TL;DR
This paper introduces CloneCloud, a novel tool that visualizes code clones using tag clouds to help developers understand why code duplication occurs. By analyzing identifier names within clones, CloneCloud offers a more intuitive way to grasp the underlying reasons for code duplication, aiding in more effective refactoring decisions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper tackles the challenge of managing code clones, which are identical or similar code fragments within a software system. While detecting code clones has seen significant progress, the focus is shifting towards managing them, which requires understanding their context and reasons for existence. Developers often need to identify areas with a high concentration of clones to prioritize refactoring efforts. Existing visualization techniques, like scatterplots, effectively show where clones are located but struggle to explain why they are there. This gap makes it difficult for developers to intuitively grasp the implementation details that lead to duplication and to make informed refactoring decisions.
Methods
CloneCloud employs a multi-faceted approach to support clone analysis:
- Code Clone Detection: It utilizes CCFinder, a well-established token-based code clone detection system, to identify duplicated code segments within Java source files.
- Scatterplot View: This view, inspired by Live Scatterplots, visualizes the density of code clones between directories. It uses color-coding to highlight areas with high clone density, allowing developers to quickly pinpoint potential problem areas. Users can customize the visualization using metrics like "Clone Density" and "RNR(S)" (ratio of non-repeated code sequences in a clone set).
- Tag Cloud View: This is the core innovation. Instead of just showing locations, CloneCloud generates tag clouds from the identifier names (variables, methods, type names) found within detected code clones. The size and color of the tags (red for identifiers in clones, black for others) provide an intuitive representation of the most frequent and relevant identifiers associated with code duplication.
- Source Code View: When a user clicks on an identifier in the tag cloud, this view displays the actual source code of the clones containing that identifier, highlighting the selected identifier in red and other tag cloud identifiers in green. This allows for detailed examination and verification of hypotheses about the reasons for code duplication.
Datasets
The paper mentions using "source files of Java system" as input and specifically refers to an example using "Apache Ant revision 1486439" for demonstration purposes. No specific benchmark datasets are listed, nor are any new benchmarks introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging the "Why" Gap: The most significant insight is the realization that understanding why code clones exist is crucial for effective refactoring. Tag clouds, by visualizing identifier names, offer a novel and intuitive way to surface this "why."
- Identifier Names as Clues: The paper highlights that identifier names (variables, methods, types) are rich in semantic information and can provide strong clues about the underlying implementation logic that leads to code duplication.
- Interactive Exploration: The combination of scatterplots for coarse-grained location, tag clouds for semantic understanding, and source code views for detailed inspection creates a powerful interactive workflow for clone analysis.
- Prioritizing Refactoring: By identifying areas with high clone density and understanding the common identifiers within those clones, developers can more effectively prioritize which parts of the system to refactor.
Key Results
The paper presents a qualitative evaluation of CloneCloud's effectiveness through a usage example. It demonstrates how the tool can help a developer identify areas with high code clone concentration and then understand the underlying reasons by examining the generated tag clouds and source code. The authors argue that this approach provides a more intuitive understanding compared to traditional scatterplots alone, which lack lexical information. No quantitative results (e.g., accuracy metrics, performance benchmarks) are presented in this paper.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The paper acknowledges that the current implementation is focused on Java source code.
- No quantitative evaluation of CloneCloud's effectiveness is presented, relying instead on qualitative demonstration and argumentation.
- Future Work:
- The authors plan to conduct experiments to confirm the usefulness of CloneCloud by comparing its usage with existing clone visualizers.
- They aim to further refine the tool and its visualization capabilities.
Summary updated