Supplementary material to "Mobile monitoring of urban air quality at high spatial resolution bylow-cost sensors: Impacts of COVID-19 pandemic lockdown"

Shibao Wang, Yun Ma, Zhongrui Wang, Lei Wang, Xuguang Chi, Aijun Ding, Mingzhi Yao, Yunpeng Li, Qilin Li, Mengxian Wu, Ling Zhang, Yongle Xiao, Yanxu Zhang2020 · DOI

Introduction

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated unprecedented lockdowns, creating a unique "natural experiment" to study the impact of reduced human activity on urban air quality. Traditional air quality monitoring networks, while precise, often lack the spatial density required to capture hyper-local variations in pollutant concentrations, such as those found in street canyons or at major intersections. This study utilizes mobile monitoring systems equipped with low-cost sensors (LCS) to bridge this spatial gap and provide a high-resolution analysis of how the lockdown transformed the chemical fingerprint of the urban atmosphere.

Methodology

The research employed mobile monitoring platforms to collect high-resolution spatial data for Carbon Monoxide (CO), Nitrogen Dioxide (NO₂), and Ozone (O₃). The analysis segmented data into three primary temporal categories: Pre-COVID, COVID-Lockdown, and Post-COVID. Furthermore, the data was categorized by day type (weekdays vs. weekends/holidays) and time of day (rush hour vs. non-rush hour). This multi-dimensional approach allowed for a robust comparison of diurnal cycles and spatial distributions across different stages of the pandemic.

Results and Discussion

Temporal Shifts and the Ozone Paradox

The most significant finding of the study is the divergent behavior of primary and secondary pollutants during the lockdown. As shown in Figure 1, concentrations of NO₂ and CO—pollutants directly tied to vehicular combustion—plummeted during the lockdown phase. Specifically, peak-hour NO₂ levels were approximately 50% lower than Pre-COVID levels.

Diurnal cycles of CO, NO₂, and O₃ across Pre-COVID, COVID-Lockdown, and Post-COVID periods, illustrating the 'Ozone Paradox'.

Conversely, O₃ levels exhibited a paradoxical increase during the lockdown. This phenomenon, often referred to as the "Ozone Paradox," is a result of altered titration effects in the urban atmosphere. Under normal conditions, high levels of Nitric Oxide (NO) from traffic react with and destroy O₃. The drastic reduction in traffic during the lockdown led to a decrease in NO, allowing O₃ to accumulate to higher levels than observed in the Pre-COVID period.

Spatial Heterogeneity and Hyper-local Mapping

Mobile monitoring revealed significant spatial variability that stationary networks often miss. Even during periods of overall lower pollution, certain urban corridors and intersections remained persistent hotspots.

High-resolution spatial map of CO concentrations on weekdays, showing the concentration of pollutants along major transit arteries.

As illustrated in Figure 2, pollution levels generally followed the city's major road network. The high-resolution mapping capability of the LCS systems allowed for the identification of specific areas where human exposure might remain high despite city-wide reductions. This spatial consistency suggests that while the magnitude of pollution changed during the lockdown, the underlying geographic drivers—primarily the road infrastructure—remained constant.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study demonstrates the power of mobile sensing for hyper-local environmental monitoring. While the lockdown drastically reduced traffic-related pollutants, the complex, non-linear chemistry of the urban atmosphere led to an increase in ozone, highlighting the challenges of urban air quality management.

Future work should focus on improving the calibration of low-cost sensors against environmental factors like temperature and humidity. Integrating this high-resolution spatial data with human mobility patterns will be crucial for developing more accurate models of personal pollutant exposure, moving beyond ambient air quality metrics to better protect public health.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2020supplementary,
  author = {Shibao Wang and Yun Ma and Zhongrui Wang and Lei Wang and Xuguang Chi and Aijun Ding and Mingzhi Yao and Yunpeng Li and Qilin Li and Mengxian Wu and Ling Zhang and Yongle Xiao and Yanxu Zhang},
  title = {{Supplementary material to "Mobile monitoring of urban air quality at high spatial resolution bylow-cost sensors: Impacts of COVID-19 pandemic lockdown"}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2020-1169-supplement},
}
Figure