Surveillance of acute infectious gastroenteritis (1992–2009) and food-borne disease outbreaks (1996–2009) in Italy, with a focus on the Piedmont and Lombardy regions

Lapo Mughini‐Gras, Caterina Graziani, Felicina Biorci, Anna Pavan, Renata Magliola, Antonia Ricci, Giorgio Gilli, Elisabetta Carraro, Luca BusaniEurosurveillance 2012 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the effectiveness of regional, internet-based surveillance systems in Piedmont and Lombardy, Italy, in improving the detection and reporting of acute infectious gastroenteritis (AGE) and food-borne disease outbreaks. By comparing regional data with national averages from the National Infectious Diseases Notification System (SIMI) over nearly two decades, researchers found that digitalized regional reporting significantly increased notification rates for non-typhoid salmonellosis and infectious diarrhea, providing a more accurate epidemiological picture than traditional national systems.

The "Iceberg" Problem in Public Health

Official statistics for acute infectious gastroenteritis often represent only the "tip of the iceberg." Most cases are mild, leading to significant under-reporting because patients may not seek medical care, or physicians may not request diagnostic tests or report confirmed cases. In Italy, the chronic under-reporting in the National Infectious Diseases Notification System (SIMI) prompted the development of more sensitive regional interventions.

Surveillance Architecture and Methods

The study analyzed notification data from 1992 to 2009, focusing on two proxies for AGE: non-typhoid salmonellosis and infectious diarrhoea. The researchers compared regional notification rates from Piedmont (system launched in 2002) and Lombardy (system launched in 2004) against the national mean.

Flowchart of the food-borne disease surveillance system in Italy, illustrating the reporting path from local health units to the national system (SIMI).

The regional systems utilized internet-based platforms to facilitate better coordination between laboratories, physicians, and local health units. Statistical tools like the Cuzick test for temporal trends and Mann–Whitney tests for group comparisons were used to validate the findings.

Key Insights: The Digital Dividend

The transition to web-based management yielded several critical improvements:

  • Increased Sensitivity: Regional systems detected significantly more cases per 100,000 people than the national average.
  • Early Warning: Regional systems flagged increases in Salmonella isolates 1–2 years before national or European authorities (EFSA) identified the trends.
  • Demographic Focus: Data confirmed that children aged 0–14 years remain the most vulnerable group, with the highest notification rates.

Results and Regional Divergence

While national salmonellosis rates decreased by 86% between 1992 and 2009—likely due to improved food safety—the regional systems in Lombardy and Piedmont showed a relative rise in notifications starting around 2006.

  • Salmonellosis: Piedmont and Lombardy reported 1.6 and 10.3 more cases per 100,000, respectively, compared to the national mean post-implementation.
  • Infectious Diarrhoea: Regional reporting exceeded the national average by 3.9 (Piedmont) and 13.3 (Lombardy) cases per 100,000.
  • Outbreak Reporting: Interestingly, while individual case reporting improved, the increase in reporting of multi-case outbreaks was not statistically significant, highlighting the ongoing difficulty of identifying common infection sources.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite the success of these systems, manual data entry remains a bottleneck, introducing delays and potential errors. Furthermore, the systems currently lack automated spatio-temporal cluster detection for real-time hotspot identification.

Future public health surveillance should prioritize full electronic reporting directly from diagnostic laboratories to the surveillance system. Scaling these regional models nationwide could significantly enhance Italy's ability to respond to food-borne threats and infectious disease outbreaks.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe trends in the occurrence of acute infectious gastroenteritis (1992 to 2009) and food-borne disease outbreaks (1996 to 2009) in Italy. In 2002, the Piedmont region implemented a surveillance system for early detection and control of food-borne disease outbreaks; in 2004, the Lombardy region implemented a system for surveillance of all notifiable human infectious diseases. Both systems are internet based. We compared the regional figures with the national mean using official notification data provided by the National Infectious Diseases Notification System (SIMI) and the National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT), in order to provide additional information about the epidemiology of these diseases in Italy. When compared with the national mean, data from the two regional systems showed a significant increase in notification rates of non-typhoid salmonellosis and infectious diarrhoea other than non-typhoid salmonellosis, but for food-borne disease outbreaks, the increase was not statistically significant. Although the two regional systems have different objectives and structures, they showed improved sensitivity regarding notification of cases of acute infectious gastroenteritis and, to a lesser extent, food-borne disease outbreaks, and thus provide a more complete picture of the epidemiology of these diseases in Italy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mughinigras2012surveillance,
  author = {Lapo Mughini‐Gras and Caterina Graziani and Felicina Biorci and Anna Pavan and Renata Magliola and Antonia Ricci and Giorgio Gilli and Elisabetta Carraro and Luca Busani},
  title = {{Surveillance of acute infectious gastroenteritis (1992–2009) and food-borne disease outbreaks (1996–2009) in Italy, with a focus on the Piedmont and Lombardy regions}},
  booktitle = {Eurosurveillance},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.2807/ese.17.08.20098-en},
}
Figure