Supramolecular Environment-Dependent Electronic Properties of Metal–Organic Interfaces.

Afaf El‐Sayed, D. J. Mowbray, J. M. García‐Lastra, Celia Rogero, E. Goiri, Patrizia Borghetti, Ayse Turak, Bryan P. Doyle, Martina Dell’Angela, Luca Floreano, Yutaka Wakayama, Ángel Rubio, J. Enrique Ortega, Dimas G. de OteyzaThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the arrangement of organic molecules on a metal surface affects their electronic properties. By creating ordered "donor-acceptor" networks of fluorinated copper-phthalocyanines (F16CuPc) and pentacene (PEN) on gold, researchers found that these supramolecular structures significantly alter the electronic behavior of the molecules, particularly F16CuPc. This work highlights the importance of considering deeper electronic orbitals beyond the HOMO/LUMO for understanding charge transfer at interfaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organic electronics hold immense promise for miniaturization and novel functionalities, but their widespread adoption hinges on a deep understanding of how organic molecules behave at interfaces within devices. Crucial processes like charge injection and exciton separation are heavily influenced by these interfaces. While model systems of single organic molecules on metal surfaces have been extensively studied, understanding the complex interplay of molecule-molecule and molecule-substrate interactions in ordered multi-component systems is essential for designing and optimizing organic electronic devices. This paper addresses this by investigating a model donor-acceptor system (F16CuPc and PEN) on a gold surface, aiming to elucidate how their specific arrangement (monolayer vs. binary mixture) impacts their electronic structure and charge transfer properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining experimental and theoretical techniques:

  • Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM): Used to visualize the surface morphology and determine the crystallographic structure and ordering of the molecular layers. This allowed them to identify the formation of a long-range ordered donor-acceptor network in the binary mixture.
  • X-ray Photoemission Spectroscopy (XPS): Employed to probe the core-level electronic states of the constituent atoms (C, N, F) in the molecules. By analyzing shifts in these core-level energies, they could infer changes in the electronic environment and charge transfer.
  • Ultraviolet Valence Band Photoemission Spectroscopy (UPS): Used to investigate the valence band electronic structure, particularly the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and its vicinity.
  • Density Functional Theory (DFT) Calculations: Performed to model the electronic structure, adsorption energies, and charge distribution of the molecular layers, both in isolation and on the Au(111) substrate. These calculations were crucial for interpreting the experimental results and understanding the underlying physics. The calculations incorporated van der Waals (vdW) functionals to accurately capture long-range interactions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental data obtained from surface science techniques and theoretical calculations performed on model systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Supramolecular Ordering Dictates Electronic Properties: The formation of a specific ordered network, driven by intermolecular interactions (C-F···H-C hydrogen bonds in this case), significantly alters the electronic structure of the molecules compared to their isolated or single-component layers.
  • Beyond Frontier Orbitals: The most significant electronic changes in F16CuPc upon forming the binary mixture do not originate from its highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) but from deeper lying orbitals (HOMO-2, HOMO-3, HOMO-4). This challenges the common focus solely on HOMO/LUMO for understanding charge transfer.
  • Directed Charge Transfer: The binary mixture exhibits an increased charge transfer from F16CuPc to the gold substrate, which is directly linked to the upward shift and broadening of these deeper lying orbitals.
  • Enhanced Stability: The mixed layer forms a more stable and ordered network, making it easier to image and study, which is attributed to the maximized intermolecular interactions.

Key Results

  • A long-range ordered donor-acceptor network of F16CuPc and PEN was successfully formed on Au(111).
  • The electronic structure of F16CuPc showed significant changes in the binary mixture, with molecular orbitals shifting upwards in energy by approximately 0.07 eV.
  • Charge transfer from F16CuPc to the Au(111) substrate increased from 0.32 to 0.44 electrons per molecule in the mixed layer.
  • This charge transfer was found to primarily originate from deeper lying molecular orbitals (HOMO-2 to HOMO-4) rather than the HOMO.
  • The C-F and F 1s core-level XPS spectra of F16CuPc showed the largest shifts (~0.2 eV) in the mixed layer, indicating significant electronic changes at these outer atoms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model System: While this study uses a well-defined model system, translating these findings to more complex, real-world organic electronic devices will require further investigation.
  • Focus on F16CuPc: The electronic changes in PEN were less pronounced and harder to analyze due to coverage-dependent shifts. Future work could explore other donor molecules or different interface configurations.
  • Theoretical Accuracy: While DFT with vdW functionals provided good agreement, subtle differences between theory and experiment remain, potentially related to the excited-state nature of photoemission.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that understanding these supramolecularly driven electronic changes is crucial for designing functional donor-acceptor mixtures with optimized properties. Future work could focus on tailoring these interactions to precisely control charge transfer and other electronic phenomena for specific device applications. The ability to control electronic properties by designing molecular arrangements opens avenues for "a priori" design of new materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

Model donor–acceptor assemblies at metal–organic interfaces, namely, fluorinated copper-phthalocyanines (F16CuPC) and pentacene (PEN) assemblies on the Au(111) surface, have been the focus of the present study. A full picture of the crystallographic and electronic structure of PEN and F16CuPC monolayers as well as of their 1:1 binary mixture on the Au(111) surface has been explored by means of a variety of surface-sensitive techniques, providing important information on the intermolecular and molecule–substrate interactions governing the self-assembly process. A long-range ordered donor–acceptor network is observed for the mixture as a result of the greatly enhanced intermolecular interaction via C–F···H–C hydrogen bonds. Interestingly, the new supramolecular structure involves changes in the electronic structure of the molecular components. In particular, the strongest changes are observed at the C and F atoms of the F16CuPc, as opposed to the F16CuPc N, Cu, or PEN C atoms. With the aid of theoretical calculations, such effects are found to be at least partially related to an upward shift in energy of the F16CuPc molecular orbitals, concomitant with a molecule-to-metal charge donation, not from the HOMO, but deeper lying orbitals.
BibTeX
@article{elsayed2012supramolecular,
  author = {Afaf El‐Sayed and D. J. Mowbray and J. M. García‐Lastra and Celia Rogero and E. Goiri and Patrizia Borghetti and Ayse Turak and Bryan P. Doyle and Martina Dell’Angela and Luca Floreano and Yutaka Wakayama and Ángel Rubio and J. Enrique Ortega and Dimas G. de Oteyza},
  title = {{Supramolecular Environment-Dependent Electronic Properties of Metal–Organic Interfaces.}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1021/jp211749g},
}
Figure