Supplementary material to "Aggravated Air Pollution and Health Burden due to Traffic Congestion in Urban China"

Peng Wang, Ruhan Zhang, Shida Sun, Meng Gao, Bo Zheng, Dan Zhang, Yangli Zhang, Gregory R. Carmichael, Hongliang Zhang2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study quantifies the impact of traffic congestion on urban air quality and public health in 22 major Chinese cities. By integrating high-resolution TomTom traffic data with the Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) modeling system, researchers demonstrate that "stop-and-go" traffic acts as a significant force multiplier for emissions. Accounting for real-world congestion levels reveals substantial increases in $NO_x$, VOCs, and CO emissions, leading to thousands of additional premature deaths from respiratory and cardiovascular diseases. The findings underscore the necessity of incorporating traffic flow management into urban environmental policies.

Introduction

Urban air quality management traditionally relies on "bottom-up" emission inventories that utilize average traffic volumes and speeds. However, real-world traffic is characterized by significant fluctuations, particularly during peak commute hours. When vehicles operate in heavy congestion, engines function less efficiently, resulting in significantly higher emission factors per kilometer compared to free-flow conditions. This "congestion effect" often leads to an underestimation of the true health burden of urban traffic in standard models. This study addresses this gap by applying speed-dependent emission correction factors to assess the air quality and health impacts across 22 key Chinese cities, including megacities like Beijing and Shanghai.

Methods and Data

The researchers employed a multi-stage modeling framework to link real-time traffic behavior to health outcomes:

  1. Emission Correction Factors: Speed-dependent multipliers were applied to standard inventories. For instance, CO emissions were modeled to be over four times higher at speeds below 20 km/h than at speeds above 40 km/h.
  2. CMAQ Modeling: The Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) system simulated the atmospheric chemistry and transport of $PM_{2.5}$, $O_3$, $NO_2$, and $CO$.
  3. Scenario Comparison: The study compared a BASE case (standard emissions) against CASE 2 (emissions adjusted for real-world congestion).
  4. Health Impact Assessment: Premature mortality for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD), Ischemic Heart Disease (IHD), Lung Cancer (LC), and Cerebrovascular Disease (CEVD) was calculated using concentration-response functions.
Figure 1: (a) Study regions including the North China Plain (NCP), Yangtze River Delta (YRD), Pearl River Delta (PRD), and Sichuan Basin (SCB) with 22 major cities; (b) Spatial distribution of adjusted anthropogenic emissions.

The study utilized 2020 TomTom traffic data to derive hourly diurnal profiles for the target cities. Meteorological data and observations from the National Air Quality Monitoring Network were used to validate the CMAQ simulations, ensuring they accurately reflected 2020 conditions.

Results

The Congestion Penalty

The analysis reveals a non-linear relationship between vehicle speed and pollution. Dropping from free-flow speeds to heavy congestion (<20 km/h) more than quadruples the emission rates for pollutants like CO and NMVOCs. Consequently, the CASE 2 scenario showed significantly higher annual average anthropogenic emissions, particularly in densely populated regions like the North China Plain and Yangtze River Delta.

Temporal and Spatial Hotspots

Congestion does not just increase the volume of pollution; it shifts its timing. Distinct morning and evening peaks in $NO_2$ and CO align precisely with workday commute times, creating localized "hotspots" of high exposure.

Figure 2: Diurnal profiles of congestion levels across different days of the week, highlighting the morning and evening peaks on workdays compared to the flatter weekend profile.

The "weekend effect" further validates the model's sensitivity: traffic patterns shift significantly on Saturdays and Sundays, with the morning peak nearly disappearing. This temporal variation is critical for accurate exposure assessment.

Health Burden in Megacities

The health burden is disproportionately concentrated in megacities. These areas suffer from a "double penalty": they experience the highest levels of congestion and possess the highest population densities. The study's health impact assessment indicates that thousands of premature deaths are specifically attributable to the additional pollution generated by traffic delays.

Discussion and Conclusion

The results demonstrate that traffic congestion is a major contributor to urban air pollution and associated health risks in China. The study suggests that "green" transportation policies should expand their focus beyond tailpipe standards to include active traffic flow management. Improving traffic efficiency may be as effective for public health as large-scale vehicle fleet upgrades.

Limitations of the study include the use of 2020 data, which may reflect unique pandemic-related traffic patterns, and the use of generalized correction factors across different vehicle types. Future research should refine these factors by accounting for specific vehicle fleet compositions and post-pandemic "normal" traffic conditions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2022supplementary,
  author = {Peng Wang and Ruhan Zhang and Shida Sun and Meng Gao and Bo Zheng and Dan Zhang and Yangli Zhang and Gregory R. Carmichael and Hongliang Zhang},
  title = {{Supplementary material to "Aggravated Air Pollution and Health Burden due to Traffic Congestion in Urban China"}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2022-577-supplement},
}
Figure