Supplementary material to "Modeling the effects of tropospheric ozone on the growth and yield of global staple crops with DSSAT v4.8.0"

Jose Rafael Guarin, Jonas Jägermeyr, Elizabeth A. Ainsworth, Fabio A. A. Oliveira, Senthold Asseng, Kenneth J. Boote, Joshua Elliott, Lisa Emberson, Ian Foster, Gerrit Hoogenboom, David Kelly, Alex C. Ruane, Katrina Sharps2023 · DOI

Introduction

Tropospheric ozone ($O_3$) is a potent greenhouse gas and a toxic air pollutant that physically damages plant tissues, reducing photosynthesis and, ultimately, crop yields. Despite its significant impact, most global crop models have historically ignored $O_3$. This paper details the integration of $O_3$ sensitivity into the DSSAT (Decision Support System for Agrotechnology Transfer) v4.8.0 framework, enabling more accurate predictions for maize, rice, soybean, and wheat.

Methodology

The researchers updated four major models within DSSAT: CERES-Maize, CERES-Rice, CROPGRO-Soybean, and NWheat. The core of their approach involves two new sensitivity parameters:

  1. $FOZ_1$: The fraction of photosynthesis remaining at a specific $O_3$ threshold.
  2. $SFOZ_1$: The slope of the yield response to increasing $O_3$ concentrations.

A massive sensitivity analysis was performed, running simulations across a matrix of $O_3$ concentrations (0 to 120 ppb), $CO_2$ levels (350 vs. 550 ppm), and water regimes (normal "wet" vs. 50% reduced "dry" rainfall).

Table S2: Maize yield sensitivity to $SFOZ_1$ across varying ozone, CO2, and water regimes.

Datasets and Validation

The study draws on a robust combination of site-specific environmental data and a massive literature review:

  • Experimental Site Data: Soil profiles (Table S1) and weather data from key research sites: Champaign, IL; Stuttgart, AR; and Maricopa, AZ.
  • Cultivar Library: A comprehensive meta-analysis of $O_3$ response data for 131 distinct cultivars.
  • Validation Data: Results from FACE (Free-Air $CO_2$ Enrichment) and SoyFACE experiments were used to ensure the simulations matched real-world observations.

Key Insights

The "Drought Shield" and $CO_2$ Mitigation

One of the most significant findings is that $O_3$ damage is often less severe under dry conditions. When plants are water-stressed, they close their stomata to prevent moisture loss, which effectively "locks the door," preventing ozone from entering the leaf. Similarly, higher $CO_2$ concentrations (550 ppm) consistently mitigated yield losses from $O_3$ by inducing stomatal closure.

Genetic Variability

The sensitivity of different cultivars varies wildly. For instance, some wheat varieties are nearly three times more sensitive to ozone than others. This highlights a major opportunity for plant breeders to select for ozone-tolerant traits as a climate adaptation strategy.

Results

The supplementary tables provide a granular look at the "yield gap" created by ozone. For maize, under "wet" conditions at 350 ppm $CO_2$, increasing $O_3$ from 0 to 120 ppb can crash yields from ~9853 kg/ha to nearly zero if the cultivar is highly sensitive ($FOZ_1 = 1.0$).

Table S3: Maize yield sensitivity to $FOZ_1$ across varying ozone, CO2, and water regimes.

Conclusion

While the model is a significant leap forward, the authors note that it remains highly sensitive to the $FOZ_1$ and $SFOZ_1$ values, which are often derived from controlled chamber studies. Future improvements will require better high-resolution maps of actual tropospheric ozone concentrations and a more distinct decoupling of $O_3$ effects on biomass versus final grain yield.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{guarin2023supplementary,
  author = {Jose Rafael Guarin and Jonas Jägermeyr and Elizabeth A. Ainsworth and Fabio A. A. Oliveira and Senthold Asseng and Kenneth J. Boote and Joshua Elliott and Lisa Emberson and Ian Foster and Gerrit Hoogenboom and David Kelly and Alex C. Ruane and Katrina Sharps},
  title = {{Supplementary material to "Modeling the effects of tropospheric ozone on the growth and yield of global staple crops with DSSAT v4.8.0"}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/egusphere-2023-1540-supplement},
}
Figure