Sustainable planning of the energy-water-food nexus using decision making tools

Niclas Bieber, Jen Ho Ker, Xiaonan Wang, Charalampos Triantafyllidis, Koen H. van Dam, Rembrandt Koppelaar, Nilay ShahEnergy 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel integrated modeling framework that links agent-based modeling of resource demand with optimization for energy, water, and food systems. Applied to Ghana, it highlights the vulnerability of its power infrastructure and demonstrates how policy interventions like feed-in tariffs and agricultural intensification can drive renewable energy adoption and reduce emissions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The world faces a growing challenge in meeting the basic needs of energy, water, and food, especially in developing countries experiencing rapid urbanization. Existing models often focus on individual sectors or pairs of sectors (like energy-water), but fail to capture the complex interdependencies of the "energy-water-food" (EWF) nexus. This gap hinders effective planning for sustainable development, particularly in regions with limited resources and infrastructure. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a holistic methodology to support resilient and sustainable planning at a city-region level, incorporating all three critical resources and considering factors like climate change and policy impacts.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in its integrated modeling approach. It combines:

  • Socio-demographic and Agent-Based Modeling (ABM): This module simulates population dynamics and human activities to forecast resource demands (energy, water) at a high spatial and temporal resolution (5-minute intervals). It creates a representative population of agents (citizens, companies) whose aggregated behavior drives demand.
  • Resource-Technology Network (RTN) Optimization: This is a mixed-integer linear optimization model that determines the optimal allocation and investment in technologies for water, wastewater, and power systems. It incorporates capital expenditures (CAPEX), operational expenditures (OPEX), CO2 emissions, and a novel metric: the opportunity cost of food production foregone (OPF). The OPF quantifies the land use impact of energy infrastructure on food production.

This combination allows for a more comprehensive understanding of trade-offs and synergies within the EWF nexus.

Datasets

The study utilizes data for a case study of the Greater Accra Metropolitan Area (GAMA) in Ghana. Data sources include:

  • National statistics from the Ghana Statistical Service.
  • Fieldwork for demographic and socio-economic data.
  • Literature reviews for technology process data (costs, operational parameters).
  • Scientific papers, industrial, and government reports for technology-specific data.
  • Global Economic Monitor (GEM) Commodities data bank for fossil fuel prices.
  • Life cycle assessment (LCA) reviews for water use in power generation.
  • CO2 emission factors from an LCA harmonization study by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL).

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing data was compiled and adapted for the model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The EWF Nexus is Crucial for Developing Cities: The paper strongly emphasizes that urban areas are key drivers of resource consumption and carbon emissions, making integrated EWF planning essential for sustainable development, especially in rapidly growing cities in developing nations.
  • Opportunity Cost of Food Production Foregone (OPF) is a Powerful Metric: Introducing OPF into the optimization model effectively highlights the land-use trade-offs between energy infrastructure and food production, influencing technology selection and revealing previously hidden costs.
  • Ghana's Power Sector is Vulnerable and Needs Diversification: The case study reveals that Ghana's power generation infrastructure is heavily reliant on hydropower, making it susceptible to climate change impacts like drought. This underscores the urgent need for diversification.
  • Policy Interventions Have Tangible Impacts: The model demonstrates how specific policies, such as feed-in tariffs, carbon credit pricing, and agricultural intensification, can significantly alter the energy mix, reduce emissions, and influence economic costs.
  • Integrated Models Enable Scenario Planning: The framework's ability to simulate various scenarios (climate change, policy shifts, technology advancements) provides valuable insights for policymakers and planners to make informed decisions.

Key Results

  • The integrated model successfully simulated the EWF nexus for a sub-Saharan African city region (GAMA, Ghana).
  • The introduction of the OPF metric shifted the optimal power generation mix, favoring technologies with smaller land footprints (e.g., nuclear, hydropower, wind) over those with larger ones (e.g., solar PV).
  • Climate change scenarios, specifically reduced hydropower capacity due to lower rainfall, led to increased reliance on more expensive and higher-emission technologies, highlighting the need for diversification.
  • Policy simulations showed that:
  • A tariff on electricity imports reduced imports and increased reliance on natural gas, but also increased OPF and carbon emissions from domestic production.
  • Increasing carbon credit prices effectively shifted the mix towards renewables and biofuels, but at a significant increase in capital costs and OPF.
  • Investment in agricultural intensification led to lower OPF and made solar PV more competitive, driving a shift towards cleaner energy sources.
  • Feed-in tariffs and infrastructure investment could significantly boost renewable energy penetration.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Planning and Commissioning Time: The current model does not explicitly account for the time required to plan and commission new power generation infrastructure.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: A comprehensive sensitivity analysis on model parameters is needed to understand the robustness of the results to uncertainties.
  • Threshold Value Identification: Developing iterative procedures to find threshold values for parameters (e.g., carbon tax) that trigger significant shifts in the energy mix would be beneficial.
  • Social Tariffs and Subsidies: Investigating the effectiveness of social tariffs and subsidies for vulnerable populations, as seen in Latin America, could enhance electrification efforts.
  • Inclusion of Social Costs: Incorporating social costs into the existing framework would provide a more holistic assessment.
  • Extension to Residential Housing: Expanding the framework to include the residential housing sector would offer a more complete picture of urban resource demand.
  • Parameter Uncertainties: Further work is needed to address parameter uncertainties using statistical techniques like Latin Hypercube Sampling or Monte Carlo methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Developing countries struggle to implement suitable electric power and water services, failing to match infrastructure with urban expansion. Integrated modelling of urban water and power systems would facilitate the investment and planning processes, but there is a crucial gap to be filled with regards to extending models to incorporate the food supply in developing contexts. In this paper, a holistic methodology and platform to support the resilient and sustainable planning at city region level for multiple sectors was developed for applications in urban energy systems (UES) and the energy-water-food nexus, combining agent-based modelling - to simulate and forecast resource demands on spatial and temporal scales - with resource network optimization, which incorporates capital expenditures, operational costs, environmental impacts and the opportunity cost of food production foregone (OPF). Via a scenario based approach, innovative water supply and energy deployment policies are presented, which address the provision of clean energy for every citizen and demonstrate the potential effects of climate change. The results highlighted the vulnerability of Ghana's power generation infrastructure and the need for diversification. Feed-in tariffs and investment into supporting infrastructure and agriculture intensification will effectively increase the share of renewable energy and reduce carbon emissions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bieber2017sustainable,
  author = {Niclas Bieber and Jen Ho Ker and Xiaonan Wang and Charalampos Triantafyllidis and Koen H. van Dam and Rembrandt Koppelaar and Nilay Shah},
  title = {{Sustainable planning of the energy-water-food nexus using decision making tools}},
  booktitle = {Energy},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.enpol.2017.11.037},
}
Figure