Supporting the Development of Problem Solving Skills in an Integrated Electromagnetics and Vector Calculus Course

Carol P. Jaeger, Philip D. Loewen, Negar M. HarandiProceedings of the Canadian Engineering Education Association (CEEA) 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Electromagnetics and vector calculus are taught as an integrated course in the Electrical Engineering program at UBC. In this paper, the course structure is described, and unique features are highlighted. A key goal of the course is to help students develop problem solving skills. To assist students in building these skills, a blended classroom approach has been adopted to allow an increase in discussion and problem solving activities in the classroom. Results of student assessment and a summary of student feedback on the teaching technologies and activities incorporated into the course are reported.

Introduction

In many engineering programs, multivariable calculus and electromagnetics are taught as separate "silos." This separation often leads to a "retention gap," where students forget mathematical tools—such as Stokes' Theorem or Divergence—before they are required to apply them to physical phenomena like electric fields. Consequently, electromagnetics instructors often spend significant lecture time re-teaching basic calculus. Furthermore, students struggle with the transition from merely solving a provided integral to constructing the correct integral to model a physical device—a critical skill for professional engineering.

To address these challenges, researchers at the University of British Columbia (UBC) redesigned the curriculum into an integrated 3-credit course co-delivered by the Department of Mathematics and the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering. The goal was to bridge the gap between abstract math and engineering application by shifting focus from rote calculation to complex modeling skills.

Methodology and Technological Integration

The course adopted a "blended" classroom structure. Theoretical content was moved to pre-week videos, freeing up in-class time for collaborative problem-solving and discussion. Several key technologies were integrated to support this shift:

  • WeBWorK: An online platform providing randomized variables for homework, forcing students to discuss methodology rather than just comparing final answers.
  • ViDeX: A custom video platform allowing students to bookmark and annotate lecture videos while providing instructors with viewing data.
  • Mentimeter: A web-based tool for anonymous in-class polling, used to spark peer instruction and surface conceptual errors without social pressure.
  • Piazza: An online forum for peer-to-peer technical support.

Results and Student Sentiment

The efficacy of these interventions was tracked through diagnostic tests, mid-semester surveys, and longitudinal performance data from 2016 to 2018.

Student Perception of Tools

Survey data indicated high student satisfaction with the integrated tools. As shown in Figure 1, a significant majority of students rated "Solved Problems," "Webwork," and "Piazza" as very or somewhat useful. Specifically, approximately 85% of students found the randomized homework (WeBWorK) beneficial to their learning.

Student ratings of the usefulness of various course technologies and activities.

Academic Performance

Quantitative results showed notable gains. On qualitative electromagnetics questions, the class average rose from 40% at the term's start to 59% on the final exam. Furthermore, UBC students outperformed historical benchmarks on several key diagnostic questions.

A consistent positive correlation was observed between diligence in randomized homework and final course grades. As detailed in Figure 4, the R² value for homework vs. final grade remained relatively stable in most years, with values of 0.47 in 2016 and 0.46 in 2018.

Longitudinal performance data showing student scoring trends and the correlation between homework and final grades.

Discussion and Insights

One key insight was the "Passive Learning Trap": while students overwhelmingly desired more instructor-led problem solving, they were less enthusiastic about working on problems themselves. The authors argue that while watching an expert is easier, active participation is necessary to build the "muscle memory" required for exams.

The use of Mentimeter was particularly successful in fostering engagement, as anonymity allowed students to debate answers freely. Additionally, the randomization in WeBWorK effectively turned homework into a collaborative exercise focused on logic rather than rote calculation.

Limitations and Future Work

Despite these successes, challenges remain. Moving content to video format appeared to negatively impact physical attendance in some sections. Furthermore, scores on a 10-question concept inventory remained steady at approximately 60% over three years, suggesting that deep conceptual shifts are difficult to achieve within a single semester. Future work will focus on better tracking student interaction with specific resources to identify which activities most directly impact achievement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electromagnetics and vector calculus are taught as an integrated course in the Electrical Engineering program at UBC. In this paper, the course structure is described, and unique features are highlighted.A key goal of the course is to help students develop problem solving skills. To assist students in building these skills, a blended classroom approach has been adopted to allow an increase in discussion and problem solving activities in the classroom. Results of student assessment and a summary of student feedback on the teaching technologies and activities incorporated into the course are reported.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jaeger2018supporting,
  author = {Carol P. Jaeger and Philip D. Loewen and Negar M. Harandi},
  title = {{Supporting the Development of Problem Solving Skills in an Integrated Electromagnetics and Vector Calculus Course}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Canadian Engineering Education Association (CEEA)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.24908/pceea.v0i0.13080},
}
Figure