Surface EMG cross talk quantified at the motor unit population level for muscles of the hand, thigh, and calf

Carina Marconi Germer, Dario Farina, Leonardo Abdala Elias, Stefano Nuccio, François Hug, Alessandro Del VecchioJournal of Applied Physiology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to quantify surface electromyography (sEMG) crosstalk at the individual motor unit level, revealing that crosstalk can lead to significant misinterpretations of muscle activity and intermuscular coordination. The study demonstrates that spatial filtering techniques, particularly double differential, are effective in reducing crosstalk, offering a practical solution for improving sEMG signal analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Surface electromyography (sEMG) is a widely used tool for studying neuromuscular activity, but its interpretation can be compromised by "crosstalk." Crosstalk occurs when electrical signals from one muscle are detected by electrodes placed over a neighboring muscle. This contamination can lead to overestimations of muscle activity and inaccurate assessments of how different muscles coordinate their actions (intermuscular correlation). While crosstalk has been acknowledged, precisely quantifying it, especially at the fundamental level of individual motor units across various muscle groups, and understanding its impact on different sEMG analysis metrics has remained a challenge. This paper aims to address this by providing a detailed, motor-unit-level characterization of crosstalk and evaluating methods to mitigate it.

Methods

The researchers employed high-density surface EMG (HD-sEMG) to record muscle activity from participants performing isometric contractions of hand, thigh, and calf muscles. A key methodological innovation was the decomposition of HD-sEMG signals into individual motor unit spike trains. This allowed for the precise identification of motor unit action potentials (MUAPs) and, crucially, the detection and quantification of crosstalk MUAPs (Cross MUAPs) in neighboring muscles.

To assess crosstalk significance, they used a statistical approach: spike-triggered averaging (STA) of EMG signals from neighboring muscles using identified motor unit discharge times. The significance of a Cross MUAP was determined by comparing its amplitude to a noise threshold derived from random trigger sequences.

The study also investigated the effectiveness of spatial filtering techniques: single differential (SD) and double differential (DD). These methods involve mathematical combinations of signals from adjacent electrodes to enhance signal specificity and reduce common noise.

Finally, the influence of crosstalk on various sEMG metrics was evaluated, including:

  • Motor unit crosstalk amplitude and index: Quantifying the magnitude and relative contribution of crosstalk.
  • EMG signal reconstruction: Creating "Synthetic EMG" (crosstalk-free signal from decomposed motor units) and "Cross EMG" (crosstalk from neighboring muscles) to isolate and analyze crosstalk's effects.
  • Time-domain metrics: Assessing the impact on overall muscle activity (RMS).
  • Frequency-domain metrics: Examining changes in the EMG power spectrum (median frequency).
  • Intermuscular correlation: Evaluating how crosstalk affects the correlation between the EMG signals of different muscles.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 25 healthy volunteers (participants) performing specific isometric contraction tasks. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation; rather, the data was generated specifically for this research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Crosstalk is pervasive and motor-unit-specific: Nearly all muscles studied exhibited crosstalk, and its presence varied significantly between individual motor units and muscle pairs. This highlights that crosstalk isn't a uniform phenomenon but rather a complex interaction dependent on individual unit properties and spatial relationships.
  • Spatial filtering is a powerful tool: The study strongly supports the use of spatial filtering (SD and especially DD) as an effective and simple method to reduce crosstalk. This is a practical takeaway for researchers and clinicians using sEMG.
  • Crosstalk significantly biases intermuscular correlation: This is a critical finding. Crosstalk can artificially inflate the perceived coordination between muscles, potentially leading to incorrect conclusions about muscle synergy.
  • Crosstalk's impact on power spectrum is minor: While crosstalk does slightly shift the EMG power spectrum, it's unlikely to cause major misinterpretations, and conventional temporal filtering is ineffective against it. This suggests that frequency-domain analysis might be more robust to crosstalk than time-domain metrics like correlation.
  • Asymmetry in crosstalk: The study observed asymmetric crosstalk between muscle pairs (e.g., FDI to thenar vs. thenar to FDI), likely related to differences in muscle activation levels and motor unit properties.

