Supplementary material to "Impacts of Meteorological Uncertainties on the Haze Formation in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) during Wintertime: A case study"

Naifang Bei, Jiarui Wu, Feng Tian, Junji Cao, Ru‐Jin Huang, Xin Long, Xing Li, Shuyu Zhao, Xuexi Tie, Guohui Li2017 · DOI

Introduction

Predicting severe particulate matter pollution, or "haze," in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) region is a complex challenge. While industrial and vehicular emissions are the primary drivers, the specific timing and intensity of these events are heavily influenced by meteorological conditions. Weather models, however, are inherently prone to small errors in initial atmospheric states, which can propagate and affect air quality forecasts. This study investigates the extent to which meteorological uncertainty contributes to errors in haze predictions.

Methodology

The researchers employed an ensemble modeling approach to quantify the sensitivity of chemical transport models to meteorological fluctuations. By running multiple simulations with slightly perturbed initial conditions, they calculated the "spread" or variance among model outputs for key variables, including wind components, temperature, relative humidity, and Planetary Boundary Layer (PBL) height.

A central metric used in this analysis is the Relative Ensemble Spread of Mass (RESM), which measures how much the predicted concentration of a specific chemical species (such as PM2.5, SO2, or NO2) varies due to meteorological "noise." The study focused on a severe haze episode occurring between January 13 and 20, 2014, across major urban centers in the BTH region.

Synoptic Weather Patterns and Consistency

To isolate the impact of small-scale meteorological fluctuations, it was first necessary to ensure that the broad synoptic weather patterns remained consistent across the ensemble members.

Evolution of geopotential height and wind vectors at the surface from January 13 to January 20, 2014, illustrating the synoptic conditions during the haze episode.

As shown in the figure above, the geopotential heights and wind vectors at the surface level demonstrate the evolution of the weather system during the study period. The consistency in these large-scale patterns across the ensemble allows for a focused analysis of how smaller uncertainties in variables like wind speed and PBL height ripple through the chemical transport model.

Key Findings

The Amplification of Secondary Aerosols

One of the most significant insights is that meteorological uncertainty does not affect all pollutants equally. Secondary aerosols, such as nitrate and Secondary Organic Aerosols (SOA), exhibit much higher sensitivity to weather fluctuations than primary pollutants. In some instances, the RESM for these species exceeded 150%, suggesting that the complex chemical reactions involved in their formation act as an amplifier for meteorological errors.

PBL Height as a Critical Variable

The Planetary Boundary Layer (PBL) height is a major source of uncertainty. Since the PBL defines the volume of air in which pollutants are trapped, even minor variations in its predicted height can lead to substantial changes in ground-level PM2.5 concentrations. The ensemble spread for PBL height showed significant spikes, highlighting its role as a "wildcard" in air quality modeling.

Spatial and Temporal Sensitivity

The impact of meteorological uncertainty varies by location and time. PM2.5 predictions in Beijing showed different sensitivity patterns compared to Shijiazhuang, likely due to local topography and the interaction of weather systems with the surrounding mountains. Furthermore, the greatest uncertainty often coincided with meteorological "turning points," such as shifts in wind direction or the arrival of cold fronts.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that meteorological uncertainty is a significant factor in air quality forecasting, with the RESM for PM2.5 typically ranging between 10% and 30% during peak haze periods. However, for specific components like nitrate, this uncertainty can be much higher. While this case study provides valuable insights into winter haze in the BTH region, future research is needed to explore these sensitivities during other seasons and to consider the combined impact of uncertainties in both meteorology and emission inventories.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{bei2017supplementary,
  author = {Naifang Bei and Jiarui Wu and Feng Tian and Junji Cao and Ru‐Jin Huang and Xin Long and Xing Li and Shuyu Zhao and Xuexi Tie and Guohui Li},
  title = {{Supplementary material to "Impacts of Meteorological Uncertainties on the Haze Formation in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) during Wintertime: A case study"}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2017-698-supplement},
}
Figure