Sustainability of Cooperative Professional Development: Focused on Teachers’ Efficacy

Jae-Woo Choi, Woonsun KangSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different types of cooperative professional development (CPD) impact teachers' self-efficacy in Korean middle schools. It found that a "collaborative" CPD approach, characterized by active participation, knowledge exchange, and peer feedback, significantly boosts teacher efficacy more than other identified CPD types. This highlights the crucial role of collaborative learning environments for sustainable professional development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical need for effective professional development (PD) to enhance teacher quality, particularly in the context of sustainability education (SE). SE requires teachers to adopt learner-centered, critical thinking approaches, which necessitates strong teacher efficacy. While PD is known to influence teacher efficacy, the paper identifies a gap in understanding how different types of cooperative professional development (CPD) specifically contribute to this efficacy, especially in non-Western contexts like Korea. The authors argue that simply participating in PD isn't enough; the nature of that participation matters for its sustainability and impact on teachers' confidence and practice.

Methods

The study employed a mixed-methods approach, primarily relying on quantitative analysis of existing survey data.

  • K-means Cluster Analysis: This was used to group teachers into distinct types based on their engagement in various cooperative professional development activities. This is a standard clustering technique for identifying natural groupings within data.
  • Hierarchical Regression Analysis: This statistical method was used to determine the predictive power of different variables (gender, age, experience, school climate, and CPD type) on teacher self-efficacy. This is a common technique for understanding the relative importance of multiple predictors.
  • Factor Analysis (PCA): Used to identify underlying dimensions within the cooperative professional development activities, which then informed the clustering process.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the 2013 Teaching and Learning International Survey (TALIS) conducted by the OECD. This is a large-scale, nationally representative dataset of teachers, providing rich information on their professional development, teaching practices, and school context. No new benchmarks were introduced; the paper leverages existing, publicly available data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CPD is not monolithic: The study demonstrates that "cooperative professional development" isn't a single entity. Teachers engage in it in vastly different ways, leading to distinct "types" of participation.
  • Collaboration is key to efficacy: The "collaborative" CPD group, characterized by active knowledge sharing, joint activities, and peer feedback, showed the strongest positive impact on teacher self-efficacy. This suggests that simply "cooperating" isn't enough; deep, reciprocal engagement is crucial.
  • Sustainability hinges on active participation: The findings imply that PD that is merely passive or transactional (like just exchanging materials) is less likely to lead to sustainable improvements in teacher efficacy compared to active, collaborative learning.
  • Context matters, but universal principles emerge: While the study is in a Korean context, the emphasis on collaboration and reflection for teacher efficacy likely has broader implications for professional development design globally.

Key Results

  • Four CPD Types Identified: The K-means clustering identified four distinct groups of teachers based on their CPD engagement:
  • Disengaged Group (36.8%): Least involved in CPD activities.
  • Collaborative Group (11.3%): Highly engaged in joint activities, peer observation, and feedback.
  • Activity-Focused Group (24.8%): Engaged in joint tasks and team activities.
  • Coordinative Group (27.1%): Primarily focused on sharing materials and mutual assistance.
  • Collaborative CPD is the Strongest Predictor of Efficacy: Hierarchical regression analysis revealed that belonging to the "collaborative group" (CPD1) was the most significant predictor of higher teacher self-efficacy, even after controlling for gender, age, years of experience, and school climate.
  • All CPD Types Showed Significant Differences: While the collaborative group was most impactful, all identified CPD types showed statistically significant differences in their relationship with teacher self-efficacy compared to the disengaged group.
  • Model Improvement: Adding CPD-type to the regression model significantly improved its explanatory power for teacher self-efficacy (R² increased from 0.03 to 0.08).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Source Limitation: The study relied on the TALIS dataset, which has limitations in capturing the full nuance of school climate factors. Specifically, only "shared leadership" was usable from the school climate indicators, limiting a comprehensive analysis of this variable.
  • Cross-Sectional Data: The study uses cross-sectional data, meaning it captures a snapshot in time. It cannot establish definitive causality, only strong associations.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors suggest future studies should aim to:
  • Complement the limitations of the TALIS data by incorporating more detailed school climate measures.
  • Further explore the sustainability of CPD and its link to consistent pedagogical approaches in SE.
  • Investigate how to foster collaborative professional development environments, emphasizing the role of school administrators and policy-makers.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, we aim to gain critical insights into how cooperative professional development affects teachers’ efficacy. To this end, the purpose of this study is to identify cooperative professional development types (CPD-type) and to reveal the relationship between CPD-type and teachers’ efficacy in Korean middle schools, controlling for gender, age, years of experience and school climate. The data of this study are derived from the 2013 Teaching and Learning International Survey (TALIS) conducted by the OECD. The K-mean cluster analysis was used to identify distinct clusters of middle school teachers based on CPD. This process identified four specific groups: the disengaged group (36.8%), the collaborative group (11.3%), the activity-focused group (24.8%), and the coordinative group (27.1%). Hierarchical regression analysis revealed that all dummy variables of CPD-type were statistically significant, controlling for gender, age, years of experience, and school climate. Comparing the relative importance of each variable on teachers’ efficacy, the CPD1 (1 = the collaborative group) variable was most important. The results of this study provide a rationale for teachers to participate in collaborative professional development actively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{choi2019sustainability,
  author = {Jae-Woo Choi and Woonsun Kang},
  title = {{Sustainability of Cooperative Professional Development: Focused on Teachers’ Efficacy}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11030585},
}
Figure