Sustainable development of materials: Broadening stakeholder engagement

Julie M. Schoenung, Elsa Olivetti, Guest EditorsMRS 2023 · DOI

Abstract

We present a transformative vision for future materials selection, processing, and design decisions in the context of sustainability. Specifically, we highlight the concept of sustainable development of materials and the need to broaden the range of stakeholders engaged in materials design decisions. Beyond the traditional structure–processing–performance triangle, there is a critical need to incorporate sustainability metrics into materials design, embracing concepts of green chemistry, circularity, and alternatives assessment. Implementation requires broad engagement beyond traditional materials science boundaries, including global perspectives on public policy, governance, economics, and public health.

Introduction

Traditional materials science and engineering (MSE) has long been guided by the "structure–processing–performance" triangle. While this paradigm has driven decades of technological innovation, it often overlooks the broader environmental and social impacts of material choices. In a recent perspective published in the MRS Bulletin, Julie M. Schoenung and Elsa A. Olivetti argue for a shift toward the "sustainable development of materials." This framework integrates life-cycle thinking and safer chemistry into the core of materials design by engaging a wider array of stakeholders, from ecologists to local communities.

The Sustainability Blind Spot

The success of MSE in enabling "green" technologies has created a paradox. Solutions designed to mitigate climate change often introduce new, unforeseen challenges:

  • Mass and Energy Paradox: Electric vehicles (EVs) are 20–30% heavier than internal combustion engine vehicles due to battery requirements, leading to increased road wear and higher embodied energy.
  • Material Complexity: Modern electronics have transitioned from using approximately 30 elements in the 1990s to over 70 today. This "elemental diversity" makes end-of-life recovery and recycling nearly impossible.
  • Toxicity and Inequity: The demand for critical materials like cobalt and lithium often relies on toxic extraction processes and can exacerbate social inequities in mining regions, particularly in the Global South.

A Multi-Dimensional Framework

To address these issues, the authors propose a framework that intersects three core principles: Safer Chemicals (reducing toxicity), Circular Economy (reducing waste), and Energy Efficiency (reducing carbon footprint).

This approach requires "disciplinary multilingualism." Materials scientists must learn to communicate with toxicologists, hydrologists, and sociologists to understand how material choices impact complex ecological and social systems. Furthermore, supply chain disruptions—such as those seen during the COVID-19 pandemic—can serve as "windows of opportunity" to bypass institutional barriers and adopt sustainable alternatives that were previously deemed too risky.

The paper highlights several sobering trends that underscore the urgency of this shift:

  • LED Material Intensity: LED bulbs can be up to six times more material-intensive than the incandescent bulbs they replace.
  • High-Entropy Materials: The rise of complex alloys and ceramics containing 5–10 elements in equimolar ratios significantly increases the difficulty and cost of materials recovery.
  • Extractivism vs. Value Addition: There is a critical need to shift from simple raw material extraction to "domestic value addition," empowering local communities through data sovereignty and technical training.

The Path Forward: Data and Education

Realizing this vision requires two major shifts. First, the development of "machine learning-ready data" that includes resource use and emissions information is essential for predictive sustainability modeling under the Materials Genome Initiative. Second, MSE education must move away from reductionist approaches toward "systems thinking," incorporating ethics, justice, and planetary boundaries into the core curriculum. By broadening stakeholder engagement, the materials community can ensure that the next generation of technologies is truly sustainable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We present a transformative vision for future materials selection, processing, and design decisions in the context of sustainability. Specifically, we highlight the concept of sustainable development of materials and the need to broaden the range of stakeholders engaged in materials design decisions. For instance, beyond the traditional structure–processing–performance triangle, there is a critical need to incorporate sustainability metrics into materials design. Such metrics embrace concepts of green chemistry and chemicals management, critical materials and materials circularity, materials substitution and alternatives assessment. Implementation requires broad engagement beyond the traditional materials science and engineering boundaries, including global perspectives on public policy, governance, economics, and public health. Educational norms clearly must also change, together with workforce development programs and comprehensive industrial buy-in. This vision is further expanded upon in the articles in this issue, which we summarize here, providing highlights of each article and identifying critical intersections among the topics presented, thereby providing a framework to realize our vision. Graphical Abstract
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schoenung2023sustainable,
  author = {Julie M. Schoenung and Elsa Olivetti and Guest Editors},
  title = {{Sustainable development of materials: Broadening stakeholder engagement}},
  booktitle = {MRS},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1557/s43577-023-00521-8},
}
Figure