Sustainable and Smart: Rethinking What a Smart Home is

Maha Salman, Steve Easterbrook, Samar Sabie, Josie Abate2016 · DOI

Abstract The term Smart Home typically refers to dwellings augmented with high-tech responsive systems such that heating, air conditioning, lighting, appliances, entertainment outlets, and architectural components are computerized and managed, often via a remote control. Smart homes promise comfort, convenience, and resource conservation in the near future. Yet the notion of increased dependency on technology for comfort and efficiency (and hence, sustainably) needs to be revised. While we (justifiably) expect our dwellings to use technological advances to sense and respond to our needs, a growing body of literature warns against increased dependencies and amplified complexification, given the resource depletion anticipated in the future. Through examples and discussions drawn primarily from vernacular architecture discourse, this paper addresses this dichotomy. We investigate how smart homes can be re-defined to better fit sustainability goals while anticipating technology limitations. We introduce members of the ICT4S community to the sustainability potentials of vernacular domestic architecture and inspire them by its smart responses to human needs and harsh conditions. And finally, we argue that re-employing tried-and-true vernacular techniques in conjunction with ICT systems can offer smart yet simple and feasible solutions to future housing needs while being inherently more sustainable from an environmental and operational stance.

Introduction: Challenging the Techno-Centric Smart Home

This research challenges the current techno-centric definition of "smart homes," arguing that true sustainability comes from reversing the trend of active buildings and passive occupants. Current industry standards define a smart home through its "active design": a complex web of sensors, HVAC systems, and automated appliances that manage comfort on behalf of the user.

The authors argue this approach has three major flaws:

  1. Fragility: High-tech systems are prone to "software aging," hardware failure, and energy outages. When the tech fails, buildings designed as "machines for living" often become uninhabitable.
  2. Passive Occupancy: Automation strips dwellers of agency, making them passive occupants who lose the ability to interact with their environment to conserve resources.
  3. The "One Size Fits All" Trap: Modern smart homes often ignore local context, applying energy-intensive technological solutions to diverse climates and cultures, a practice the authors describe as a "colonial impulse" in research.

Methodology: Vernacular Motifs and Digital Validation

The researchers employ a dual-method approach to bridge traditional wisdom with modern engineering. First, they conduct a qualitative architectural review of "vernacular architecture"—traditional building styles developed through generations of trial and error. They specifically focus on hot, humid climates to identify "smart" passive features like Barjeels (wind towers), thermal massing, and interior courtyards.

Traditional courtyard architecture reviewed for its passive cooling and lighting properties.

To validate these traditional principles, the authors developed a digital design model for a sustainable villa based on a "checklist of vernacular motifs." They then used DK-Solar environmental assessment software to run 12 different simulation combinations (varying orientation, insulation, and glazing) against extreme hot-climate data (temperatures reaching 60°C) to calculate potential energy savings.

Key Insights: Smart by Design, Not Gadgetry

A core finding is that a vernacular home is "smart" because of its orchestration—how its layout, materials, and orientation turn hot air into a cool breeze without electronic automation.

Passive cooling mechanisms in vernacular architecture during day and night cycles.

Key conceptual shifts proposed include:

  • Active Occupancy: In traditional homes, dwellers are "active," moving to different rooms as the sun shifts. The authors argue ICT should support this human expertise rather than replace it.
  • Resilience through Simplicity: A building that uses thermal mass to delay heat transfer is inherently more "intelligent" during a power outage than a glass-walled apartment with a smart thermostat.
  • The "Lower Bound" of Savings: Standard simulation software often cannot accurately calculate the cooling benefits of passive ventilation like wind towers. Therefore, quantitative results likely underestimate the true efficiency of vernacular designs.

Quantitative Results

The simulations provided a strong proof of concept for returning to traditional principles:

  • Orientation & Insulation: Simply optimizing a building’s orientation (North-South) and adding thermal insulation reduced energy use by approximately 45%.
  • Glazing & Shading: Performance improved even further when incorporating double-glazing and both internal/external shading devices.
  • Qualitative Success: The authors demonstrated that a modern villa can maintain a contemporary aesthetic while functioning like a traditional courtyard house, proving that sustainable vernacular motifs are compatible with modern lifestyles.

Limitations and Future Work

While promising, the authors acknowledge areas for further exploration. Current simulations focus on single houses, but vernacular architecture relies heavily on "compact urban planning" (narrow alleys and shared walls). Future work must investigate neighborhood-level microclimates. Additionally, the paper proposes an "amalgamation" of active and passive design but requires a specific technical framework for how ICT systems should "gently teach" occupants to interact with their homes. Finally, current environmental assessment tools need updates to better model complex passive systems like natural convection in wind towers.

Summary updated

Abstract

The term Smart Home typically refers to dwellings augmented with high-tech responsive systems such that heating, air conditioning, lighting, appliances, entertainment outlets, and architectural components are computerized and managed, often via a remote control. Smart homes promise comfort, convenience, and resource conservation in the near future. Yet the notion of increased dependency on technology for comfort and efficiency (and hence, sustainably) needs to be revised. While we (justifiably) expect our dwellings to use technological advances to sense and respond to our needs, a growing body of literature [1-5] warns against increased dependencies and amplified complexification, given the resource depletion anticipated in the future. Through examples and discussions drawn primarily from vernacular architecture discourse, this paper addresses this dichotomy. We investigate how smart homes can be re-defined to better fit sustainability goals while anticipating technology limitations. We introduce members of the ICT4S community to the sustainability potentials of vernacular domestic architecture and inspire them by its smart responses to human needs and harsh conditions. And finally, we argue that re-employing tried-and-true vernacular techniques in conjunction with ICT systems can offer smart yet simple and feasible solutions to future housing needs while being inherently more sustainable from an environmental and operational stance.
BibTeX
@misc{salman2016sustainable,
  author = {Maha Salman and Steve Easterbrook and Samar Sabie and Josie Abate},
  title = {{Sustainable and Smart: Rethinking What a Smart Home is}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.2991/ict4s-16.2016.22},
}
Figure