Surface Effects on Nanoindentation

Tong‐Yi Zhang, Wei-Hua XuJournal of Materials research/Pratt's Guide to Venture Capital Sources 2002 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the concept of "apparent surface stress" to explain depth-dependent hardness in nanoindentation. By accounting for this surface work alongside bulk deformation, the authors develop a model that accurately predicts experimental hardness data across a wide range of materials, revealing a critical indentation depth below which surface effects dominate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nanoindentation is a crucial technique for characterizing the mechanical properties of materials at the micro- and nanoscale. A well-documented phenomenon is "depth-dependent hardness," where a material appears harder at shallower indentation depths. Existing models, like strain-gradient plasticity, explain this by considering bulk deformation mechanisms. However, these models often neglect the energy dissipated at the material's surface during indentation. This paper addresses the gap by proposing that surface effects, specifically the energy required to deform the surface itself, play a significant role in depth-dependent hardness, especially at very small indentation depths.

Methods

The authors propose a theoretical framework that divides the work done during indentation into two components: bulk work and surface work. They introduce "apparent surface stress" ($\textit{f}$) as a parameter representing the energy dissipated per unit area of the solid surface. This apparent surface stress is theorized to include contributions from both intrinsic surface stress and pseudo-surface stress arising from friction and plastic deformation at the contact interface.

They derive equations for depth-dependent hardness ($\textit{H}$) that incorporate this apparent surface stress, with specific forms for different indenter tip geometries (conical, Northstar, Berkovich, Vickers). For instance, for sharp indenters, the relationship is given by $\textit{H} = \textit{H}_0 + \textit{g} \textit{f}/\textit{h}$, where $\textit{H}_0$ is the hardness at large depths, $\textit{g}$ is a geometric factor, and $\textit{h}$ is the indentation depth.

The core of their method involves fitting this theoretical model to experimental nanoindentation data from various materials. By analyzing the linear relationship between hardness and the reciprocal of indentation depth ($\textit{1/h}$), they extract values for $\textit{H}_0$ and $\textit{f}$. They also introduce a "critical indentation depth" ($\textit{h}_c$) where the dominance shifts from surface to bulk deformation.

Datasets

The paper utilizes a variety of experimental nanoindentation data from the literature and their own laboratory. These datasets cover a broad spectrum of materials, including:

  • Metals: (111) single-crystal Cu, polycrystalline Cu, (110) Ag, (100) Ag, (111) W, (110) W, (100) W, (100) Al, Au film, Al films (1-µm and 2-µm thick).
  • Polymers: Silicone elastomer, polycarbonate, epoxy resin.
  • Ceramics/Amorphous Materials: Diamond-like carbon (DLC) films (annealed and unannealed).

The data is presented as hardness versus the reciprocal indentation depth, often with different tip radii or crystalline orientations considered.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surface Work is Crucial: The study strongly suggests that surface effects are not negligible and play a significant role in depth-dependent hardness, particularly at shallow indentation depths.
  • Apparent Surface Stress: The introduction of "apparent surface stress" provides a quantifiable parameter to represent the energy dissipation at the surface, unifying the explanation across diverse materials.
  • Critical Indentation Depth: The concept of a critical indentation depth ($\textit{h}_c$) is a key outcome, defining a threshold below which surface deformation dominates and above which bulk deformation takes over. This offers a new way to understand the transition in deformation mechanisms.
  • Material Dependence: The extracted apparent surface stress values vary significantly across materials, with harder materials generally exhibiting higher $\textit{f}$ values. This suggests a link between material properties and surface energy dissipation.
  • Surface Roughness Impact: The authors postulate that surface roughness might consume more energy during indentation, leading to higher apparent surface stress, as observed in mechanically polished versus electrochemically polished copper.
  • Tip Geometry Matters: The model accounts for different indenter tip shapes, showing that the geometric factor ($\textit{g}$) influences the relationship between hardness and apparent surface stress.

Key Results

  • Linear Relationship: Experimental data for hardness versus the reciprocal indentation depth consistently show a linear relationship, supporting the proposed model.
  • Model Fit: The developed model, incorporating apparent surface stress, provides good agreement with empirical data for depth-dependent hardness across metals, polymers, and DLC films.
  • Extracted Parameters: Table II provides extracted values for $\textit{H}_0$ (hardness at large depth) and $\textit{f}$ (apparent surface stress) for numerous materials, offering a quantitative comparison. For example, mechanically polished (111) Cu yielded $\textit{H}_0$ = 0.662 GPa and $\textit{f}$ = 60.0 J/m², while electrochemically polished (111) Cu gave $\textit{H}_0$ = 0.718 GPa and $\textit{f}$ = 18.9 J/m².
  • Critical Depth Examples: For mechanically and electrochemically polished (111) Cu, critical depths were estimated at $\textit{h}_c$ = 75 nm and $\textit{h}_c$ = 111 nm, respectively.
  • Surface Effect Dominance: For (100) Al, fitting the data with the proposed surface-effect model yielded a significantly higher correlation coefficient ($\textit{r}^2$ = 0.9214) compared to a model neglecting surface effects ($\textit{r}^2$ = 0.5875), strongly supporting the surface effect's importance at nanometer scales.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Apparent Surface Stress Magnitude: The authors note that the extracted apparent surface stress is about 2 or 3 orders of magnitude higher than the surface energy of the same material. This suggests that "apparent surface stress" encompasses more than just intrinsic surface energy.
  • Surface Morphology: While surface roughness is hypothesized to influence apparent surface stress, a detailed understanding and quantification of this relationship are still needed.
  • Theoretical Refinement: More theoretical and experimental studies are called for to fully understand the nature of apparent surface stress and its precise relation to surface morphology.
  • Critical Depth Condition: The paper highlights that if $\textit{h}^* < 2\textit{A}^*$, the surface term may dominate over the entire indentation depth range, a condition that warrants further investigation.
  • Generalizability: While the model shows broad applicability, further validation across an even wider range of materials and conditions would be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2002surface,
  author = {Tong‐Yi Zhang and Wei-Hua Xu},
  title = {{Surface Effects on Nanoindentation}},
  journal = {Journal of Materials research/Pratt's Guide to Venture Capital Sources},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1557/jmr.2002.0254},
}
Figure