Superoxide formation in Li2VO2F cathode material – a combined computational and experimental investigation of anionic redox activity

Jin Hyun Chang, Christian Baur, Jean-Marcel Ateba, Denis Arčon, Gregor Mali, Dorothea Alwast, R. Jürgen Behm, Maximilian Fichtner, Tejs Vegge, J. M. García‐LastraJournal of Materials Chemistry A 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This work reports new insights and understanding of anionic redox activities in Li-rich cathode materials during electrochemical cycling based on computational and experimental analyses. By combining density functional theory (DFT) and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, we demonstrate that $Li_2VO_2F$ cathodes trigger anionic redox—forming peroxides and superoxides—at a relatively low potential of 4.1 V. The study reveals that superoxide formation is partially irreversible and inextricably linked to vanadium dissolution, providing a clear mechanistic explanation for the capacity fading observed in these promising Li-rich disordered rocksalt (DRS) materials.

Introduction

To advance the energy density of lithium-ion batteries, researchers are increasingly focusing on "Li-rich" cathode materials. Unlike conventional cathodes that rely solely on transition metal (TM) redox, these materials utilize anionic redox, where oxygen ions participate in electron exchange. However, oxygen redox is often associated with structural instability, oxygen gas evolution, and rapid performance decay. Disordered rocksalt oxyfluorides, such as $Li_2VO_2F$, are of particular interest because fluorine substitution can potentially stabilize the lattice. This study addresses the fundamental lack of understanding regarding the specific oxygen species (peroxides vs. superoxides) that form during cycling, their activation voltages, and the reversibility of these reactions.

Methodology

The research employed a "closed-loop" approach, bridging theoretical predictions with experimental validation:

  • Computational Modeling: 650 DFT calculations were performed to train a Cluster Expansion (CE) model, enabling the simulation of complex, disordered $Li_xVO_2F$ structures. Metropolis Monte Carlo simulations were used to generate voltage profiles and identify minimum-energy configurations.
  • Spectroscopy: Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) was utilized to detect unpaired electrons in superoxides ($O_2^-$). Additionally, $^6Li$ and $^{51}V$ Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) probed the local chemical environment and magnetic properties of the pristine material.
  • Chemical Analysis: Inductive Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-OES) quantified vanadium dissolution into the electrolyte across multiple cycles.

Key Insights and Results

Low-Voltage Anionic Activation

A significant finding is that superoxides form at just 4.1 V. In many other Li-rich oxides, anionic redox typically activates at 4.5 V or higher. This indicates that $Li_2VO_2F$ accesses its additional capacity much earlier than anticipated.

Sequential Oxidation and Irreversibility

Computational results showed that anionic redox progresses sequentially from peroxide ($O_2^{2-}$) starting at $x \approx 1.4$ to superoxide ($O_2^-$) starting at $x \approx 0.8$. EPR spectra of the discharged material (1.3 V) revealed residual traces of superoxides, proving that the reaction is not fully reversible, which contributes directly to capacity fade.

The Degradation Feedback Loop

The study proposes a "runaway" mechanism for capacity loss: vanadium dissolution creates lattice vacancies that facilitate the diffusion and eventual escape of peroxides and superoxides as oxygen gas. This oxygen loss further destabilizes the vanadium, leading to increased dissolution. ICP-OES confirmed that V-loss is voltage-dependent; charging to 4.5 V resulted in nearly 15% vanadium loss after only 7 cycles.

Metastability and Magnetism

DFT analysis shows that while the ground state of $Li_2VO_2F$ is a layered structure, high-energy ball milling traps the material in a metastable disordered rocksalt phase. Furthermore, the pristine material was found to be diamagnetic, providing a silent background for EPR that allowed for the clear detection and quantification of subsequent superoxide signals.

Conclusion

This investigation clarifies the role of superoxide formation in the degradation of $Li_2VO_2F$ cathodes. The coupling of vanadium dissolution with irreversible oxygen redox identifies a primary hurdle for the commercialization of disordered rocksalt materials. Future work should focus on suppressing vanadium dissolution through strategies such as high-concentration electrolytes or atomic layer deposition (ALD) coatings to stabilize the electrode-electrolyte interface and unlock the full potential of anionic redox.

Summary updated

Abstract

This work reports new insights and understanding of anionic redox activities in Li-rich cathode materials during electrochemical cycling based on computational and experimental analyses.
BibTeX
@article{chang2020superoxide,
  author = {Jin Hyun Chang and Christian Baur and Jean-Marcel Ateba and Denis Arčon and Gregor Mali and Dorothea Alwast and R. Jürgen Behm and Maximilian Fichtner and Tejs Vegge and J. M. García‐Lastra},
  title = {{Superoxide formation in Li<sub>2</sub>VO<sub>2</sub>F cathode material – a combined computational and experimental investigation of anionic redox activity}},
  journal = {Journal of Materials Chemistry A},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1039/d0ta06119k},
}
Figure