Supersymmetry and Electroweak Breaking in the Interval

David Diego Castro, Gero von Gersdorff, Mariano QuirosOpenReview 2025 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper explores how supersymmetry breaking and electroweak symmetry breaking can arise in a five-dimensional spacetime with a compactified interval. By dynamically determining boundary conditions, they identify new sources of supersymmetry breaking beyond the standard Scherk-Schwarz mechanism, leading to tree-level electroweak symmetry breaking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics, while incredibly successful, doesn't explain phenomena like the hierarchy problem (why the Higgs mass is so much smaller than the Planck scale) or the unification of fundamental forces. Supersymmetry (SUSY) is a theoretical framework that proposes a symmetry between bosons and fermions, which could help address these issues and provide a path towards a unified theory. However, SUSY must be broken at some energy scale to match observations.

This paper investigates how SUSY breaking and electroweak symmetry breaking (the mechanism that gives mass to fundamental particles) can occur in a specific theoretical setup: a five-dimensional spacetime where one dimension is compactified into an interval. Unlike previous approaches that imposed rigid boundary conditions, this work allows boundary conditions to be determined dynamically by the theory's action. This flexibility opens up new avenues for understanding how SUSY is broken and how electroweak symmetry breaking can be triggered at low energies, potentially offering solutions to the hierarchy problem.

Methods

The authors employ a "downstairs" approach to model physics in a 5D interval, where fields are continuous and boundary conditions are derived from the action principle. This contrasts with the "upstairs" orbifold approach, which uses fixed points and imposed boundary conditions. They focus on hypermultiplets, which contain both scalar (Higgs-like) and fermionic (Higgsino-like) fields, as these are crucial for electroweak symmetry breaking.

Key techniques include:

  • Action Principle for Boundary Conditions: Instead of fixing boundary conditions beforehand, they are derived from the variation of the action, allowing for more general scenarios.
  • Real Hypermultiplets: They work with real representations of hypermultiplets, which simplifies calculations while capturing the same degrees of freedom as complex ones.
  • Bulk and Boundary Terms: The total action is split into contributions from the bulk of the 5D interval and from the boundaries.
  • Mode Decomposition: Fields are decomposed into 4D mass eigenstates and 5D wave functions, allowing for the analysis of mass spectra.
  • Symmetry Analysis: They carefully analyze the conditions for supersymmetry to hold and identify how deviations from these conditions lead to breaking.
  • Comparison with Orbifold Approach: They show how their formalism can reproduce results from the more standard orbifold approach, validating their method.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamically Determined Boundary Conditions: The core innovation is allowing boundary conditions to arise naturally from the action, rather than being imposed. This leads to a richer set of possibilities for supersymmetry breaking.
  • New Sources of Supersymmetry Breaking: Beyond the standard Scherk-Schwarz (SS) mechanism (interpreted as a misalignment of boundary conditions), they identify a new source arising from a mismatch in boundary parameters for hyperscalars.
  • Tree-Level Electroweak Symmetry Breaking: For specific parameter choices, electroweak symmetry breaking can occur at the tree level, meaning it doesn't require quantum corrections to manifest. This is a significant result for model building.
  • Supersoft Breaking: Scherk-Schwarz breaking is "supersoft" (finite), meaning it doesn't lead to problematic divergences at higher energy scales. However, breaking from boundary hyperscalar masses can have different characteristics.
  • Connection to Higgs Mass: The framework provides a mechanism for generating a Higgs mass that can be decoupled from the compactification scale, potentially helping with the hierarchy problem.

Key Results

  • They derive a general supersymmetric action for hypermultiplets in a 5D interval.
  • They explicitly solve the equations of motion and obtain mass eigenvalues and eigenfunctions for both bosonic (scalar) and fermionic (fermion) sectors.
  • They demonstrate how deviations from supersymmetric boundary conditions lead to supersymmetry breaking.
  • They show that for certain parameter regimes, electroweak symmetry breaking can be triggered at the tree level, with the Higgs mass being related to parameters like the interval size and boundary masses.
  • They analyze specific cases, including those that can reproduce results from the orbifold approach and lead to vectorlike fermions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Phenomenological Constraints: While the paper explores theoretical possibilities, a detailed phenomenological analysis (e.g., comparing with experimental bounds on particle masses) is left for future work.
  • Higher-Order Corrections: The paper focuses on tree-level and one-loop effects. Investigating higher-order radiative corrections and their impact on stability and electroweak breaking is suggested.
  • Model Embedding: The paper considers a single hypermultiplet and a U(1) gauge group for simplicity in some sections. Embedding the full Standard Model gauge group (SU(2)L x U(1)Y) and considering multiple hypermultiplets is a natural next step.
  • Cosmological Implications: The paper briefly mentions the radion stabilization via Casimir energy and the potential for solving the fermion mass problem, suggesting these are areas for further investigation.
  • Nature of Breaking: While the paper distinguishes between Scherk-Schwarz breaking and breaking by boundary masses, a deeper understanding of the "softness" and implications of the latter is still desired.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hypermultiplets are considered in the five-dimensional interval where all fields are continuous and the boundary conditions are dynamically obtained from the action principle. The orbifold boundary conditions are obtained as particular cases. We can interpret the Scherk-Schwarz supersymmetry breaking as a misalignment of boundary conditions while a new source of supersymmetry breaking corresponding to a mismatch of different boundary parameters is identified. The latter can be viewed as coming from boundary supersymmetry breaking masses for hyperscalars and the nature of the corresponding supersymmetry breaking parameter is analyzed. For some regions of the parameter space where supersymmetry is broken (either by Scherk-Schwarz boundary conditions or by boundary hyperscalar masses) electroweak symmetry breaking can be triggered at the tree level.
BibTeX
@misc{castro2025supersymmetry,
  author = {David Diego Castro and Gero von Gersdorff and Mariano Quiros},
  title = {{Supersymmetry and Electroweak Breaking in the Interval}},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=3WPuZjVuLH},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}
Figure