Survey on security issues of routing and anomaly detection for space information networks

Ming Zhuo, Leyuan Liu, Shijie Zhou, Zhiwen TianScientific 2021 · DOI

Space Information Networks (SINs) represent a paradigm shift in global connectivity, integrating satellites (LEO, MEO, GEO), Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs), and ground stations to support high-dynamic, real-time broadband transmission. However, as these networks become increasingly integrated into terrestrial systems, their vulnerability to cyber-attacks grows. This paper provides a comprehensive survey of the security landscape for SINs, focusing specifically on secure routing and anomaly detection through the lens of both traditional methods and emerging Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies.

The Unique Security Landscape of SINs

Unlike terrestrial networks, SINs operate in a high-latency, resource-constrained environment with asymmetrical link capacities and highly dynamic topologies. These characteristics render traditional security models insufficient. The authors identify a critical gap: while satellite communication is established, the "integration" of these networks exposes them to sophisticated threats such as eavesdropping, spoofing, and DDoS attacks.

Taxonomy of Security Threats

The paper classifies SIN threats into three primary categories: Natural, Environmental, and Mission threats. Mission threats are particularly concerning, involving malicious activities like the Turla malware or "Zombie invasion" hacks aimed at controlling or destroying network assets.

Taxonomy of security threats in Space Information Networks, categorized by natural, environmental, and mission-based risks.

Secure Routing and Anomaly Detection

Routing in SINs is analyzed across three domains: User-to-Satellite (UDL), Inter-Satellite (ISL), and Boundary routing. The survey compares traditional single-layer strategies against multi-layer intelligent algorithms.

For anomaly detection, the authors propose a novel framework combining a Cybersecurity Knowledge Graph with a Graph Neural Network (GNN)-based Encoder-Decoder.

  • Encoder: Embeds graph vertices to capture structural and attribute features.
  • Decoder: Reconstructs network topology and attributes.
  • Anomaly Scoring: Nodes with a high reconstruction error (D-value) are flagged as potential threats.

This approach treats SINs as Delay Tolerant Networks (DTNs), shifting the focus from constant connectivity to reliable delivery over time. By using GNNs, the system can extract features directly from the moving graph structure of the satellite constellation.

Key Results and Performance Analysis

A major finding of the survey is the significant resilience advantage of multi-layered routing (LEO/MEO/GEO) over single-layer LEO systems. During "oscillatory phases"—periods of high utilization where routes must leap to higher entities—multi-layer systems maintain much higher stability.

Performance comparison between Multi-Layered and LEO-only routing, showing end-to-end delay and packet loss probability.

As shown in the performance data, Multi-Layered Satellite Routing (MLSR) keeps packet loss below 6%, whereas single-layer LEO routing experiences spikes up to 34% during peak utilization. Furthermore, AI-based anomaly detection methods like ITAD and OCSVM achieved accuracies between 0.88 and 0.99 on satellite-specific datasets such as House Keeping TeleMetry (HKTM).

Future Directions and Challenges

Despite the promise of AI, several bottlenecks remain:

  1. Onboard Constraints: Limited computer capacity on satellites hinders real-time deployment of heavy deep learning models.
  2. Lack of Standards: Most current protocols rely on empirical analysis rather than formal security models.
  3. Emerging Tech: Future research should explore Blockchain for decentralized identity management and Mobile Edge Computing (MEC) to offload security computations to gateways.

Ultimately, the integration of AI, digital twins, and blockchain into SINs will be a long-term technical challenge essential for maintaining cybersecurity in the next generation of global communications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Space information networks is network systems that can receive, transmit, and process spatial information lively. It uses satellites, stratosphere airships, Unmanned Aerial Vehicles, and other platforms as the carrier. It supports high-dynamic, real-time broadband transmission of earth observations and ultra-long-distance, long-delay reliable transmission of deep space exploration. The deeper the network integration, the higher the system's security concerns and the more likely SINs will be controlled and destroyed in terms of cybersecurity. How to integrate new IT technologies such as artificial intelligence, digital twins, and blockchain to diverse application scenarios of SINs while maintaining SIN cybersecurity will be a long-term critical technical issue. This study is a review of the security issues for space information networks. First, this paper examines space information networks' security issues and figures out the relationship between the main security threats, services, and mechanisms. Then, this article selects secure routing and anomaly detection from many security technologies to conduct a detailed overview from two perspectives of traditional methods and artificial intelligence. Subsequently, this paper investigates anomaly detection schemes for spatial information networks and proposes a deep learning-based anomaly detection scheme. Finally, we suggest the potential research directions and opening problems of space information network security. Overall, this paper aims to give readers an overview of the newly emerging technologies in space information networks' security issues and provide inspiration for future exploration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhuo2021survey,
  author = {Ming Zhuo and Leyuan Liu and Shijie Zhou and Zhiwen Tian},
  title = {{Survey on security issues of routing and anomaly detection for space information networks}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-01638-z},
}
Figure