Supply chain loss from easing COVID-19 restrictions: an evolutionary epidemiological-economic modeling study

Qingpeng Zhang, Yang Ye, Zhidong Cao, Daniel ZengResearch Square 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, many firms have been shifting their supply chains away from countries with stringent control measures to mitigate supply chain disruption. Nowadays, the global economy is reopening from the COVID-19 pandemic at various paces in different countries. Understanding how the global supply network evolves during and after the pandemic is necessary for determining the timing of reopening. By harnessing the real-world and real-time global human movement and the latest macroeconomic data, we propose an evolutionary epidemiological-economic model to explore the evolutionary dynamics of the global supply network under various global reopening scenarios. We find that the delay in full reopening in highly restrictive countries has limited public health benefits in the long run but leads to significant supply chain loss to less restrictive ones. Longer duration of stringent control measures leads to lower supply chain recovery in five years. The recovery rate varies across production sectors, depending on the characteristics of production, the degree of self-reliance, and the location of production hubs. This research presents the first data-driven evidence of supply chain loss due to the timing of reopening and sheds light on the post-pandemic supply chain reformation and recovery. Our results provide data-driven evidence that supports the reopening in countries with high vaccine coverage.

Introduction

Traditional economic assessments of the COVID-19 pandemic often treat the resulting disruptions as temporary "shocks"—short-term dips in production that naturally rebound once restrictions are lifted. However, this perspective overlooks the structural shifts that occur when global supply chains are severed for extended periods. If a supplier is unable to operate due to prolonged lockdowns, clients do not simply wait; they seek more reliable alternatives. This study addresses the long-term structural changes in the global supply network, investigating how the timing of reopening affects the permanent "fitness" and market share of national industries.

Methods

To capture these dynamics, the researchers developed a novel evolutionary epidemiological-economic model. This framework links two complex systems to simulate the interplay between public health policy and global trade.

  1. SVEIRD Meta-population Model: A disease transmission model tracking Susceptible, Vaccinated, Exposed, Infectious, Recovered, and Deceased populations across 141 countries. This model is driven by real-world global air traffic data to simulate international viral spread.
  2. Evolutionary Multi-Regional Input-Output (MRIO) Model: This core innovation applies Fisher’s fundamental theorem of natural selection to economics. Rather than assuming static market shares, it treats firms (sectors within countries) as entities competing for investment based on profitability and reliability. Pandemic restrictions that reduce labor availability act as a selective pressure, favoring firms in less restrictive environments.
The conceptual framework links global mobility and supply networks to model how labor availability impacts production and market evolution.

The study synthesized high-fidelity data from the GTAP 10 Database for supply network structures, the Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker for policy stringency (Containment and Health Index, CHI), and real-time air traffic and macroeconomic data on labor and Gross Value Added (GVA).

Key Insights and Results

The "Evolutionary Trap"

The model reveals that prolonged restrictions create an "evolutionary trap." Firms in high-restriction (High-CHI) countries lose profitability and production capacity. Simultaneously, firms in low-restriction (Low-CHI) countries expand to fill the void. This shift is not easily reversed; because capacity expansion requires significant time and investment, the market share migration is "sticky."

Diminishing Health Returns vs. Economic Cost

For highly transmissible variants like Omicron, the model suggests that extremely late reopening offers diminishing public health benefits. Late reopening often results in significant infection surges later due to lower levels of natural immunity, leading to cumulative mortality rates similar to earlier reopening scenarios but at a much higher economic cost.

Permanent GVA Loss and Recovery Lag

High-CHI countries are projected to suffer permanent GVA loss by the end of a five-year horizon. The global supply network does not return to pre-pandemic states within this window, as the "back-shifting" of supply chains to original hubs is significantly slower than the initial migration away from them. Regression analysis indicates that a sector's "risk diversity"—the extent to which its production hubs are concentrated in restrictive countries—is a primary predictor of its eventual market share loss.

Discussion and Limitations

This research provides data-driven evidence that the timing of reopening is a critical determinant of long-term economic health. While the "growth of the fitter" framework provides a robust theoretical basis for these findings, the authors note that empirical data for calibrating the exact rate of evolutionary change across different industries remains limited. Additionally, the model assumes policy stringency remains within historical bounds and does not account for future viral mutations or potential "vaccine fatigue."

Despite these limitations, the study underscores that for countries with high vaccine coverage, the economic risks of delayed reopening may far outweigh the marginal public health gains, potentially leading to a semi-permanent decline in global industrial competitiveness.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, many firms have been shifting their supply chains away from countries with stringent control measures to mitigate supply chain disruption. Nowadays, the global economy is reopening from the COVID-19 pandemic at various paces in different countries. Understanding how the global supply network evolves during and after the pandemic is necessary for determining the timing of reopening. By harnessing the real-world and real-time global human movement and the latest macroeconomic data, we propose an evolutionary epidemiological-economic model to explore the evolutionary dynamics of the global supply network under various global reopening scenarios. We find that the delay in full reopening in highly restrictive countries has limited public health benefits in the long run but leads to significant supply chain loss to less restrictive ones. Longer duration of stringent control measures leads to lower supply chain recovery in five years. The recovery rate varies across production sectors, depending on the characteristics of production, the degree of self-reliance, and the location of production hubs. This research presents the first data-driven evidence of supply chain loss due to the timing of reopening and sheds light on the post-pandemic supply chain reformation and recovery. Our results provide data-driven evidence that supports the reopening in countries with high vaccine coverage.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023supply,
  author = {Qingpeng Zhang and Yang Ye and Zhidong Cao and Daniel Zeng},
  title = {{Supply chain loss from easing COVID-19 restrictions: an evolutionary epidemiological-economic modeling study}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-2355650/v1},
}
Figure