Surpassing millisecond coherence times in on-chip superconducting quantum memories by optimizing materials, processes, and circuit design

Suhas Ganjam, Yanhao Wang, Yao Lü, Archan Banerjee, Chan U Lei, Lev Krayzman, Kim Kisslinger, Chenyu Zhou, Ruoshui Li, Yichen Jia, Mingzhao Liu, Luigi Frunzio, Robert SchoelkopfarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers at Yale University and Brookhaven National Laboratory have shattered the millisecond barrier for on-chip superconducting quantum memories. By developing a novel "tripole stripline" resonator to isolate and quantify specific sources of energy loss, the team optimized a tantalum-on-sapphire materials platform to achieve record-breaking coherence times of up to 2.7 milliseconds.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the race to build a practical quantum computer, "coherence time"—how long a quantum state survives before leaking into the environment—is the ultimate metric. Superconducting circuits have improved vastly, but we still lack a complete "loss budget" for them. When a qubit loses energy, is it because of the metal surface, the bulk of the substrate, or the way the chip is packaged?

Usually, these effects are tangled together, making it nearly impossible to know which knob to turn. To reach the next level of performance, researchers need a way to predict device behavior by precisely measuring individual loss mechanisms and then engineering circuits that "hide" from the most dominant ones.

Methods

The authors introduced several clever techniques to deconstruct quantum "noise":

  • The Tripole Stripline: This is a new multimode resonator design. It supports three distinct electromagnetic modes, each engineered to be sensitive to a different type of loss: one "sees" mostly surface loss, another focuses on the bulk substrate, and the third detects losses from the physical package (seams and walls).
  • Materials & Process Optimization: They moved beyond standard aluminum, using tantalum thin films. They also tested various grades of sapphire and applied high-temperature annealing (1200°C) to the substrates to create atomically flat surfaces.
  • Energy Participation Ratio (EPR) Modeling: By measuring the loss factors in their resonators, they used a mathematical model to predict exactly how a transmon qubit made of the same materials would perform.
  • The Hairpin Geometry: To create the final memory, they designed a "hairpin" stripline. This geometry folds the electromagnetic field inward, making it nearly "blind" to the lossy walls of the metal package.

Datasets

While not a "dataset" in the machine-learning sense, the study relies on a comprehensive suite of experimental measurements:

  • Resonator Library: Data from dozens of tripole striplines across different material combinations (Al vs. Ta, annealed vs. unannealed, and three grades of sapphire: EFG, HEM, and HEMEX).
  • Validation Qubits: Coherence data from co-fabricated aluminum and tantalum transmon qubits used to verify the predictive model.
  • Memory Devices: Performance metrics from four distinct "Hairpin" quantum memory chips (labeled QM1-4).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tantalum Wins: Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) revealed that tantalum grows nearly epitaxially on sapphire, avoiding the messy, amorphous "oxide layer" found in aluminum. This reduces surface loss by more than a factor of two.
  • Annealing is Essential: Heating the sapphire doesn't just clean it; it reorganizes the surface into a "stepped" terrace structure. This slashed bulk dielectric loss by up to 8x in certain sapphire grades.
  • Stability over Time: A major "aha" moment was the temporal stability. While standard qubits fluctuate wildly because they are sensitive to single defects (Two-Level Systems) near their tiny junctions, these larger stripline memories are incredibly stable, fluctuating by only ±10% over 30 hours.
  • Predictive Power: The team demonstrated they could accurately predict a qubit's $T_1$ (lifetime) based solely on resonator data, proving that loss is a predictable material property rather than a mystery.

Key Results

  • Record Coherence: The on-chip quantum memories achieved single-photon Ramsey times ($T_2$) of 2.0–2.7 ms.
  • Energy Relaxation: The energy relaxation times ($T_1$) reached 1.0–1.4 ms, the highest reported for an on-chip superconducting memory to date.
  • Qubit Improvement: Tantalum-based transmon qubits showed a 2x improvement over aluminum versions, consistently reaching $T_1$ values around 300 µs.
  • Bulk Loss Limit: They identified a bulk loss factor for annealed HEMEX sapphire as low as $2.8 \times 10^{-8}$, suggesting that the substrate itself is now the primary bottleneck, not the fabrication process.

Limitations and Future Work

Despite the record-breaking memory times, the ancilla transmon (the "controller" qubit) is still limited by surface losses. Because the transmon requires a tiny Josephson junction, it concentrates electric fields into a very small area, making it much more sensitive to surface defects than the memory itself.

Future work will likely focus on "cleaning up" the junction interface or finding even higher-purity substrates to bring the ancilla's coherence up to the millisecond level of the memory. Additionally, while this work used a coaxial architecture, the authors suggest these insights could be adapted for more complex, multi-qubit planar systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The performance of superconducting quantum circuits for quantum computing has advanced tremendously in recent decades; however, a comprehensive understanding of relaxation mechanisms does not yet exist. In this work, we utilize a multimode approach to characterizing energy losses in superconducting quantum circuits, with the goals of predicting device performance and improving coherence through materials, process, and circuit design optimization. Using this approach, we measure significant reductions in surface and bulk dielectric losses by employing a tantalum-based materials platform and annealed sapphire substrates. With this knowledge we predict and experimentally verify the relaxation times of aluminum- and tantalum-based transmon qubits. We additionally optimize device geometry to maximize coherence within a coaxial tunnel architecture, and realize on-chip quantum memories with single-photon Ramsey times of 2.0$-$2.7 ms, limited by their energy relaxation times of 1.0$-$1.4 ms. To our knowledge this is the highest coherence achieved in an on-chip quantum memory, and demonstrates an advancement towards a more modular and compact coaxial circuit architecture for bosonic qubits with reproducibly high coherence.
BibTeX
@misc{ganjam2023surpassing,
  author = {Suhas Ganjam and Yanhao Wang and Yao Lü and Archan Banerjee and Chan U Lei and Lev Krayzman and Kim Kisslinger and Chenyu Zhou and Ruoshui Li and Yichen Jia and Mingzhao Liu and Luigi Frunzio and Robert Schoelkopf},
  title = {{Surpassing millisecond coherence times in on-chip superconducting quantum memories by optimizing materials, processes, and circuit design}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.15539},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15539},
}

Loading related content...

Figure