Suppressive Lateral Interactions at Parafoveal Representations in Primary Visual Cortex

Arezoo Pooresmaeili, Jose L. Herrero, Matthew W. Self, Pieter R. Roelfsema, Alexander ThieleJournal of Neuroscience 2010 · DOI

Abstract

The perceptual salience and visibility of image elements is influenced by other elements in their vicinity. While collinear flanking elements usually improve sensitivity for a target in foveal vision, this study finds that in the parafovea, these flankers primarily exert suppressive effects. Recording from V1 neurons in macaques, the researchers demonstrate that collinear flankers reduce perceptual sensitivity by increasing baseline neural activity, which in turn reduces the dynamic range available for responding to the central target.

Introduction

Our visual system does not process objects in isolation; the context surrounding an element significantly alters its perception. A well-documented phenomenon in foveal psychophysics is facilitation: a faint target becomes easier to detect when flanked by collinear elements. However, a discrepancy exists between these human behavioral findings and animal neurophysiology, which often reports suppression at more eccentric parafoveal locations. This study investigates this gap by recording from the primary visual cortex (V1) of macaques during contrast detection tasks, specifically examining why the parafovea behaves differently than the fovea.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual approach using rhesus macaques. Single-unit recordings were taken from 72 V1 neurons during passive fixation to map Contrast Response Functions (CRFs). Additionally, multiunit recordings were obtained from 38 V1 sites while monkeys performed a contrast detection task, reporting the presence of a faint Gabor target via eye movements. Stimuli consisted of a central Gabor target and two collinear flankers placed at varying distances (1, 2, or 3 wavelengths, $\lambda$).

Experimental paradigm and raw neural responses. (A) Stimulus sequence for the contrast detection task. (B) Raster plots and PSTHs for a representative V1 neuron across different center contrasts and flanker distances.

Results

The study revealed that parafoveal V1 is dominated by lateral inhibition. Even at distances typically associated with facilitation in the fovea (3$\lambda$), flankers induced suppression.

Contrast response functions (CRFs) for two representative neurons. The curves illustrate how collinear flankers (colored lines) reduce the dynamic range compared to the center-only condition (black line).

A key finding was the mechanism of this suppression: flankers increased "ongoing activity" in the absence of a target (raising the "floor"), but simultaneously reduced the neuron's maximum firing capacity when the target appeared (lowering the "ceiling"). This reduction in dynamic range directly correlated with decreased behavioral sensitivity. Furthermore, the increased baseline activity acted as neural "noise," leading to a higher rate of false alarms in the detection task. The suppressive effect was strongest when flankers matched the neuron's preferred orientation (collinear) and weakest when they were orthogonal.

Discussion

These results suggest that the dominant effect of collinear flankers in parafoveal vision is suppression, contrasting with the facilitation observed at the fovea. This difference may stem from distinct neural "wiring" or the influence of top-down attention, which might override suppressive signals in the center of gaze. Future research is needed to directly compare foveal and parafoveal V1 using identical recording techniques to resolve whether these differences are inherent to the cortical architecture or modulated by behavioral state.

Summary updated

Abstract

The perceptual salience and visibility of image elements is influenced by other elements in their vicinity. The perceptual effect of image elements on an adjacent target element depends on their relative orientation. Collinear flanking elements usually improve sensitivity for the target element, whereas orthogonal elements have a weaker effect. It is believed that the collinear flankers exert these effects through lateral interactions between neurons in the primary visual cortex (area V1), but the precise mechanisms underlying these contextual interactions remain unknown. Here, we directly examined this question by recording the effects of flankers on the responses of V1 neurons at parafoveal representations while monkeys performed a fixation task or a contrast detection task. We found, unexpectedly, that collinear flankers reduce the monkeys' perceptual sensitivity for a central target element. This behavioral effect was explained by a flanker-induced increase in the activity of V1 neurons in the absence of the central target stimulus, which reduced the amplitude of the target response. Our results indicate that the dominant effect of collinear flankers in parafoveal vision is suppression and suggest that these suppressive effects are caused by a decrease in the dynamic range of neurons coding the central target.
BibTeX
@article{pooresmaeili2010suppressive,
  author = {Arezoo Pooresmaeili and Jose L. Herrero and Matthew W. Self and Pieter R. Roelfsema and Alexander Thiele},
  title = {{Suppressive Lateral Interactions at Parafoveal Representations in Primary Visual Cortex}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.6071-09.2010},
}
Figure