Sustainability, collapse and oscillations of global climate, population and economy in a simple World-Earth model

Jan Nitzbon, Jobst Heitzig, Ulrich ParlitzarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Anthropocene is characterized by close interdependencies between the natural Earth system and human society, posing novel challenges to model development. Here we present a conceptual model describing the long-term coevolution of natural and socioeconomic subsystems of Earth. While the climate is represented via a global carbon cycle, we use economic concepts to model socio-metabolic flows of biomass and fossil fuels between nature and society. A wellbeing-dependent parametrization of fertility and mortality governs human population dynamics. Our analysis focuses on assessing possible asymptotic states of the Earth system for a qualitative understanding of its complex dynamics rather than quantitative predictions. Low dimension and simple equations enable a parameter-space analysis allowing us to identify preconditions of several asymptotic states and hence fates of humanity and planet. These include a sustainable co-evolution of nature and society, a global collapse and everlasting oscillations. We consider scenarios corresponding to different socio-cultural stages of human history. The necessity of accounting for the "human factor" in Earth system models is highlighted by the fact that carbon stocks during the past centuries evolved opposing to what would "naturally" be expected on a planet without humans. The intensity of biomass use and the contribution of ecosystem services to human well-being are found to be crucial determinants of the asymptotic state in a biomass-only scenario. The capitalistic, fossil-based scenario reveals that trajectories with fundamentally different asymptotic states might still be almost indistinguishable during a very long transient phase. Given current population levels, our study also supports the claim that besides reducing the global demand for energy, only the extensive use of renewable energies may pave the way into a sustainable future.

Introduction: Modeling the Co-evolving Earth

Traditionally, climate modeling has been bifurcated into two distinct methodologies. On one hand, complex Earth System Models (ESMs) treat human activity as an external "forcing"—an exogenous variable similar to volcanic eruptions or solar variability. On the other, Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs) focus on economic optimization, often at the cost of oversimplifying critical natural feedbacks.

In the Anthropocene, however, nature and society have become so deeply intertwined that they function as a single, co-evolving system. To address this, researchers have developed a "World-Earth" model that couples the global carbon cycle with human population and capital dynamics. By using a low-dimensional system of five ordinary differential equations, the model allows for a qualitative exploration of the long-term "fates" of our planet—sustainability, collapse, or perpetual oscillation—on centennial to millennial timescales.

The World-Earth Model Architecture

The proposed dynamical system tracks five primary state variables: Terrestrial Carbon ($L$), Atmospheric Carbon ($A$), Geological Carbon ($G$), Human Population ($P$), and Physical Capital ($K$). The interactions between these variables are governed by socio-metabolic flows of biomass and fossil fuels.

Figure 1: Conceptual diagram of the World-Earth model showing the interdependencies between carbon stocks, economic production, and human well-being.

The model integrates economic concepts, such as a Cobb-Douglas production function, to determine economic output based on energy inputs, labor, and capital. A critical innovation is the definition of human well-being ($W$), which is not solely a function of consumption but also includes "ecosystem services" derived from terrestrial carbon stocks. This creates a feedback loop: over-harvesting biomass to drive consumption eventually degrades the very ecosystem services that support well-being, subsequently impacting population growth through fertility and mortality rates.

Dynamics and the "Human Factor"

One of the most striking insights from the model is the reversal of natural carbon cycle trends. In a purely natural state, the Earth's carbon cycle typically settles into one of two stable equilibria: a "forest" state (high terrestrial carbon) or a "desert" state (low terrestrial carbon). The authors observe that current global carbon stocks are moving in a direction—decreasing terrestrial carbon while increasing atmospheric carbon—that is physically impossible in a "natural" system without accounting for human intervention. Effectively, human activity is forcing the system to "climb the hill" away from its natural basin of stability.

Furthermore, the model exhibits "multistability." Depending on initial conditions and socio-economic parameters, the system can converge toward radically different asymptotic states. In scenarios where well-being is heavily dependent on ecosystem services, the model can produce "limit cycles"—sustained, predator-prey-like oscillations where the human population grows, overshoots environmental capacity, crashes, and then recovers as the environment regenerates.

Mapping the Fates of Humanity

By analyzing the parameter space, the researchers identified distinct regimes that determine the long-term trajectory of the World-Earth system. These regimes are defined by factors such as biomass sector productivity and the sensitivity of well-being to land carbon.

Figure 4: Parameter space mapping showing regimes of sustainability, collapse, and oscillations based on economic output per biomass input and well-being sensitivity to land carbon.

The analysis reveals that the "intensity of use" is a primary determinant of survival in biomass-reliant societies. If biomass is extracted too efficiently without a corresponding valuation of the standing stock (ecosystem services), a global collapse becomes inevitable.

In more complex, fossil-fuel-based capitalistic scenarios, the model warns of a "Great Divergence." It shows that a path leading to a sustainable "forest" state and a path leading to a catastrophic "desert" collapse can appear virtually identical for the first 800 years of simulation. This suggests that traditional socio-economic indicators may be "blind" to approaching biospheric tipping points until it is too late to change course.

Conclusion: The Renewable Mandate

The model's results underscore a stark reality: a society relying exclusively on finite fossil fuels or over-exploited biomass will eventually face collapse or perpetual instability. The authors conclude that the only mathematically viable path to a high-population, high-well-being sustainable future is the extensive and rapid adoption of renewable energy sources. Unlike biomass or fossil fuels, renewables provide the necessary energy for economic production without depleting terrestrial or geological carbon stocks, thereby decoupling human progress from environmental degradation.

While the model is intentionally simplified—omitting spatial heterogeneity and other greenhouse gases—it provides a vital conceptual framework for understanding the qualitative boundaries of our future in the Anthropocene.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Anthropocene is characterized by close interdependencies between the natural Earth system and the human society, posing novel challenges to model development. Here we present a conceptual model describing the long-term coevolution of natural and socioeconomic subsystems of Earth. While the climate is represented via a global carbon cycle, we use economic concepts to model socio-metabolic flows of biomass and fossil fuels between nature and society. A wellbeing-dependent parametrization of fertility and mortality governs human population dynamics. Our analysis focuses on assessing possible asymptotic states of the Earth system for a qualitative understanding of its complex dynamics rather than quantitative predictions. Low dimension and simple equations enable a parameter-space analysis allowing us to identify preconditions of several asymptotic states and hence fates of humanity and planet. These include a sustainable co-evolution of nature and society, a global collapse and everlasting oscillations. We consider scenarios corresponding to different socio-cultural stages of human history. The necessity of accounting for the "human factor" in Earth system models is highlighted by the fact that carbon stocks during the past centuries evolved opposing to what would "naturally" be expected on a planet without humans. The intensity of biomass use and the contribution of ecosystem services to human well-being are found to be crucial determinants of the asymptotic state in a biomass-only scenario. The capitalistic, fossil-based scenario reveals that trajectories with fundamentally different asymptotic states might still be almost indistinguishable during a very long transient phase. Given current population levels, our study also supports the claim that besides reducing the global demand for energy, only the extensive use of renewable energies may pave the way into a sustainable future.
BibTeX
@misc{nitzbon2017sustainability,
  author = {Jan Nitzbon and Jobst Heitzig and Ulrich Parlitz},
  title = {{Sustainability, collapse and oscillations of global climate, population and economy in a simple World-Earth model}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1702.01050},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.01050},
}

Loading related content...

Figure