Sustainable Industrial Energy Supply Systems with Integrated Renewable Energy, CCUS, and Energy Storage: A Comprehensive Evaluation

Liujian Yang, Xingyu Wu, Beijia Huang, Zeqiu LiSustainability 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel integrated industrial energy supply system (IRE-CCUS-BESS-SPS) that combines renewable energy, carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS), and battery energy storage. The system demonstrates a significant 59.78% reduction in carbon emissions, albeit with a 12.9% increase in economic cost, offering a promising framework for sustainable industrial operations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The industrial sector is a major contributor to carbon emissions, and achieving ambitious emission reduction targets necessitates a fundamental shift towards low-carbon energy supply systems. While integrating renewable energy sources like wind and solar can improve sustainability, their inherent intermittency poses challenges to system stability and efficiency. Furthermore, existing industrial processes often rely heavily on fossil fuels. This paper tackles the challenge of creating a truly sustainable industrial energy supply by proposing and evaluating an integrated system that not only incorporates renewables but also actively addresses carbon emissions through CCUS technology and manages intermittency with energy storage. The goal is to achieve a cost-effective and environmentally low-impact energy supply for industrial facilities.

Methods

The authors developed a comprehensive model of their proposed Integrated Renewable Energy-Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage-Battery Energy Storage System (IRE-CCUS-BESS-SPS). This model was simulated using Aspen Plus for the CCUS components and MATLAB for the rest of the system, with data exchanged between the platforms. The system's performance was then evaluated using a "4E" framework: Economy, Environment, Energy, and Exergy.

Key modeling aspects include:

  • Renewable Energy Integration: Modeling of wind turbines and solar photovoltaic panels, accounting for their power generation characteristics.
  • CCUS System: Detailed simulation of a calcium-based CCUS process, including CO2 capture using CaO, methanation with hydrogen to produce methane, and heat recovery.
  • Energy Storage: Modeling of zinc-bromine batteries for energy storage to manage renewable energy intermittency.
  • Water Electrolysis: Modeling of hydrogen production via water electrolysis to fuel the methanation process.
  • System Integration: A holistic approach to model the interplay between these components, including power grid interaction as a supplement.
  • Evaluation Metrics: A robust set of indicators covering economic viability (NPV, payback period, LCCR, LCOM), environmental impact (net emission reduction, CO2 removal rate), energy efficiency, and exergy loss.

Datasets

The paper utilizes meteorological data for wind speed and solar radiation intensity from China. It also references and compares its simulation results with data from existing literature (specifically Ref. [30]) for validation of the CCUS model. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Integration is Key: The study highlights that simply adding renewables isn't enough. The true power lies in integrating renewables with CCUS and energy storage to create a robust, low-carbon system.
  • CCUS as a Carbon Sink and Value Creator: The CCUS system not only captures CO2 but also converts it into valuable methane, demonstrating a pathway for industrial decarbonization that can also generate revenue.
  • The Trade-off Between Cost and Carbon Reduction: While the integrated system significantly cuts emissions, it comes with an increased economic cost. This underscores the need for policy support to bridge this gap.
  • Energy Storage Utilization Needs Optimization: The current energy storage system, while adding flexibility, shows low utilization rates. This points to a need for more sophisticated scheduling algorithms.
  • Government Policy is Crucial: The authors strongly suggest that government incentives, such as tax deductions and subsidies, are essential to accelerate the adoption of CCUS technology.

Key Results

  • Carbon Emission Reduction: The integrated IRE-CCUS-BESS-SPS system achieved a remarkable 59.78% reduction in carbon emissions compared to the pre-integration system.
  • Economic Impact: The integration led to a 12.9% increase in the overall economic cost.
  • Financial Viability: The system demonstrated a positive Net Present Value (NPV) over its lifecycle, with a payback period of 6.09 years, indicating good economic prospects.
  • Energy Supply Mix: The energy supply comprises 48.60% fuel oil, 22.10% biomass, and an additional 270.04 kW of heat from waste heat boilers.
  • Cost of Mitigation: The Levelized Cost of CO2 Removal (LCCR) was 122.95 CNY/t, and the Levelized Cost of Methanation (LCOM) was 10,908.35 CNY/t. These figures are higher than current carbon trading costs and methane prices, highlighting the need for economic incentives.
  • Energy Loss: The carbon capture reactor exhibited the highest energy loss (35.8%), followed by the methanation reactor (33.6%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low Energy Storage Utilization: The authors acknowledge that the energy storage unit's utilization frequency is low. Future work should focus on developing dynamic scheduling algorithms and multi-time scale scheduling strategies to optimize its use and improve overall system efficiency.
  • Economic Incentives Not Fully Modeled: The payback period calculation did not explicitly account for policy incentives, which the authors suggest are crucial for adoption. Future analyses could incorporate these more directly.
  • System Safety and Robustness: The current study focuses on steady-state operations and does not consider system safety. Future research should integrate dynamic scheduling and multi-objective optimization to analyze system safety and robustness.
  • Further Optimization: The authors suggest optimizing operating conditions for carbon capture reactors, improving heat exchanger designs, and exploring more efficient heat exchange technologies to reduce exergy loss. They also propose optimizing methanation reaction efficiency and establishing dynamic capture systems.
  • Policy Recommendations: The paper provides specific policy recommendations, including tax deductions, investment subsidies, and carbon tax adjustments, to encourage CCUS adoption.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the increasing emphasis on emission reduction targets, the low-carbon sustainable transformation of industrial energy supply systems is crucial. Addressing the urgent issue of reducing industrial carbon emissions, this study presents an integrated industrial energy supply system (IRE-CCUS-BESS-SPS) that incorporates renewable energy; calcium-based carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS); and battery energy storage systems (BESSs) to improve energy efficiency and sustainability. The system model is designed to achieve a cost-effective and environmentally low-impact energy supply, validated through Aspen Plus V11.0 and Matlab R2019b simulations. The system’s performance is evaluated using a 4E index system encompassing economy, environment, energy, and exergy. The findings indicate that the system’s lifetime net present value (NPV) is positive, with a payback period of 6.09 years. Despite a 12.9% increase in the overall economic cost, carbon emissions are significantly reduced by 59.78%. The energy supply composition includes 48.60% from fuel oil and 22.10% from biomass, with an additional 270.04 kW of heat provided by waste heat boilers. The equalization costs for CO2 removal (LCCR) and methanation (LCOM) are 122.95 CNY/t and 10908.35 CNY/t, respectively, both exceeding current carbon emission trading costs and methane prices. This research offers a robust framework for designing sustainable industrial energy systems that integrate renewable energy, CCUS, and energy storage technologies for low-carbon operations. The analysis also suggests that government policies, such as direct financial subsidies or tax relief, are effective in accelerating the adoption of CCUS technology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2025sustainable,
  author = {Liujian Yang and Xingyu Wu and Beijia Huang and Zeqiu Li},
  title = {{Sustainable Industrial Energy Supply Systems with Integrated Renewable Energy, CCUS, and Energy Storage: A Comprehensive Evaluation}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/su17020712},
}
Figure