Supplementary material to "Exploring wintertime regional haze in Northeast China: role of coal and biomass burning"

Jian Zhang, Lei Liu, Liang Xu, Qiuhan Lin, Hujia Zhao, Zhibin Wang, Song Guo, Min Hu, Zongbo Shi, Dantong Liu, Dao Huang, Weijun Li2020 · DOI

Introduction

Northeast China faces unique air quality challenges during winter, driven by a combination of heavy industrial activity, intense coal-based residential heating, and seasonal biomass burning. While the North China Plain (NCP) is well-studied, this region experiences extreme pollution events—with PM$_{2.5}$ concentrations occasionally exceeding 1000 µg/m³—that require granular investigation. This study characterizes the chemical "fingerprints" of these events to distinguish between varying emission sources and meteorological drivers.

Methods

The research employed a multi-faceted approach combining field observations with advanced laboratory analysis:

  • Single-Particle Analysis: Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) was used to analyze individual particles, establishing correlations between physical dimensions and morphology.
  • Chemical Classification: Particles were categorized into types such as fly ash, soot, mineral dust, organic matter (OM), and potassium-rich organic matter (K-OM), which serves as a tracer for biomass burning.
  • Meteorological & Trajectory Modeling: Wind speed, direction, temperature, and relative humidity were monitored at urban (Shenyang) and mountain sites. 24-hour backward trajectories traced the geographic origins of air masses.
  • Bulk Chemical Ratios: The organic-to-elemental carbon (OC/EC) ratio was used to distinguish between primary combustion sources and secondary aerosol formation.

Results and Discussion

Regional Haze Evolution

The study period in late 2016 witnessed a rapid transition from "Excellent" air quality to "Severe haze pollution" across Northeast China. The pollution intensified significantly between October 31 and November 4, impacting major urban centers including Harbin, Changchun, and Shenyang.

Evolution of regional haze pollution levels in Northeast China from October 31 to November 4, 2016.

Classification of Haze Episodes

Researchers identified two distinct haze types based on pollution intensity and chemical signatures:

  • Haze-I: Characterized by moderate pollution levels and a chemical signature consistent with coal burning.
  • Haze-II: A "heavy" haze event dominated by biomass burning markers. During Haze-II, the fraction of K-rich organic matter (K-OM) increased significantly across almost all particle size bins (100–2500 nm), indicating that crop residue burning is a primary driver of the most severe pollution episodes.
Meteorological parameters (wind, temperature, RH, pressure) at urban and mountain sites, categorized by haze type (Clean, Haze-I, and Haze-II).

Meteorological data indicates that stagnant conditions—low wind speeds and high relative humidity—facilitated the accumulation of pollutants during these episodes.

Chemical Signatures and Vertical Distribution

A defining characteristic of Haze-II was the exceptionally high OC/EC ratios, reaching 25.4 at the urban site and 27.9 at the mountain site. These values are significantly higher than the 4.5–5.5 range typically observed in the North China Plain, underscoring the massive influx of organic carbon from biomass. Comparison between sites revealed higher OC/EC ratios at the mountain site, suggesting a higher proportion of aged or secondary aerosols at higher altitudes within the boundary layer.

Conclusion

The findings highlight that while coal-to-gas transitions are vital, controlling seasonal biomass burning is equally critical for mitigating extreme "heavy haze" events in Northeast China. The unique chemical signatures identified—particularly the high OC/EC ratios and K-OM prevalence—provide a roadmap for targeted regional air quality management.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2020supplementary,
  author = {Jian Zhang and Lei Liu and Liang Xu and Qiuhan Lin and Hujia Zhao and Zhibin Wang and Song Guo and Min Hu and Zongbo Shi and Dantong Liu and Dao Huang and Weijun Li},
  title = {{Supplementary material to "Exploring wintertime regional haze in Northeast China: role of coal and biomass burning"}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2019-1025-supplement},
}
Figure