Suppression of a SARS-CoV-2 outbreak in the Italian municipality of Vo’
Enrico Lavezzo, Elisa Franchin, Constanze Ciavarella, Gina Cuomo-Dannenburg, Luisa Barzon, Claudia Del Vecchio, Lucía Rossi, Riccardo Manganelli, Arianna Loregian, Nicolò Navarin, Davide Abate, Manuela Sciro, Stefano Merigliano, Ettore De Canale, Maria Cristina Vanuzzo, Valeria Besutti, Francesca Saluzzo, Francesco Onelia, Monia Pacenti, Saverio Giuseppe Parisi, Giovanni Carretta, Daniele Donato, Luciano Flor, Silvia Cocchio, Giulia Masi, Alessandro Sperduti, Lorenzo Cattarino, Renato Salvador, Michele Nicoletti, Federico Caldart, G. Castelli, Eleonora Nieddu, Beatrice Labella, Ludovico Fava, Matteo Drigo, Katy A. M. Gaythorpe, Alessandra Rosalba Brazzale, Stefano Toppo, Marta Trevisan, Vincenzo Baldo, Christl A. Donnelly, Neil M. Ferguson, Ilaria Dorigatti, Andrea Crisanti, Kylie E. C. Ainslie, Marc Baguelin, Samir Bhatt, Adhiratha Boonyasiri, Olivia Boyd, Helen Coupland, Zulma M. Cucunubá, Bimandra A. Djafaara, Sabine van Elsland, Richard G. FitzJohn, Seth Flaxman, Will D. Green, Timothy B. Hallett, Arran Hamlet, David Haw, Natsuko Imai, Benjamin Jeffrey, Edward Knock, Daniel J. Laydon, Thomas A. Mellan, Swapnil Mishra, Gemma Nedjati‐Gilani, Pierre Nouvellet, Lucy Okell, Kris V. Parag, Steven Riley, Hayley A Thompson, H. Juliette T. Unwin, Robert Verity, Michaela Vollmer, Patrick Walker, Caroline E. Walters, Haowei Wang, Yuanrong Wang, Oliver J. Watson, Charles Whittaker, Lilith K. Whittles, Xiaoyue XiNature2020 · DOI
In early 2020, the global response to SARS-CoV-2 was hampered by significant unknowns regarding the role of asymptomatic carriers. The municipality of Vo’, Italy, became a unique "natural laboratory" following its first recorded COVID-19 death on February 21, 2020. In response, the regional government implemented a strict 14-day lockdown and attempted to test the entire population of approximately 3,300 residents. This study analyzes data from this comprehensive testing effort to quantify the frequency of asymptomatic infection, viral dynamics, and the efficacy of community-wide suppression strategies.
Methods and Study Design
The researchers conducted two sequential nasopharyngeal swab surveys to track the outbreak's progression. The first survey occurred at the start of the lockdown, and the second was conducted at its conclusion.
Flowchart of the study population and testing results across two survey periods.
Testing utilized RT-PCR for the E and RdRp genes. Viral load quantification was performed using cycle threshold ($C_t$) data to compare infectiousness across groups. Additionally, a modified SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered) model was developed to account for symptomatic, presymptomatic, and asymptomatic transmission pathways. Transmission chains were reconstructed using household and contact network data to estimate the reproduction number ($R_t$) and serial interval.
Key Findings
Asymptomatic Transmission and Viral Load
A critical discovery was that 42.5% of confirmed infections were entirely asymptomatic. Crucially, the study found no statistically significant difference in the viral loads of symptomatic versus asymptomatic individuals. This parity suggests that "silent" spreaders are major drivers of transmission, as they shed the virus at levels comparable to symptomatic patients.
Lockdown Efficacy and Prevalence Reduction
The combination of total-population testing and a strict lockdown proved highly effective. The reproduction number ($R_t$) plummeted from an initial 2.44 to 0.41.
Comparison of SARS-CoV-2 prevalence between the first and second surveys, showing a significant reduction.
As shown in the figure above, the prevalence of infection dropped from 2.6% (95% CI: 2.1–3.3%) in the first survey to 1.2% (95% CI: 0.8–1.8%) by the second. Only 8 new cases were detected in the final survey, indicating successful suppression of the local outbreak.
Demographic Observations
Notably, none of the 234 children under 10 years old tested positive in either survey, even when living in households with infected adults. While the sample size is small, this suggests significantly lower susceptibility in this age group during the initial wave.
Discussion and Limitations
The Vo’ study provided a blueprint for "test and trace" policies by demonstrating that identifying and isolating asymptomatic carriers is essential for controlling SARS-CoV-2. However, the study has limitations. PCR testing only identifies active infections; a serological survey would be required to determine the true cumulative infection rate. Furthermore, the model assumed perfect diagnostic sensitivity, though evidence of a +/-/+ test sequence in one participant suggests the possibility of rare false negatives.
Despite these limitations, the results from Vo’ underscore the power of mass testing and rapid intervention in suppressing viral transmission within a defined community.
Summary updated
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lavezzo2020suppression,
author = {Enrico Lavezzo and Elisa Franchin and Constanze Ciavarella and Gina Cuomo-Dannenburg and Luisa Barzon and Claudia Del Vecchio and Lucía Rossi and Riccardo Manganelli and Arianna Loregian and Nicolò Navarin and Davide Abate and Manuela Sciro and Stefano Merigliano and Ettore De Canale and Maria Cristina Vanuzzo and Valeria Besutti and Francesca Saluzzo and Francesco Onelia and Monia Pacenti and Saverio Giuseppe Parisi and Giovanni Carretta and Daniele Donato and Luciano Flor and Silvia Cocchio and Giulia Masi and Alessandro Sperduti and Lorenzo Cattarino and Renato Salvador and Michele Nicoletti and Federico Caldart and G. Castelli and Eleonora Nieddu and Beatrice Labella and Ludovico Fava and Matteo Drigo and Katy A. M. Gaythorpe and Alessandra Rosalba Brazzale and Stefano Toppo and Marta Trevisan and Vincenzo Baldo and Christl A. Donnelly and Neil M. Ferguson and Ilaria Dorigatti and Andrea Crisanti and Kylie E. C. Ainslie and Marc Baguelin and Samir Bhatt and Adhiratha Boonyasiri and Olivia Boyd and Lorenzo Cattarino and Constanze Ciavarella and Helen Coupland and Zulma M. Cucunubá and Gina Cuomo-Dannenburg and Bimandra A. Djafaara and Christl A. Donnelly and Ilaria Dorigatti and Sabine van Elsland and Richard G. FitzJohn and Seth Flaxman and Katy A. M. Gaythorpe and Will D. Green and Timothy B. Hallett and Arran Hamlet and David Haw and Natsuko Imai and Benjamin Jeffrey and Edward Knock and Daniel J. Laydon and Thomas A. Mellan and Swapnil Mishra and Gemma Nedjati‐Gilani and Pierre Nouvellet and Lucy Okell and Kris V. Parag and Steven Riley and Hayley A Thompson and H. Juliette T. Unwin and Robert Verity and Michaela Vollmer and Patrick Walker and Caroline E. Walters and Haowei Wang and Yuanrong Wang and Oliver J. Watson and Charles Whittaker and Lilith K. Whittles and Xiaoyue Xi and Neil M. Ferguson},
title = {{Suppression of a SARS-CoV-2 outbreak in the Italian municipality of Vo’}},
booktitle = {Nature},
year = {2020},
doi = {10.1038/s41586-020-2488-1},
}