Key Results

  • Prevalence of crosstalk: In monopolar recording mode, approximately 80% of motor units generated significant crosstalk signals to neighboring muscles. This proportion decreased significantly with spatial filtering: to 50% for single differential (SD) and 42% for double differential (DD).
  • Crosstalk magnitude: Relative crosstalk amplitude (RMS) ranged from 8% to 44% of the EMG signal in monopolar mode.
  • Intermuscular correlation overestimation: Crosstalk led to a significant overestimation of intermuscular correlation. Spatial filtering, particularly DD, effectively reduced or abolished this overestimation for most muscle pairs.
  • Power spectrum shift: Crosstalk removal slightly increased the median frequency of the EMG power spectrum, but the shift was small (maximum 4 Hz), indicating a minor effect.
  • Spatial filtering effectiveness: DD was particularly effective in reducing crosstalk and its influence on intermuscular correlation, confirming its utility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Motor unit identification dependency: Crosstalk estimation relies on the number of identified motor units. The study acknowledges that Cross EMG might be underestimated if not all motor units were identified.
  • Limited electrode coverage: The method only accounted for crosstalk from motor units within the electrodes' pick-up volume, not considering different activation regions or compartments of complex muscles (e.g., soleus).
  • Sample bias: The participant sample was predominantly male, limiting the generalizability of findings to females. Sex-related anatomical differences (e.g., subcutaneous tissue thickness) could influence crosstalk.
  • Synchronization effects: Simultaneous muscle contractions could lead to synchronized motor unit activity, potentially biasing STA-derived MUAP amplitudes and correlation analyses.
  • Future work: The authors suggest future studies could delve deeper into motor unit action potential characteristics, separating propagating and non-propagating components, and evaluating the effect of volume conduction on spatial crosstalk distribution. Further investigation into sex-related differences is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cross talk is an important source of error in interpreting surface electromyography (EMG) signals. Here, we aimed at characterizing cross talk for three groups of synergistic muscles by the identification of individual motor unit action potentials. Moreover, we explored whether spatial filtering (single and double differential) of the EMG signals influences the level of cross talk. Three experiments were conducted. Participants (total 25) performed isometric contractions at 10% of the maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) with digit muscles and knee extensors and at 30% MVC with plantar flexors. High-density surface EMG signals were recorded and decomposed into motor unit spike trains. For each muscle, we quantified the cross talk induced to neighboring muscles and the level of contamination by the nearby muscle activity. We also estimated the influence of cross talk on the EMG power spectrum and intermuscular correlation. Most motor units (80%) generated significant cross-talk signals to neighboring muscle EMG in monopolar recording mode, but this proportion decreased with spatial filtering (50% and 42% for single and double differential, respectively). Cross talk induced overestimations of intermuscular correlation and has a small effect on the EMG power spectrum, which indicates that cross talk is not reduced with high-pass temporal filtering. Conversely, spatial filtering reduced the cross-talk magnitude and the overestimations of intermuscular correlation, confirming to be an effective and simple technique to reduce cross talk. This paper presents a new method for the identification and quantification of cross talk at the motor unit level and clarifies the influence of cross talk on EMG interpretation for muscles with different anatomy.<b>NEW & NOTEWORTHY</b> We proposed a new method for the identification and quantification of cross talk at the motor unit level. We show that surface EMG cross talk can lead to physiological misinterpretations of EMG signals such as overestimations in the muscle activity and intermuscular correlation. Cross talk had little influence on the EMG power spectrum, which indicates that conventional temporal filtering cannot minimize cross talk. Spatial filter (single and double differential) effectively reduces but not abolish cross talk.
BibTeX
@article{germer2021surface,
  author = {Carina Marconi Germer and Dario Farina and Leonardo Abdala Elias and Stefano Nuccio and François Hug and Alessandro Del Vecchio},
  title = {{Surface EMG cross talk quantified at the motor unit population level for muscles of the hand, thigh, and calf}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Physiology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1152/japplphysiol.01041.2020},
}
Figure