Surface EMG of jaw elevator muscles: effect of electrode location and inter‐electrode distance

Tommaso Castroflorio, Dario Farina, A. Bottin, Maria Grazia Piancino, Pierangiola Bracco, Roberto MerlettiJournal of Oral Rehabilitation 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the precise placement of surface EMG electrodes on jaw muscles significantly impacts recorded signal variability, with larger inter-electrode distances reducing this sensitivity. The findings highlight the critical need to standardize electrode placement and inter-electrode distance for reliable comparisons in research and clinical settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Surface electromyography (EMG) is a powerful, non-invasive tool for assessing muscle activity. However, modeling studies have consistently shown that where you place the electrodes on a muscle can drastically alter the recorded signal. This is particularly true for muscles with complex architectures or near innervation zones and tendons. For jaw elevator muscles (like the masseter and temporalis), which are crucial for chewing and speaking, there's a notable lack of clear methodological guidance on how electrode placement and the distance between electrodes (inter-electrode distance, IED) affect EMG signal analysis. Previous studies often used varying IEDs without specifying optimal placement criteria, making it difficult to compare results across different research groups or even within the same study over time. This paper aims to quantify this sensitivity and provide recommendations for more robust EMG recordings from these muscles.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-channel surface EMG technique using a linear array of 16 silver-point electrodes, each with a 1 mm diameter and an initial inter-electrode distance of 2.5 mm. This allowed them to simulate various bipolar recording configurations by combining adjacent electrodes, effectively creating IEDs ranging from 2.5 mm to 20 mm in 2.5 mm increments.

They investigated two key jaw elevator muscles: the superficial masseter and the anterior temporalis, in 13 healthy subjects. For each muscle, subjects performed maximal voluntary clenching for 10 seconds.

The core of their analysis focused on two EMG variables:

  • Average Rectified Value (ARV): A measure of signal amplitude.
  • Mean Power Spectral Frequency (MNF): A spectral measure reflecting the central tendency of the signal's frequency content.

To quantify the impact of electrode placement, they calculated:

  • Total Variability (Atot): The maximum percentage difference in EMG variable estimates across all electrode locations on the muscle, normalized to the mean. This indicates the potential error if electrodes are placed arbitrarily.
  • Minimum Variability (Amin): The minimal percentage difference in EMG variable estimates between adjacent electrode locations. This represents the sensitivity to small displacements when the recording is placed in the most stable location.

Statistical analysis involved three-way repeated measures ANOVA to assess the effects of muscle, side (left/right), and IED on Atot and Amin, followed by post-hoc tests for specific comparisons.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used data collected from 13 healthy human subjects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Placement Matters (A Lot): The study unequivocally demonstrates that even small electrode displacements can lead to massive variations (over 100%) in EMG signal estimates, especially when electrodes are placed without specific criteria. This underscores the inherent variability in surface EMG recordings.
  • IED is a Key Moderator: Increasing the inter-electrode distance significantly reduces the variability caused by electrode placement. This suggests that a larger IED offers a more stable and less sensitive measurement to minor positional shifts.
  • Spectral vs. Amplitude Sensitivity: While both amplitude (ARV) and spectral (MNF) variables are sensitive to placement, amplitude measures appear to be more affected by electrode location.
  • Optimal Placement Criteria: The study proposes a method to identify an "optimal electrode location" that minimizes sensitivity to small displacements. This is crucial for improving the repeatability of measurements.
  • Standardization is Paramount: The findings strongly advocate for fixing the inter-electrode distance when comparing EMG data across different subjects, muscles, or experimental conditions to ensure meaningful comparisons.

Key Results

  • Maximal Variability (Atot): For small IEDs (e.g., 2.5 mm), Atot values exceeded 100%, meaning estimates could vary by more than the original value. As IED increased, Atot decreased, reaching around 40% for commonly used IEDs.
  • Minimal Variability (Amin): Amin was generally smaller than Atot, indicating that even with optimal placement, some variability exists. For spectral variables (MNF), Amin was not significantly affected by IED. For amplitude variables (ARV), Amin was smallest at a 2.5 mm IED, suggesting that at this distance, there's a location that is relatively stable.
  • Optimal Location: The study identified specific optimal locations for electrode placement: 23.1 ± 7.7% of the mandibular angle-cantus distance for the masseter and 24.4 ± 6.6 mm for the temporalis.
  • IED Effect on Variables: As IED increased, MNF tended to decrease, and ARV tended to increase. This is attributed to the larger detection volume with larger IEDs.
  • Inter-Muscle Differences: The temporalis muscle showed higher Atot values than the masseter, indicating it's more sensitive to electrode placement. ARV values were also higher for the temporalis than the masseter.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subject Variability: The authors note that the optimal electrode location varied considerably within subjects, likely due to the spread of innervation zones and muscle fiber length. This suggests that individual subject-specific optimization might still be necessary.
  • Electrode Size: While the study used small electrodes (1 mm diameter), they acknowledge that larger electrodes, which cover a greater detection volume, might yield different variability patterns. However, they posit that the general conclusions regarding the effect of IED should hold.
  • Normalization: The paper briefly mentions that normalization procedures (e.g., expressing signals as a percentage of a maximal voluntary contraction) could further decrease amplitude variability but also introduces its own challenges, such as the reproducibility of the normalization contraction.
  • Future Work: The study implicitly suggests that future research should adopt standardized electrode placement and IEDs. Further investigation into the impact of different electrode sizes and normalization techniques on these findings would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study addresses methodological issues on surface electromyographic (EMG) signal recording from jaw elevator muscles. The aims were (i) to investigate the sensitivity to electrode displacements of amplitude and spectral surface EMG variables, (ii) to analyse if this sensitivity is affected by the inter-electrode distance of the bipolar recording, and (iii) to investigate the effect of inter-electrode distance on the estimated amplitude and spectral EMG variables. The superficial masseter and anterior temporalis muscles of 13 subjects were investigated by means of a linear electrode array. The percentage difference in EMG variable estimates from signals detected at different locations over the muscle was larger than 100% of the estimated value. Increasing the inter-electrode distance resulted in a significant reduction of the estimation variability because of electrode displacement. A criterion for electrode placement selection is suggested, with which the sensitivity of EMG variables to small electrode displacements was of the order of 2% for spectral and 6% for amplitude variables. Finally, spectral and, in particular, amplitude EMG variables were very sensitive to inter-electrode distance, which thus should be fixed when subjects or muscles are compared in the same or different experimental conditions.
BibTeX
@article{castroflorio2005surface,
  author = {Tommaso Castroflorio and Dario Farina and A. Bottin and Maria Grazia Piancino and Pierangiola Bracco and Roberto Merletti},
  title = {{Surface EMG of jaw elevator muscles: effect of electrode location and inter‐electrode distance}},
  journal = {Journal of Oral Rehabilitation},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1111/j.1365-2842.2005.01442.x},
}
Figure