Superradiant instabilities of asymptotically anti-de Sitter black holes

Stephen Green, Stefan Hollands, Akihiro Ishibashi, Robert M. WaldClassical 2016 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper proves that any asymptotically anti-de Sitter (AdS) black hole with an "ergoregion"—a zone where the horizon's rotation is so fast that even light must move with it—is inherently unstable. By combining the "canonical energy" stability criterion with high-frequency WKB wave constructions, the authors demonstrate that these black holes inevitably trigger a runaway "black hole bomb" effect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In general relativity, proving that a black hole is stable (or unstable) is notoriously difficult. The standard approach involves "mode analysis"—solving the linearized Einstein equations to see if any perturbations grow exponentially over time. While this works for simple cases like the 4D Kerr metric, it becomes mathematically intractable in higher dimensions or in more complex spacetime geometries.

The authors focus on asymptotically anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetimes. Unlike our flat universe, AdS space has a negative cosmological constant, effectively acting like a "box" with a reflecting boundary at infinity. When a rotating black hole sits in this box, a phenomenon called superradiance occurs: waves reflecting off the black hole can actually gain energy. In flat space, these waves would just fly away. In AdS, they hit the "walls" of the universe and bounce back, hitting the black hole again and again. This creates a feedback loop known as the "black hole bomb."

The gap addressed here is providing a rigorous, general proof that this instability exists for any AdS black hole with an ergoregion, regardless of its specific symmetry or the number of dimensions ($d \ge 4$).

Methods

The authors sidestep the nightmare of solving full evolution equations by using the Canonical Energy Method ($\mathcal{E}$), a framework previously developed by Hollands and Wald.

  1. Stability Criterion: If you can find a valid initial perturbation with negative canonical energy ($\mathcal{E} < 0$), the system is unstable. Because energy must be conserved and the flux through the horizon is positive, a negative-energy perturbation can never "settle down" to a stable state.
  2. WKB Approximation: To find such a perturbation, the authors use the WKB (Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin) method to construct high-frequency gravitational wave packets. These packets are designed to mimic a test particle with negative energy, which is only possible inside an ergoregion (where the horizon Killing field becomes spacelike).
  3. Corvino-Schoen Technique: A major hurdle in GR is that you can't just "place" a wave packet anywhere; it must satisfy the Einstein constraint equations (the "initial data" must be physically valid). The authors use the Corvino-Schoen technique to "glue" their approximate WKB wave packet into a globally valid, exact solution of the constraints without losing the crucial negative-energy property.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a work of theoretical mathematical physics, this paper relies on analytical proofs and geometric constructions rather than numerical simulations or empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The AdS Advantage: In asymptotically flat space, proving instability is harder because energy can escape to infinity. In AdS, the "reflecting" boundary conditions mean the only place energy can go is through the horizon. This simplifies the stability requirements: you only need a single Killing field normal to the horizon.
  • Ergoregions at Infinity: Interestingly, in AdS spacetimes, ergoregions don't just happen near the horizon; they can occur near the boundary at infinity.
  • No Axisymmetry Needed: Unlike previous proofs for flat space that required perturbations to be axisymmetric (aligned with the rotation), this proof works for any smooth perturbation.
  • The Particle-Wave Bridge: The "aha moment" is showing that if a point particle can have negative energy in a region (a well-known result), then a sufficiently high-frequency gravitational wave can be constructed to do the same while still obeying the complex constraints of General Relativity.

Key Results

  • Theorem 1: The paper’s central result. It formally states that if an asymptotically AdS black hole has an ergoregion, there exists a perturbation with $\mathcal{E} < 0$, rendering the black hole unstable.
  • Broad Applicability: This result confirms the instability of Kerr-AdS black holes (above the Hawking-Reall bound) and the recently discovered "black resonator" solutions.
  • Dimension Independence: The proof holds for all spacetime dimensions $d \ge 4$, providing a universal tool for higher-dimensional gravity studies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The "What Happens Next?" Problem: The canonical energy method proves that an instability exists, but it doesn't describe the end state. It remains unknown if the black hole eventually sheds its angular momentum to become stable or if the spacetime undergoes a more violent transition.
  • Vacuum Constraints: The primary proof assumes vacuum Einstein gravity. While the authors suggest extensions to include matter fields (like electromagnetic or scalar fields) should be straightforward, those were not explicitly detailed in the main theorem.
  • Charged Black Holes: The authors briefly discuss charged (Reissner-Nordström-AdS) black holes. They note that the WKB method is less effective here because the charge-to-mass ratio of a wave packet vanishes at high frequencies, meaning the "generalized ergoregion" for particles doesn't perfectly translate to wave instability in the same way. This suggests a need for different techniques for the charged case.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the linear stability of asymptotically anti-de Sitter black holes in general relativity in spacetime dimension $d\ge4$. Our approach is an adaptation of the general framework of Hollands and Wald, which gives a stability criterion in terms of the sign of the canonical energy, $\mathcal{E}$. The general framework was originally formulated for static or stationary and axisymmetric black holes in the asymptotically flat case, and the stability analysis for that case applies only to axisymmetric perturbations. However, in the asymptotically anti-de Sitter case, the stability analysis requires only that the black hole have a single Killing field normal to the horizon and there are no restrictions on the perturbations (apart from smoothness and appropriate behavior at infinity). For an asymptotically anti-de Sitter black hole, we define an ergoregion to be a region where the horizon Killing field is spacelike; such a region, if present, would normally occur near infinity. We show that for black holes with ergoregions, initial data can be constructed such that $\mathcal{E}<0$, so all such black holes are unstable. To obtain such initial data, we first construct an approximate solution to the constraint equations using the WKB method, and then we use the Corvino-Schoen technique to obtain an exact solution. We also discuss the case of charged asymptotically anti-de Sitter black holes with generalized ergoregions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{green2016superradiant,
  author = {Stephen Green and Stefan Hollands and Akihiro Ishibashi and Robert M. Wald},
  title = {{Superradiant instabilities of asymptotically anti-de Sitter black holes}},
  booktitle = {Classical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1088/0264-9381/33/12/125022},
}
Figure