing a more comprehensive, dualistic model of thriving that better reflects the needs of Chinese workers and provides a validated measurement tool.
Methods
The research employed a multi-study approach:
- Study 1: Connotation and Structure Induction: This study used a qualitative, grounded theory approach involving interviews with 36 employees in China. Through open, axial, and selective coding, they identified the core components and structure of dualistic psychological thriving at work.
- Study 2: Scale Development and Validation:
- Initial Scale Construction: Based on Study 1 findings, an initial scale was developed. This was refined through expert evaluation and pilot testing, resulting in a 16-item scale.
- Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA): Two EFAs were conducted on independent samples (N=97 and N=152) to identify the underlying factor structure of the scale. The first EFA led to the deletion of some items, and the second EFA confirmed a two-factor structure for the remaining 9 items.
- Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA): A second, independent sample (N=152) was used to confirm the proposed second-order, two-factor model of dualistic psychological thriving at work.
- Reliability and Validity Testing: The scale's reliability (Cronbach's alpha) and validity (convergent and criterion) were assessed. Criterion validity was tested by examining the relationship between the new scale and established measures of workplace friendship and work autonomy.
- Study 3: Generational Heterogeneity: This study analyzed data from a larger sample (N=302) to investigate differences in overall levels and pursuit preferences of dualistic psychological thriving across different generational cohorts (post-1970s, post-1980s, post-1990s). Analysis of variance (ANOVA) and least significant difference (LSD) tests were used.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from employees in various companies in Liaoning Province, China. Specific sample sizes for each study were:
- Study 1: 36 employees.
- Study 2 (EFA 1): 97 valid questionnaires from 152 initial participants.
- Study 2 (CFA): 152 valid questionnaires from 204 initial participants.
- Study 3: 302 valid questionnaires from employees across four companies in Liaoning and Hebei Provinces.
No pre-existing benchmark datasets were used for training or evaluation; instead, the study generated its own data through surveys.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Dualistic Nature of Thriving: The most significant insight is the confirmation that psychological thriving at work is not a monolithic concept but rather a dualistic one, comprising both immediate "work experience" (vitality and learning) and future-oriented "work development" (expectations for future growth). This dualism is crucial for sustainable employee well-being.
- Cultural Nuance: The study highlights that Western models of thriving may not fully capture the complexities of the Chinese workplace, particularly the interplay of anxiety and future-oriented aspirations. The proposed dualistic model offers a more culturally relevant framework.
- Generational Differences in Priorities: The research reveals that different generations have distinct preferences for thriving. This suggests that a one-size-fits-all approach to employee engagement and development is ineffective.
- Importance of Future Outlook: The finding that even those with high current vitality and learning (post-1990s) still value future development, and that those focused on future development (post-1980s) also benefit from current engagement, underscores the interconnectedness of these two dimensions.
Key Results
- Scale Validation: The developed 9-item scale for dualistic psychological thriving at work demonstrated good reliability (Cronbach's alpha = 0.815) and validity, including criterion validity, showing significant positive relationships with workplace friendship and work autonomy.
- Generational Differences:
- Overall Thriving: Post-1990s employees reported the highest overall levels of dualistic psychological thriving, followed by post-1980s, and then post-1970s employees.
- Preference for Thriving: * Post-1990s employees showed a stronger inclination towards "psychological thriving of work experience" (vitality and learning).
- Post-1980s employees leaned more towards "psychological thriving of work development" (future expectations).
- Post-1970s employees did not show a significant preference for either dimension, suggesting a more balanced or less distinct prioritization.
Limitations and Future Work
- Dynamic Nature: The authors acknowledge that psychological thriving might be a continuous or cyclical state. Future research should employ dynamic methods to explore these characteristics and their influence mechanisms.
- Conceptual Proximity: Further research is needed to clarify the relationship and distinctions between dualistic psychological thriving and psychological well-being.
- Generalizability: The study's participants were from China, which may limit the generalizability of findings to Western contexts. Future research should include participants from Western cultures to enhance generalizability.
- Influencing Factors: While generational differences were explored, future work should delve deeper into the specific influencing factors of dualistic psychological thriving across generations and construct a corresponding theoretical system.
Summary updated