Sustainable-Development Measurement of China’s Coworking Industry Using Social-Network Analysis Method

Danning Zhang, Ming Yan, Haowen Wang, Weiwei LiSustainability 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses Social Network Analysis (SNA) to create a novel three-level index system to measure the sustainable development of China's coworking industry. The study reveals a diverse and interconnected ecosystem, highlighting the crucial role of internet giants and suggesting tailored strategies for different coworking models to overcome bottlenecks and foster growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's coworking industry, a burgeoning sector within the sharing economy, faces significant challenges despite government support for entrepreneurship. These include service homogeneity and a reliance on single-profit models, hindering its sustainable development. Existing research often focuses on individual coworking spaces rather than the industry's broader structural dynamics. This paper aims to address this gap by providing a systematic, multi-level framework to assess the industry's development status and identify pathways for sustainable growth, particularly in the context of China's unique entrepreneurial landscape.

Methods

The authors employ Social Network Analysis (SNA) to construct a three-level comprehensive index system:

  • Macrolevel (Density-Comprehensive Index): Measures the overall tightness and cohesion of the industrial network by integrating graph density and centrality.
  • Mesolevel (Subgroup-Comprehensive Index): Utilizes the External-Internal (E-I) index to assess the degree of clustering within subgroups (communities) and the network's openness.
  • Microlevel (Centrality-Comprehensive Index): Evaluates the position and influence of individual nodes (enterprises) within the network using point centrality, betweenness centrality, and closeness centrality.

This framework is applied to analyze six distinct coworking industry models in China.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from two primary sources:

  • Industry Research Reports: Specifically, the "2018–2019 China Coworking Industry Research Report," "Research Report on Coworking Brand in China in 2018," and "2019–2025 Investment Potential Analysis and Future Prospect Forecast Report of China's Coworking Industry."
  • Baidu Search: Used to identify and map the network relationships between coworking enterprises and other relevant entities.

The paper constructs an "equal-weight 0–1 network relation matrix" based on observed cooperation between different types of enterprises.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rich Ecological Diversity: China's coworking industry is characterized by a diverse network, integrating coworking spaces, internet companies, real estate firms, investment institutions, and universities. This cross-border integration is a significant feature.
  • Chinese Characteristics: Unlike Western coworking models focused on revitalizing old spaces, China's industry emerged from a need for affordable office solutions for entrepreneurs, reflecting a distinct entrepreneurial gene and a preference for team-based work requiring private offices.
  • Internet Giants as Ecosystem Drivers: Major internet enterprises like Alibaba, Tencent, and Baidu play a pivotal role, not just as participants but as strategic players shaping the industry's ecological development.
  • Model Diversification is Key: The study identifies six distinct coworking models, each with unique strengths and weaknesses, suggesting that tailored strategies are crucial for sustainable growth.
  • Bottlenecks Remain: Despite growth, issues like service homogeneity and single-profit models persist, requiring further development in resource integration and cross-border collaboration.

Key Results

  • Network Scale: The "new real-estate" and "open-space" models exhibit the largest network scales, indicating maturity. The "industry-driven" model is the smallest and appears to be in its nascent stage.
  • Density-Comprehensive Index: The "industry-driven" model, despite its small scale, shows the highest density, suggesting strong industrial ecology and resource support. Conversely, "open-space" and "new real-estate" models, while large, need to deepen resource integration and collaboration.
  • Subgroup Analysis (E-I Index): Most models show negative E-I indices, indicating strong internal cohesion within subgroups but limited external openness. The "industry-driven" and "media-platform" models exhibit particularly high internal reliance. The "angel-investment" model is an exception, showing positive E-I indices and balanced cooperation.
  • Centrality Analysis: Internet giants (Baidu, Tencent, Alibaba) consistently rank high in centrality across various models, underscoring their influence. Betweenness centrality (ability to control resources) is a key factor for influence in most models, while point centrality (number of network relations) is dominant in the "open-space" and "media-platform" models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Supply-Side Focus: The study primarily analyzes the supply side of the coworking industry, neglecting demand-side factors and regional variations within China.
  • Generalizability: The comprehensive index system, while robust, was applied only to the coworking industry and could benefit from application and adaptation to other sharing economy sectors.
  • Data Granularity: Future research could benefit from more extensive data collection for a more scientific and comprehensive evaluation.
  • Predictive Modeling: Developing a predictive demand model is suggested to understand the influence of demand on supply.
  • Cross-Industry Application: Applying and refining the comprehensive index system to other sharing industries is a key future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

While China’s sharing economy slows down and enters a period of structural adjustment, the coworking industry is a new force. Moreover, after China had issued important policies to support the comprehensive upgrading and the sustainable development of mass entrepreneurship and mass innovation in September 2018, the development potential of the coworking industry became even greater. However, the coworking industry also faces many development bottlenecks, such as the homogeneity of services and the single-profit model. Therefore, it is of great theoretical and practical significance to realize the sustainable development of the coworking industry to facilitate mass entrepreneurship and innovation in China. The coworking industry is both a subindustry of sharing economy and a branch of the Internet industry, with the significant characteristic of networking. Therefore, we used social-network analysis (SNA) to build a three-level index system of China’s coworking industry: the density-comprehensive index at the macrolevel, the subgroup comprehensive index at the mesolevel, and the centrality-comprehensive index at the microlevel, so as to scientifically measure the development status of the coworking industry. In addition, the comprehensive index system was applied to a comparative study of the six models that were formed in actual development. Analytical results indicate that China coworking industry formed a good network with rich ecological diversity. Different from other countries, China’s coworking industry has embodied a profound gene of entrepreneurship and innovation since its early stage of development. Internet giant enterprises Alibaba, Tencent, and Baidu are playing an important role in the development of China’s coworking industry, and all have strategic layouts among several models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2021sustainable,
  author = {Danning Zhang and Ming Yan and Haowen Wang and Weiwei Li},
  title = {{Sustainable-Development Measurement of China’s Coworking Industry Using Social-Network Analysis Method}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/su13115902},
}
Figure