Supplementary material to "The 4.2 ka event in East Asian monsoon region, precisely reconstructed by multi-proxies of stalagmite"

Chao‐Jun Chen, Daoxian Yuan, Jun‐Yun Li, Xianfeng Wang, Hai Cheng, Youfeng Ning, R. Lawrence Edwards, Wu Yao, Si-Ya Xiao, Yuzhen Xu, Yangyang Huang, Haiying Qiu, Jian Zhang, Mingqiang Liang, Ting‐Yong Li2021 · DOI

Abstract

There was significant correlation at the level of 0.05. This study provides a high-resolution, multi-proxy reconstruction of the 4.2 ka event using stalagmite YK1306 from Yangkou Cave, China. By synchronizing stable isotopes with trace element ratios, we identify a distinct three-stage climatic shift in the East Asian Monsoon region, providing a robust benchmark for understanding this ancient climate anomaly.

Introduction

The 4.2 ka event, occurring approximately 4,200 years ago, is one of the most significant Holocene climate disruptions, often linked to the collapse of ancient civilizations such as the Liangzhu culture in China. Characterizing this event in the East Asian Monsoon (ASM) region has been challenging due to dating uncertainties and low temporal resolution in many existing records. This research addresses these gaps by providing a synchronized multi-proxy record from a single stalagmite, offering a high-resolution benchmark for understanding the event's internal structure and regional impact.

Methods

The study analyzed stalagmite YK1306 from Yangkou (YK) Cave. The methodology integrated several geochemical proxies:

  • Stable Isotopes ($\delta^{18}O$ and $\delta^{13}C$): $\delta^{18}O$ reflects monsoon intensity, while $\delta^{13}C$ tracks changes in overlying vegetation and soil microbial activity.
  • Trace Element Ratios (Mg/Ca, Sr/Ca, Ba/Ca): These ratios are sensitive to local hydrological conditions through Prior Calcite Precipitation (PCP).
  • Principal Component Analysis (PC1): PC1 was calculated from trace element data to create a robust "master" record of local dryness.
  • Statistical Correlation: Z-score normalization and linear interpolation were employed to compare proxies on a unified timeline and validate findings against regional records.

Results

Multi-Proxy Synchronization

The YK1306 record demonstrates an exceptionally high correlation between $\delta^{18}O$ and $\delta^{13}C$ ($r = 0.96$), confirming that monsoon intensity and local environmental conditions were perfectly in sync. Trace element ratios (Ba/Ca, Sr/Ca, and Mg/Ca) also show strong positive correlations, particularly between Ba/Ca and Sr/Ca, providing high confidence in the identified dry periods.

Multi-proxy records of stalagmite YK1306 vs. depth, highlighting the three distinct stages (I, II, III) of the 4.2 ka event.

The Three-Stage Structure

A defining feature of the 4.2 ka event in this record is its distinct three-stage structure (labeled I, II, and III). This suggests the climate transition was a structured process rather than an abrupt shift. These stages are evident between 30mm and 60mm in depth, corresponding to the period between ~3900 and ~4500 years BP.

Regional Alignment

Comparison with other major ASM stalagmite records—including Dongge, Xianglong, and Shengnong caves—shows general alignment despite slight dating errors. This coherence suggests the 4.2 ka event was a large-scale, synchronized phenomenon across East Asia.

Comparison of the YK1306 record with other regional stalagmite records, demonstrating the coherent three-stage structure across East Asia.

Discussion and Conclusion

The multi-proxy analysis of stalagmite YK1306 provides a robust framework for understanding the 4.2 ka event in the ASM region. The high correlation between proxies (significant at the 0.05 level) underscores the event's complexity and its three-stage progression. While dating precision remains a factor for future refinement, these findings offer critical insights into the hydrological mechanisms of this ancient mega-drought and its potential role in historical societal changes. Future work will focus on using these high-resolution stages to further test climate models and determine the causal drivers of these dramatic monsoon shifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

There was significant correlation at the level of 0.05.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2021supplementary,
  author = {Chao‐Jun Chen and Daoxian Yuan and Jun‐Yun Li and Xianfeng Wang and Hai Cheng and Youfeng Ning and R. Lawrence Edwards and Wu Yao and Si-Ya Xiao and Yuzhen Xu and Yangyang Huang and Haiying Qiu and Jian Zhang and Mingqiang Liang and Ting‐Yong Li},
  title = {{Supplementary material to \"The 4.2 ka event in East Asian monsoon region, precisely reconstructed by multi-proxies of stalagmite\"}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5194/cp-2021-20-supplement},
}
Figure